Don't HR Alone · Episode 78
DISC Won't Tell You Who to Hire (The Truth About Personality Tests in Recruiting)
Many owners want to add DISC or another personality assessment to their hiring process, hoping it will show who fits the job. In this episode, Rhamy explains why he told a client not to do it, and what to use instead.
DISC traces back to a 1928 book, Emotions of Normal People, by William Moulton Marston, who described how people express emotions but never built or validated a test. The questionnaires sold today came decades later and are offered by many vendors, each with different questions and scoring. DISC vendors themselves describe it as a measure of self-reported behavioral preference, not a predictor of job performance. Its forced-choice format also means scores are relative only to the person taking it, so they cannot be used to compare two candidates.
The research on what does predict performance points elsewhere. Drawing on Schmidt and Hunter (1998) and a 2022 update by Sackett and colleagues, Rhamy ranks structured interviews first, followed by job knowledge tests, work samples, cognitive ability and the personality trait of conscientiousness.
Screening candidates with an unvalidated test also creates legal exposure under Title VII and the ADA. Rhamy points to Target paying $2.8 million in 2015, and to CVS and Best Buy dropping their tests after the EEOC found probable adverse impact in 2018.
The episode closes with where personality tools do belong: after the hire, as a voluntary, low-stakes way to start conversations about how people work, and never as a substitute for getting to know each person.
Key takeaways
- Do not use DISC or any personality test to decide who to hire or to predict how someone will perform.
- Improve hiring by writing the same job-related questions for every candidate and scoring every answer on the same scale.
- Where the job allows it, add a job knowledge test or a work sample that has candidates do a piece of the actual work.
- Before using any test to screen candidates, confirm it has been validated for the job, because the employer must prove that if the test screens out a protected group at a higher rate.
- Have a professional review any assessment that probes stress, mood or reactions under pressure, since it can drift toward an illegal pre-offer medical exam under the ADA.
- If you use personality tools, keep them after the hire, voluntary and developmental, as a conversation starter rather than a verdict.
Can I use DISC assessments to screen job candidates?
It is not recommended. DISC was never designed or validated to predict job performance. It grew out of William Moulton Marston's 1928 theory of how normal people express emotions, and the questionnaires sold today were built later by other people and are offered by many different vendors. DISC vendors themselves describe it as a measure of self-reported behavioral preference, not a predictive instrument.
DISC also has a structural problem for hiring. Most versions use a forced-choice format, where you pick what is most or least like you. That locks the four scores together, so a higher score in one area lowers another. The scores are relative only to the person who took it, which means they cannot be used to compare two candidates. Since hiring is about comparing people, that is a fatal flaw.
What hiring methods actually predict job performance?
Decades of research point to a short list. Drawing on Schmidt and Hunter's 1998 study, which pulled together 85 years of data, and a 2022 update by Sackett and colleagues in the Journal of Applied Psychology, the episode ranks the methods this way:
- Structured interviews, where every candidate gets the same job-related questions scored on a consistent scale
- Job knowledge tests, for jobs that lend themselves to them
- Work sample tests, where candidates do a piece of the actual job
- Cognitive ability, meaning general mental ability
- Conscientiousness, a personality trait with a modest but real link to performance
The 2022 update corrected the older numbers downward, so even the methods that work are weaker than once claimed. DISC does not appear on the list at all.
How do I run a structured interview?
A structured interview means every candidate for a role is asked the same job-related questions, and every answer is scored on the same consistent scale. In this episode, Rhamy calls it the number one predictor of job performance among common hiring methods and the highest leverage change a small business can make to its hiring.
The practical starting point is simple: write down the questions before interviews begin, make sure each one connects to the work the person will actually do, ask them of every candidate, and score the answers the same way each time. This replaces gut feel and personality labels with a consistent comparison. Pairing it with a work sample, where the candidate does a piece of the real job, adds another method with research behind it. Both are cheaper than a personality test.
What are the legal risks of using personality tests in hiring?
Under Title VII, any test used to screen candidates is a selection procedure. If it screens out a protected group at a higher rate, the employer has to prove the test is job-related and validated, and the discrimination does not have to be intentional. A common tripwire is the four-fifths rule: if a protected group is selected at less than 80% of the rate of the top group, that is treated as evidence of adverse impact and shifts the burden to the employer.
