Don't HR Alone · Episode 5

No Call, No Show: Did they Quit? Or are they Fired?

December 6, 20238 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal

An employee stops showing up and stops answering. Is that a resignation, or does the employer now have to fire them? The answer matters, because a termination is a more fraught process than a resignation. In this episode, Rhamy explains what counts as job abandonment and how to handle it.

Rhamy defines job abandonment as an employee not showing up, with no intention of returning and, importantly, without communication. Job abandonment is treated as a resignation rather than a firing, but only when the employer follows its own rules. Many organizations use a three consecutive day rule, though some choose five days. The number is the employer's to set, and Rhamy's point is that if the policy does not define job abandonment, the employer basically cannot use it. The policy also has to be applied consistently, since doing something different from what is written can undermine it.

Before acting, Rhamy recommends leading with empathy and always reaching out first, since an absence may be caused by a crisis the employer knows nothing about. He shares an example of an employee who went silent after an emergency involving flooding and evacuation and returned a week later.

When an absence does meet the policy, the episode closes with the paperwork: record the last day worked, set the termination date the policy specifies, and handle notices such as COBRA and insurance.

Key takeaways

  • Define job abandonment in a written policy, including how many consecutive no-call, no-show days it takes.
  • Apply the policy the same way every time, because inconsistent practice can undermine it.
  • Reach out to the employee before treating an absence as abandonment, since there may be an emergency you do not know about.
  • Record the employee's last day present as soon as an unexplained absence begins.
  • State in the policy which day becomes the separation date, such as the last allowed absence day or the day after.
  • Send the required notices, including COBRA and insurance notifications, when the separation is processed.

What is job abandonment?

Job abandonment is when an employee stops showing up for work, with no intention of returning, and without communicating with the employer. In this episode, Rhamy stresses that the lack of communication is the important part. An employee who calls in sick or explains an emergency is absent, not abandoning the job.

The distinction matters because job abandonment is treated as a resignation, a voluntary separation, rather than a firing. Rhamy explains that an involuntary termination is a more fraught process: there can be questions about whether it was handled correctly, whether it was for an illegal reason, or whether it broke a contract or promise. For a termination for cause, such as poor attendance, the employer may need to show the employee failed in their job duties. A clearly defined abandonment policy gives the employer a way to treat a true walk-off as the resignation it is.

How many no-call, no-show days before it counts as job abandonment?

It depends on the employer's policy. In this episode, Rhamy explains that many organizations use a three consecutive day rule: if an employee is absent for three days without any contact, it is considered job abandonment. Others choose five days. Neither number is set in stone.

What matters is that the employer sets the number in writing. Rhamy's point is that the definition of abandonment depends on the company's policies, so if the policy does not define it, the employer basically cannot use it. A clear rule protects both the company and its employees by showing in advance when an absence will be treated as a resignation. The employer also has to apply it consistently. If the written policy says three days but managers routinely wait longer or act sooner, that practice can invalidate the policy.

Should I contact an employee who stops showing up before ending their employment?

Yes, always. In this episode, Rhamy says to lead with empathy and reach out before taking any administrative action. An employee who suddenly goes silent may be dealing with a crisis the employer knows nothing about.

He shares an example from People Processes. A dedicated employee suddenly dropped off the grid. Rather than jump to conclusions, the company reached out and learned the employee had faced an unexpected emergency involving flooding and evacuation. The employee returned a week later, grateful for the understanding. A single phone call can prevent a costly misunderstanding and the loss of a good employee.

If the employer has made genuine attempts to reach the person and the absence still meets the policy's definition of abandonment, it can then move forward with the separation.

What is the termination date for job abandonment?

Whatever date your policy specifies, which is why the policy should spell it out. In this episode, Rhamy points out that the termination date is not always the day after the last allowed absence. With a five-day rule, for example, the separation date could be the sixth day, or it could be set back to the fifth day. That distinction can seem trivial but can matter in certain legal or administrative situations.

When processing a job abandonment, Rhamy recommends precision:

  1. Record the last day the employee was present.
  2. Set a termination date that follows the company's job abandonment policy.
  3. Complete the formalities, including COBRA notifications, insurance notifications and other required steps.

Clear policies, a compassionate approach and careful documentation make these situations easier to handle.

About this episode

Is it job abandonment or something else?🕵️♂️ Job Abandonment is when an employee doesn’t show up, with no intention of returning, and importantly, without communication. Join Rhamy Alejeal in unraveling the mystery of Job Abandonment. When does absence become abandonment, and how should businesses navigate this challenging territory? From defining policies to the compassionate approach and legal intricacies, this podcast episode provides a comprehensive guide. Let's navigate the complexities of HR together!