Don't HR Alone ยท Episode 11

The Art of Strategic Annual Raise Planning

February 13, 202412 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal

Each new year, owners face the same question: how much should raises be, and how do you decide fairly across the team? Small businesses can judge each person one at a time, but as a company grows it needs a repeatable system. In this episode, Rhamy explains a practical framework for planning annual raises for hourly and salaried employees.

Rhamy splits raise planning into two parts. The first is movement of the whole salary range for a job. He calls this the cost of living adjustment, or COLA, but stresses that it really reflects local supply and demand for that job, not a published inflation figure. A quick salary benchmark for the job title and area shows whether the range moved up, down or sideways, and a small business can often express that as one percentage across its ranges.

The second part is movement within the range, often called a merit, tenure or step increase. Rhamy's method is to set the pay for a brand new person in the job and the pay for someone who does that same job perfectly, then decide how many years it would reasonably take to get from one to the other. Steps along the way are best set as percentages, and fast learners can move up more than one step at a time.

The episode closes with what happens at the top of a range: it is time for a conversation about the next role, because every pay range has an end.

Key takeaways

  • Plan raises in two parts: movement of the whole pay range for each job, then each employee's movement within that range.
  • Benchmark each job title in your area every year to see whether its pay range moved up, down or sideways.
  • Define the range by what you would pay a brand new person and what you would pay someone who does that same job perfectly.
  • Choose a realistic span of years to move from the bottom to the top of a range, shorter for fast-growing companies and longer for stable ones.
  • Set step increases as percentages so raises feel consistent at every point in the range.
  • Tie step increases to performance metrics, and let faster growers move up more than one step at a time.
  • When someone reaches the top of a range, talk with them about a new role, since a range cannot grow forever.

How should a small business plan annual raises?

Break raise planning into two parts. In this episode, Rhamy explains that compensation planning covers movement of the entire salary range for a job and movement of each employee within that range.

Range movement reflects what the market now pays for the job. Even for the same position at the same skill level, such as a new college graduate in a professional services office, the starting rate may change year to year. Movement within the range reflects the added value of someone who has been in the job longer and performs better.

Small businesses have the flexibility to judge each person individually, but as a company grows, Rhamy recommends a systematic, process-oriented approach. The work is relatively straightforward but time consuming, because it has to be done job by job. An HR person can supply research, but the final decisions about how pay should feel across the company belong to the executive.

How do I figure out the cost of living adjustment for my pay ranges?

Benchmark each job in your area and see how its range moved. In this episode, Rhamy explains that what is usually called a cost of living adjustment, or COLA, is really supply and demand for a specific job. It is not something you can copy from a government inflation figure. Demand for programmers in one area might outstrip supply one year, then a new college program or a large employer shutting down could create a glut of talent the next.

For a small business, the research can be as simple as searching the job title, the word salary and your city, then checking the salary listings and current job postings. Rhamy is agnostic about which salary data source you use. From there, a small business can often set one percentage, such as raising all ranges by 3.5%, while looking more closely at any job with many employees. Set that number aside as the range increase.

How do you build a step increase pay scale?

Define the bottom and top of the range, then spread the steps across a realistic number of years. In this episode, Rhamy lays out the method:

  1. Set the entry rate. Use market research to decide what you would pay someone brand new to the job.
  2. Set the top rate. Decide what you would pay someone who does this same job perfectly: reliable, needs almost no management and knows what to do and when. Do not confuse this with a promotion or management role.
  3. Choose the time span. Estimate how long someone might stay in the job, perhaps 3 years for some entry roles and 10 or more for others.
  4. Set the steps as percentages. For example, moving from $40,000 to $60,000 over 10 years is a 50% total increase, spread as compounding annual percentages.

The annual range adjustment then moves the whole scale on top of each step.

Should raises be a fixed dollar amount or a percentage?

A percentage. In this episode, Rhamy explains that fixed dollar steps feel very different depending on where someone sits in the range. His example is a job that runs from $40,000 for a new hire to $60,000 for someone who has mastered it over 10 years. A flat $2,000 a year would be a 5% raise at $40,000, which feels good, but much less meaningful for someone going from $58,000 to $60,000.

Setting steps as percentages that compound to the total increase gives people a more consistent raise each year. It also works alongside the annual range adjustment, which moves the whole scale over time, so in 10 years the entry and top rates will both be higher than today. Rhamy suggests building the math in a spreadsheet so each step is clear.

Should employees get a raise just for staying another year?

Not just for time served, but tenure usually does add value. In this episode, Rhamy acknowledges the objection that people should not get a raise simply for being around a year longer. He agrees, and adds that you also should not keep people in a job just because they have been there. The answer is performance metrics that show not only whether someone did the work, but whether they got better at it and learned more.

Someone with a few years in a role often accomplishes more and carries institutional knowledge, such as being the one person who knows how to handle a task that comes up every six months. Those are real reasons tenure is worth paying for. Performance also lets you move faster: if someone is as good after one year as peers with three or four, you can move them up two or three steps at a time.

What do you do when an employee reaches the top of their pay range?

Have a conversation about what comes next. In this episode, Rhamy explains that every pay range has an end. An excellent employee in a role may be worth two or even three times a brand new person in the same job, but not 30 times. He gives the example that you are never going to pay a basic payroll clerk more than about twice what a new payroll clerk earns.

Once someone reaches the top, they will still see the annual range adjustment, but their own rate of increase in that exact job will slow. That is the time to talk honestly: are they comfortable staying where they are, or are they ready for the next step? A growing organization can move them into management, cross-train them or move them into a higher-paid position with its own range. Rhamy also notes that how long a scale runs depends on the business: fast-growing companies may use three to five years, while long-tenured organizations may use much longer scales.

About this episode

Unlock the secrets of effective compensation planning with our latest episode! ๐Ÿš€ Dive into the Strategic Approach to Annual Raise Planning and discover key insights on salary adjustments, tenure-based increases, and maintaining a competitive edge in the job market. ๐Ÿ’ก Elevate your business's success and employee satisfaction by mastering the art of strategic compensation.