Because DISC has no job-specific validation, an employer using it to screen would have little to defend with. Rhamy cites Target paying $2.8 million in 2015 to over 3,000 rejected applicants over its assessments, and the EEOC finding in 2018 that the personality tests used by Best Buy and CVS probably had adverse impact, after which both stopped using them. As of October 2026, the episode notes that federal adverse impact enforcement is changing, so check current guidance.
Can a personality test count as a medical exam under the ADA?
It can. Under the ADA, a test designed to reveal a mental health condition can be treated as an illegal medical exam if it is given before a job offer. The episode points to a well-known case against Rent-A-Center, where a test that included the MMPI, a clinical psychological instrument, was ruled a medical exam. Part of Target's settlement also involved an assessment that was ruled an illegal medical exam.
DISC is generally not clinical, so its risk on this point is lower. The lesson is that the name of the test does not matter. What matters is what the test actually does. Any assessment that probes stress, mood or how someone reacts under pressure can drift toward the ADA line, so have a professional review it before using it in hiring. Software that scores or ranks candidates may also fall under newer state and local hiring laws.
Is DISC the same as the Big Five personality model?
No. The Big Five, also called the Five Factor Model, is the personality framework that is scientifically respected. It measures openness, conscientiousness, extroversion, agreeableness and stability, has been validated for decades across cultures, and treats traits as continuous dials rather than boxes people are sorted into.
Within the Big Five, conscientiousness does predict job performance modestly, at roughly a 0.2 correlation, which makes it the best personality indicator there is. That does not make it a sorting tool for specific jobs: the link is general and small, and does not hold in all roles. The precise statement from the episode is that a validated Big Five-based instrument, used carefully as one input among several, can be defensible. DISC or Myers-Briggs used to hire is not.
Why do DISC and Myers-Briggs results feel so accurate?
The feeling comes from a well-documented bias called the Barnum effect, or Forer effect. In 1948, researcher Bertram Forer gave students a personality assessment and then handed each one a personalized description. On average they rated it 4.3 out of 5 for accuracy. Every student had received the exact same description, assembled from horoscopes.
People tend to accept vague, general, flattering statements as if they were uniquely about them. That is why a profile can feel spot on without telling you anything about whether the tool predicts performance. Type systems can also be unstable: the episode cites studies finding that somewhere between 39 and 76 percent of people get a different Myers-Briggs type when they retake it just five weeks later. A label that may change next month is a weak basis for a hiring decision.
How should managers use DISC with their existing team?
After someone is hired, DISC can be a useful low-stakes development tool, as long as it is voluntary and never used for decisions. Its value is not precision. It gives a team a shared vocabulary, gets people talking about how they approach work differently, sparks self-awareness, and reminds a manager that the person across the desk is not wired the same way.
The episode also flags the risks even in this setting. Labels can box people in ("he's a high D"), become an excuse to stop growing or to excuse rude behavior as "just my style," and feed confirmation bias. The biggest cost is substituting the profile for the relationship. Good leaders individualize how they lead each person, and a profile is at best the first sentence of that conversation, not the last word.
About this episode
A client recently wanted to add DISC assessments to their hiring process. Rhamy told them no — and in this episode he explains exactly why, backed by the actual science and the actual case law.
Here's the short version: DISC was never built to predict job performance, it has never been validated for hiring, and using it to screen candidates is both scientifically indefensible and legally risky. Companies like Target have paid millions over personality-test hiring. But this isn't an anti-personality-test rant — because there IS a place these tools belong. It's just not in recruiting.
In this episode, you'll learn:
- Where DISC actually came from (a 1928 emotion theory — not a hiring tool)
- Why DISC has no predictive validity for job performance (its own vendors admit it)
- What ACTUALLY predicts performance: structured interviews, work samples, cognitive ability, and conscientiousness
- The legal trap: no validation = no defense when a test screens people out (Target's $2.8M; CVS and Best Buy dropping their tests)
- The one nuance that keeps you honest: DISC is NOT the Big Five, and conscientiousness is real
- Why these profiles FEEL so accurate (the Barnum effect)
- Where personality tools DO belong — team communication and self-awareness, never selection
- The leadership payoff: great leaders individualize, and DISC is just the poor man's shortcut to knowing your people
This episode is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.


