Don't HR Alone · Episode 76

The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act: The Law Most Employers Have Never Heard Of

September 10, 202616 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (10)

When an employee shares that she is pregnant, many kind-hearted managers respond, "Start your leave whenever you need to." In this episode, Rhamy explains why that generous instinct can violate federal law. Under the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA), leave is a last resort, not a first response.

The PWFA is an accommodation law, separate from the Pregnancy Discrimination Act of 1978. The statute took effect in June 2023, the EEOC's implementing rule followed in June 2024, and it applies to employers with 15 or more employees. As of September 2026, Rhamy says the violation the EEOC pursues most is employers defaulting to leave instead of exploring accommodations that would let the employee keep working. He cites EEOC settlements of $55,000, $90,000 and $100,000.

Rhamy explains the four accommodations the EEOC treats as virtually always reasonable: carrying and drinking water, extra restroom breaks, sitting or standing as needed, and breaks to eat or drink. Larger requests go through the same interactive process used under the ADA.

The episode also covers where obligations end: the 15-employee threshold, the requirement of a known pregnancy-related limitation, undue hardship, limits on temporarily suspending essential functions, the employer's right to choose among effective options, and tight limits on documentation.

The practical close: never default to leave, grant the simple requests without fuss, and document every step.

Key takeaways

  • Never respond to a pregnancy-related request by defaulting to leave; first explore accommodations that let the employee keep working.
  • Grant water, extra restroom breaks, sitting or standing, and breaks to eat or drink without asking for a doctor's note.
  • Treat any mention of a pregnancy-related limitation, such as morning sickness or a lifting restriction, as an accommodation request, even without formal wording.
  • Put accommodations in place with a timeline, such as 30 days, and check in because needs change over a pregnancy.
  • When documentation is reasonable, ask only for confirmation of the condition, that it is pregnancy related, and the change needed.
  • If you have fewer than 15 employees, check your state and city laws, which may require pregnancy accommodation at lower thresholds.

What is the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act?

The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) is a federal law requiring employers with 15 or more employees to provide reasonable accommodations for known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions, unless doing so would cause an undue hardship. The statute took effect in June 2023, and the EEOC's implementing rule came in June 2024.

In this episode, Rhamy distinguishes it from the Pregnancy Discrimination Act of 1978, which prohibits firing or refusing to hire someone because they are pregnant. The PWFA goes further: it requires employers to proactively adjust the job, much as the ADA does for disabilities.

Unlike the ADA, the condition does not need to rise to the level of a disability. Modest or episodic limitations, such as morning sickness, swollen ankles or prenatal appointments, are covered. Rhamy also notes that the PWFA comes with notice obligations, so update your handbook and labor law posters. As of September 2026, check current EEOC guidance.

Can I put a pregnant employee on leave?

Only as a last resort. Under the PWFA, an employer may not require an employee to take leave if another reasonable accommodation would let her keep working. In this episode, Rhamy says that as of September 2026, defaulting to leave is the violation the EEOC is pursuing most.

It often happens out of kindness. An employee mentions morning sickness, and the manager says, "Just don't come in until noon." Rhamy points out that this is effectively unpaid leave: her income drops and her choice is removed without any interactive process.

Leave is appropriate only after other effective accommodations have been explored and none works.

What pregnancy accommodations are always reasonable?

The EEOC identifies four accommodations that will virtually always be reasonable and not an undue hardship for a currently pregnant employee. Rhamy calls them the floor:

  1. Carrying and drinking water as needed.
  2. Additional restroom breaks.
  3. Sitting if the job requires standing, or standing if it requires sitting.
  4. Breaks to eat or drink.

For these four, Rhamy says you generally should not ask for a doctor's note; you should simply grant them. His example: a pregnant cashier asks for a stool and a water bottle at the register. Grant it.

Everything beyond the floor, such as leave, transfers, suspending core duties or expensive equipment, is not automatic. Those requests go through the full interactive process and undue hardship analysis. Even then, Rhamy notes that most PWFA accommodations cost little or nothing: a stool, a water bottle, a break or a schedule adjustment.

What is the interactive process for pregnancy accommodations?

It mirrors the ADA process. Rhamy lays out five steps:

  1. Recognize the trigger. Any communication about a known pregnancy-related limitation is a request. "I need a later start because of morning sickness" counts; no magic words are needed.
  2. Engage; do not default. Ask what she is experiencing, what would help her keep working and what her doctor has recommended.
  3. Explore options other than leave first, such as a modified schedule, extra breaks, temporary lighter duties, remote work, closer parking, a private space or permission to sit or stand. You may choose among effective options.
  4. Implement with a timeline. Put the accommodation in place promptly and set check-in dates, for example in 30 days, since needs change over nine months.
  5. Document everything: every conversation, every option considered and rejected, and every reason.

Rhamy stresses that documentation is your defense.

When can an employer deny a pregnancy accommodation?

Rhamy describes several limits:

  • Size. The PWFA applies only to employers with 15 or more employees, though state and city laws may apply at lower thresholds, some at one employee.
  • Known limitation. The request must relate to the employee's own pregnancy, childbirth or related condition and be communicated to you. "I'd prefer mornings" with no pregnancy connection is not a PWFA request.
  • Undue hardship. Significant difficulty or expense, weighed against your size and resources, as under the ADA.
  • Essential functions. The PWFA can require temporarily suspending an essential function, which the ADA never does, but only if she can resume it in the near future (for a current pregnancy, generally within about 40 weeks) and it is reasonable and not an undue hardship.
  • Choice of accommodation. If several options work, you pick. A lifting assist and a stool can replace a requested desk transfer.

What you cannot do is force leave when a working accommodation exists.

Can I require a doctor's note for a pregnancy accommodation?

Only in limited situations. In this episode, Rhamy explains that the EEOC discourages demanding documentation, and many requests should be handled with a simple conversation.

You cannot require documentation when the need is obvious, such as a visibly pregnant employee needing a larger uniform; when the request is one of the four predictable accommodations (water, restroom breaks, sitting or standing, and breaks to eat or drink); when it is lactation related; when you already have enough information; or when you would not normally ask, such as a one-day absence under a policy that requires notes only for three or more days.

When documentation is reasonable, ask only for the minimum: confirmation of the condition, that it is related to pregnancy, and the change needed. Rhamy notes that you cannot send the employee to a doctor of your choosing, and the information must be kept confidential.

About this episode

There's a federal law that's been in effect since June 2023 that most small business owners have never heard of — the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA). And the EEOC is already filing lawsuits and winning $55,000–$100,000 settlements. The most common violation? Defaulting to "just take your leave" when an employee announces a pregnancy. Under the PWFA, leave is a LAST resort, not a first response.

But here's what most HR content won't tell you: the PWFA is NOT unlimited. There are clear boundaries. In this episode, Rhamy Alejeal walks through the interactive process that keeps you compliant AND the situations where you do NOT have to grant an accommodation.

In this episode, you'll learn:

  • Why "just take your leave" is the #1 PWFA violation the EEOC is prosecuting
  • The 4 accommodations that are "virtually always" required (and are basically free)
  • The 5-step interactive process for pregnancy accommodations
  • When you DON'T have to accommodate: undue hardship, the 15-employee floor, and the limits on suspending essential functions
  • Why you rarely need to ask for a doctor's note
  • How the PWFA differs from the ADA (minor conditions still count)

IMPORTANT: The PWFA uses the ADA's "significant difficulty or expense" standard for undue hardship — NOT the religious accommodation standard. We keep these straight so you don't mix them up.

This episode is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The PWFA's regulatory details are set by EEOC rule, which can change; verify current guidance.