Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 42
When to Hire Employees (Without Overspending): Profit First Hiring Strategies with Michelle Scribner
Chapters (24)
Labor is usually the biggest expense a small business has, and many owners hire when they must, hoping the new person will free them up to make more money. In this episode, Rhamy talks with Michelle Scribner, CEO of Sum of All Numbers and a Master Certified Profit First Professional, about how to tell when you can afford to hire and how much to spend on people.
The conversation applies the Profit First approach from Mike Michalowicz's book. Start with real revenue: total revenue minus the cost of goods you have no real control over, such as materials or subcontracted work. Of that real revenue, a business over $1 million should spend no more than 65% on all operating expenses, including people, marketing and insurance, with 35% going to the owner for pay, taxes and profit. Very small businesses keep a higher owner share and a lower expense share.
On timing, the guidance is to hire when the business can tolerate the hire failing: save two months of the new person's salary, sometimes three, before they start. The discussion also covers sorting must-pay expenses from optional ones, keeping separate bank accounts for operating costs and the owner, treating growth spending as an owner investment with a deadline, and fitting any debt payments inside the expense budget.
The episode closes with labor burden, the true cost of an employee beyond wages, and with cash reserves for seasonal or volatile businesses, since cash flow problems are a leading reason businesses close.
Key takeaways
- Calculate your real revenue by subtracting the costs you cannot control, such as materials and subcontracted work, before setting any spending targets.
- Before making a hire, set aside two months of that person's salary, or three if your roles take longer to learn, so the business can absorb a hire that does not work out.
- Sort your expenses into must-pay costs, such as insurance, licensing and rent, and choices, so you can see what is truly left for people.
- Keep separate bank accounts for operating expenses and for the owner, so that any overspend on labor visibly comes out of your own pocket.
- Budget for the full cost of each employee, including payroll taxes, workers' compensation, paid leave and benefits, not just the hourly wage.
- If your revenue is seasonal or depends on a few large clients, build a payroll reserve so you can keep people through slow periods.
How do I know when my small business can afford to hire?
The answer offered in this episode is: when your business can tolerate the hire failing. Owners often hire on the belief that the new person will free them up and generate more revenue. That may happen, but it may not.
The practical test discussed is to save up two months of the new employee's salary in a reserve before you hire, because it typically takes about two months for someone to get up to speed. In some businesses it takes three months, so set the reserve to match how long your roles take to learn. With that money set aside, you have a defined window to train the person, watch the results and decide whether the hire is working.
The conversation also notes that a first hire is hard to get right. Like a first project, you may not yet know what good looks like, so building in that cushion protects the business.
What percentage of revenue should go to operating expenses in Profit First?
Under the Profit First approach discussed in this episode, the percentages are applied to real revenue, not total sales. Real revenue is your revenue minus cost of goods you have no real control over, such as materials or subcontracted work. In a service business it is usually the same as total revenue.
The targets shared in the episode scale with size:
- Around $100,000 of real revenue: about 30% to operating expenses, 70% to the owner
- $250,000 to $500,000: about 40% to operating expenses
- $500,000 to $1 million: about 50% to operating expenses
- Over $1 million: no more than 65% to operating expenses, 35% to the owner
Operating expenses cover everything, including people, marketing, insurance and software. The owner's share covers owner pay, taxes and profit as the reward for taking the risk. The conversation treats 35% as a floor for the owner's share.
What is real revenue in Profit First?
Real revenue is the money a business actually has to work with after removing costs it cannot control. In bookkeeping terms it is close to gross profit: top-line revenue minus cost of goods sold. The conversation adds a level of scrutiny: look at everything in your cost of goods section and ask whether you have any control over it.
Materials you must buy, like lumber for a builder, stay out. Subcontracted work also comes out. A general contractor who passes 80% of each job to other companies is really working with the remaining 20%. But once a tradesperson becomes your employee and must be paid whether or not there is work, that cost belongs in operating expenses. The same goes for costs you could cut or shop around for, such as some software. The test offered is whether you would still have the cost if the business had to stop. Real revenue is then treated as 100% for setting spending targets.
How much should a small business spend on payroll?
