Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 77
The Supreme Court Just Made Religious Accommodations Way Harder to Deny
Chapters (8)
Many employers assume that federal enforcement is easing across the board. In this episode, the final part of a three-part series on accommodation, Rhamy explains that religious accommodation is the exception. As of October 2026, he says the EEOC filed 11 religious discrimination lawsuits in 2025, including one against Apple over a Jewish employee's Sabbath observance, and he cites a $21 million settlement with Columbia University.
The reason is Groff v. DeJoy, a unanimous 2023 Supreme Court decision. For almost 50 years, employers relied on a line from TWA v. Hardison (1977) treating any cost "more than de minimis" as an undue hardship. Groff rejected that reading. Employers must now accommodate a religious practice unless it would cause "substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its particular business." Rhamy stresses that this standard applies to religion only; disability and pregnancy accommodations use the ADA's "significant difficulty or expense" test.
Harder to deny is not impossible to deny. Rhamy covers the categories where employers can still lawfully say no: real, quantified substantial cost; a documented safety, health or security risk; a request that is not religious or not sincerely held; and a bona fide seniority system, which he calls the strongest defense. He also explains the mistake that loses cases: treating coworker grumbling or customer discomfort as a hardship.
The practical close is a process: treat any religious conflict as a request, assess it against your particular business, explore alternatives, and document the analysis.
Key takeaways
- Evaluate religious accommodation requests under the Groff standard of substantial increased costs, not the old more-than-trivial test.
- Keep the standards separate: use Groff for religion, and the ADA's significant difficulty or expense test for disability and pregnancy.
- Never deny a religious accommodation because coworkers are annoyed or customers might be uncomfortable.
- Before denying on safety grounds, assess the specific garment, grooming practice or task and look for a safe alternative.
- Offer an alternative such as a voluntary shift swap system if it reasonably resolves the conflict, even if it is not the employee's first choice.
- If you deny a request, document the dollar, staffing or operational impact and why each alternative you considered failed, ideally with an attorney involved.
What did the Supreme Court decide in Groff v. DeJoy?
In Groff v. DeJoy (2023), the Supreme Court unanimously raised the bar for denying religious accommodations under Title VII. Gerald Groff was a Postal Service mail carrier who observed a Sunday Sabbath and did not want to work Sunday delivery shifts. The Postal Service said accommodating him was an undue hardship.
For almost 50 years, employers had relied on a line from TWA v. Hardison (1977) treating any accommodation costing "more than a de minimis cost" as an undue hardship, meaning almost any inconvenience was enough. The Court held that reading was wrong. Employers must now accommodate unless doing so would result in "substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its particular business."
In this episode, Rhamy highlights two phrases: substantial, meaning minor costs and a little schedule shuffling are no longer enough, and particular business, which helps small employers because the burden is measured against your own operation, not a giant enterprise.
Is the undue hardship standard the same for religious, disability and pregnancy accommodations?
No, and Rhamy calls confusing them the most common mistake in this area. There are three accommodation laws with two hardship tests:
- Religion (Title VII): after Groff, accommodation is required unless it causes substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of the particular business.
- Disability (ADA): significant difficulty or expense, a standard written into the statute by Congress.
- Pregnancy (PWFA): uses the ADA's significant difficulty or expense standard.
Groff changed only the religious standard. Rhamy notes that the Court said it was not deciding how the religious standard relates to the ADA, so disability and pregnancy accommodations were not affected.
The practical rule: when evaluating a disability or pregnancy request, use the ADA language, and do not apply Groff's wording. When evaluating a religious request, do not reach for the ADA language. Document each under its own standard.
When can an employer deny a religious accommodation?
Religious accommodation is a duty to try, not a blank check. Rhamy describes four categories where denial can hold:
- Substantial cost. Genuine, quantifiable costs such as significant recurring overtime, hiring extra staff or materially reduced productivity. He cites a meat packing plant where simultaneous prayer breaks for a large group stopped a production line, while noting that case was decided under the old, easier standard.
- Safety, health or security. A substantial, documented risk, assessed individually rather than assumed.
- Not religious or not sincere. Purely political, social, philosophical or personal preferences are not protected.
- A bona fide seniority system. Groff did not change this part of Hardison, and Title VII gives these systems special protection. You do not have to bump a senior employee from an earned shift to accommodate a junior one.
Rhamy recommends involving an attorney at the decision stage, not after a claim is filed.
Can coworker complaints justify denying a religious accommodation?
Not by themselves. In this episode, Rhamy explains that Groff was explicit: an accommodation's impact on coworkers matters only insofar as it affects the conduct of the business.
The following are not undue hardship: coworkers' disgruntlement, jealousy or dislike of the accommodation; coworker hostility to the religion; customer preference, fears or prejudice; and the argument that the accommodation is unfair simply because it exists. Accommodation, by nature, means giving one person something others do not get. Rhamy warns that employers cannot launder bias against a religion into an undue hardship claim.
What can count is a concrete operational impact. If accommodating one employee's schedule forces a coworker into so much involuntary overtime that their performance and the operation genuinely suffer, that harm can matter. Rhamy notes this is more likely in a small business than in a very large one. The line is between staff grumbling, which is not a defense, and an accommodation that is genuinely breaking the operation.
Can I deny a religious dress or grooming request for safety reasons?
Sometimes, but only after an individualized, documented assessment. Rhamy explains that a substantial, documented risk to safety, health or security can be an undue hardship, but a blanket assumption about a garment or grooming practice is not enough.
He walks through an EEOC example: a workplace bans loose clothing near a particular machine, and an employee asks to wear a long, close-fitting skirt instead of pants for religious reasons. You cannot simply say no. You have to assess whether that specific garment near that specific machine is genuinely a hazard. If it is, denial can hold; if you never looked, you lose.
Another example is a job requiring a tight-seal respirator and an employee whose faith calls for a beard that breaks the seal. The expected step is to look for a safe alternative, such as a loose-fitting powered respirator or a supplied-air hood, before denying. Denial holds only when there is no safe option or the only safe option is very expensive.
Can an employer question whether a religious belief is sincere?
Only carefully, and only with an objective reason. Title VII defines religion broadly; a belief does not have to belong to an organized faith. But purely political, social, philosophical or personal preferences are not protected, and a secular disagreement dressed in religious language does not count.
Rhamy's starting point is to take a professed belief at face value. A limited, careful inquiry into sincerity is appropriate only with an objective basis, such as the employee acting inconsistently with the belief, clearly seeking a secular benefit, or highly suspicious timing. An intrusive interrogation creates its own liability, and someone who practices imperfectly can still be sincere.
The request itself must also be tied to the belief. Rhamy cites Tiano v. Dillard's, in which an employee sought time off during a holiday blackout period for a religious pilgrimage. She lost because she could not show that going during that specific window was religiously required, rather than her preferred timing.
About this episode
You might think the current EEOC is backing off enforcement on religious accommodations; it's the opposite — the EEOC is MORE aggressive than it's been in a decade. 11 lawsuits in 2025. They sued Apple. They got a $21 million settlement from Columbia University. And in 2023, the Supreme Court unanimously raised the bar in Groff v. DeJoy, replacing the old "any inconvenience" standard with a much tougher one.
But "harder to deny" is not "impossible to deny." In this episode, Rhamy Alejeal explains the new Groff standard, the reliable situations where you can STILL say no, and the one mistake that gets employers sued.
In this episode, you'll learn:
- What the Supreme Court actually held in Groff v. DeJoy (2023)
- Why the current EEOC is prioritizing religious accommodation enforcement
- The reliable "no" categories: substantial cost, seniority systems, safety, and insincere requests
- The #1 mistake that gets employers sued (hint: coworker or customer dislike)
- How to run the interactive process under the new standard
- Why "sincerely held religious belief" has limits — political and personal preferences aren't covered
CRITICAL CLARIFICATION: The Groff "substantial increased costs" standard applies ONLY to religious accommodations under Title VII. It did NOT change the ADA (disability) or PWFA (pregnancy) standard — those still use "significant difficulty or expense." We keep all three straight so you never mix them up.
This episode is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.