There is no single magic payroll percentage in this episode. Instead, labor comes out of the total operating expense budget, which under the Profit First approach discussed is no more than 65% of real revenue for a business over $1 million, and less for smaller businesses.
To find what is left for people, start with what you have no choice about. The conversation calls these priority A costs: insurance you cannot let lapse, required licensing and government fees, often rent, and software you would lose your data by cancelling. What remains is a set of choices, such as a virtual assistant or a nicer office, and how you divide it reflects your values. A heavy-labor business will spend more on people, while a software business may spend more on customer acquisition. The episode notes that owners most often make their first hires somewhere in the $250,000 to $500,000 revenue range.
What is labor burden and how much does an employee really cost?
Labor burden is the cost of an employee beyond their wage. The episode gives the example of an employee paid $20 an hour actually costing the company $22.82 an hour at least.
The pieces discussed are:
- Government-required costs: Social Security and Medicare contributions, state unemployment contributions and workers' compensation, normally around 8.5 to 9% of pay, with many people using 10% as shorthand. Workers' compensation varies widely by industry.
- Paid leave: often left out of calculations. Seven holidays, 10 vacation days and five sick days add up to about 23 days, or roughly 10% of the working year.
- Benefits: health insurance and retirement plans such as a 401(k).
Taken together, the conversation says it is very common to spend 30% more than base pay. Factor that full cost into any decision about when to hire.
Should I take out a loan to hire employees?
The episode does not rule out debt, but it urges owners to think it through. Any loan payment has to fit somewhere, and under the Profit First approach discussed, it belongs inside the operating expense budget, which tops out at 65% of real revenue for a business over $1 million. If the payment does not fit there, it is coming out of the owner's pocket.
Loan payments also last a long time, often five or 10 years. Something that feels good now may feel very different a year in or a decade later. The conversation suggests asking whether you would make the same investment with your own money, which tends to make owners more careful. An alternative discussed is treating growth spending, such as a new hire or marketing push, as an investment you move from your owner's share back into the company, with a clear target for when it should pay for itself.
How do seasonal businesses manage payroll through slow months?
By planning the year as a whole and building a reserve. The episode uses pool service businesses as an example: they know they will have about three months with no revenue in winter. Their operating expense target has to work as an average across the whole year, with money set aside during busy months to cover the slow ones.
The same applies to any business where revenue is volatile or a single client makes up a large share. If you would still need your people after losing that client, even though the loss would hurt, plan a reserve for it. Some owners track their payroll reserve down to fractions of a month, such as 2.4 months, and set a number that lets them sleep at night.
Where people work part of the year but are paid over 12 months, as in many schools, the conversation notes payroll can accrue those costs through the year. The underlying point is that cash flow problems are a leading reason businesses close.
About this episode
Hiring is one of the biggest — and riskiest — expenses for any small business. In this episode of the Don’t HR Alone podcast, host Rhamy Alejeal sits down with Michelle Scribner, CEO of Sum of All Numbers and Master Certified Profit First Professional, to unpack when to hire, how much to spend on labor, and how to protect your business from cash flow disasters. Whether you’re thinking about your first hire or trying to scale a team, Michelle and Rhamy deliver real-world benchmarks, simple frameworks, and financial guardrails that every entrepreneur should use to build a sustainable team.
What You’ll Learn: ✅ How to calculate whether you can afford to hire ✅ The Profit First method applied to labor costs ✅ How much of your budget should go to payroll (and why it’s probably wrong) ✅ What percentage of real revenue should be operating expenses ✅ When it’s OK to dip into your owner’s profit to invest in staff ✅ What to do if your unicorn employees are burning out
💬 What’s your biggest hiring mistake—or the best one you ever made? 👇 Let us know in the comments!
💻 Visit Michelle Scribner’s Website: Explore financial clarity and support at https://sumofallnumbers.com/
📲 Follow Michelle for More Insights: Instagram & Facebook: @sumofallnumbers LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/michelle-scribner-94ab881aa
📧 Get in Touch: Email Michelle directly at mscribner@sumofallnumbers.com
✅ Take the Free Business Financial Health Check In just 2 minutes, gain personalized insights into your business’s financial health. Start here ➡️ https://bit.ly/3Ws4gLB


