Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 43
ACA Penalties: The IRS Fine That Could Bankrupt Your Business
Chapters (9)
An IRS Letter 226-J can arrive with a proposed Affordable Care Act penalty of tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars, because the company did not offer coverage to enough full-time employees or its plan was not affordable. In this episode, Rhamy explains how employer penalties work and what to check now to avoid them.
The rules apply to applicable large employers (ALEs), which averaged 50 or more full-time employees, including full-time equivalents, in the prior year. Rhamy explains how to count full-time employees and convert part-time hours into equivalents. He adds that employers who issue many W-2s but fall under the threshold should keep the calculation on file to answer an IRS letter.
To avoid penalties, an ALE's plan must be offered to at least 95% of full-time employees and their dependents, meet minimum essential coverage, provide minimum value of at least 60% of expected medical costs, and be affordable. As of April 2025, affordable means employee-only coverage costs no more than 9.02% of the employee's income.
Rhamy walks through the two penalties at their 2025 amounts: $2,900 per full-time employee, minus the first 30, for not offering coverage, and $4,350 per affected employee for coverage that is unaffordable or lacks minimum value. He notes these penalties are not tax deductible and add up monthly.
The episode closes with a checklist: confirm ALE status, review the plan with your broker, run an affordability test, check classifications of part-time and seasonal employees, and document everything. Check current IRS guidance, since thresholds change each year.
Key takeaways
- Run the ALE calculation every year using last year's full-time employees plus full-time equivalents, and keep the math and time records on file.
- Ask your broker to confirm that your plan meets minimum essential coverage and minimum value, for example by its metal tier.
- Test affordability against each eligible employee's pay, using the W-2, rate of pay or federal poverty level safe harbor, so employee-only coverage stays within the current percentage.
- Offer coverage to at least 95% of full-time employees and their dependents.
- Classify employees by the hours they actually work, including variable-hour and seasonal staff, rather than by the label you gave them.
- Document your measurement periods, classifications and offers of coverage so you can answer a Letter 226-J with evidence.
How do I know if my company is an applicable large employer under the ACA?
You are an applicable large employer (ALE) for the year if you averaged 50 or more full-time employees, including full-time equivalents, in the prior year. The episode explains the count in three steps:
- Count full-time employees. Include everyone designated full-time, plus hourly employees who averaged 30 or more hours per week.
- Convert part-time hours. Add up the hours of everyone who averaged under 30 hours a week and divide by 120 per month to get full-time equivalents. Rhamy's example: three people working 20 hours a week equal two full-time equivalents.
- Add the two numbers. If the total is 50 or more, the ACA employer rules apply.
Rhamy adds that employers with a lot of part-timers can issue far more than 50 W-2s and still fall under the threshold. In his experience, the IRS may still send a penalty letter, so keep your calculation and time records to show the rules do not apply. Check current IRS guidance on measurement methods.
What are the ACA employer penalties A and B for 2025?
There are two separate employer penalties, and as of April 2025 the episode gives these amounts:
- Penalty A, for not offering coverage: if you do not offer health coverage to at least 95% of full-time employees, the penalty is $2,900 per full-time employee, minus the first 30. Rhamy's example: with 70 employees, that comes to $116,000.
- Penalty B, for coverage that is not affordable or does not provide minimum value: $4,350 per affected employee. With 10 affected employees, that is $43,500.
An IRS letter can assess both at once, listing some employees under Penalty A and others under Penalty B, and you have to address each. Rhamy notes that for a for-profit business these penalties are not tax deductible, so they come straight out of profit, and they add up monthly, so waiting makes non-compliance more expensive. Penalty amounts change each year, so check current IRS figures.
What does a health plan need to meet ACA requirements for employers?
To avoid penalties, an applicable large employer's plan has to meet four tests, as laid out in this episode:
- Offer to enough people. Coverage must be offered to at least 95% of full-time employees and allow their dependents to enroll.
- Minimum essential coverage. The plan must cover the required services. Rhamy says almost every plan from large insurers meets this, while arrangements where a group of people share health costs almost certainly do not.
- Minimum value. The plan must be expected to cover at least 60% of medical costs. A bronze plan is defined at 60%, silver at 70%, gold at 80% and platinum at 90%. If your broker cannot tell you the plan's metal tier, it may not provide minimum value.
- Affordability. As of April 2025, employee-only coverage must cost no more than 9.02% of the employee's income.
Check current guidance, since the affordability percentage changes every year.
What is the ACA affordability percentage for 2025?
As of April 2025, the episode gives the affordability threshold as 9.02% of the employee's income. It applies only to employee-only coverage. The affordability rule does not cover what you charge for spouse or dependent coverage.
Rhamy's example: a full-time employee earning $1,500 a month cannot be charged more than about $135 a month for individual coverage.
You can run the affordability test using one of three safe harbors: W-2 wages, rate of pay, or the federal poverty level. Rhamy says the rate of pay method, calculated from the employee's gross pay, is often the most advantageous, while W-2 wages make a good quick check and the federal poverty level method is least likely to be useful. If a full-time employee turns down your coverage as unaffordable and gets coverage through healthcare.gov or a state exchange, that can trigger Penalty B. Check the current year's percentage.
What triggers an IRS Letter 226-J for ACA penalties?
Letter 226-J is the IRS notice proposing an ACA employer penalty. In this episode, Rhamy describes two common triggers.
The first is the employer's size. He explains that the IRS starts by looking at how many W-2s a business issues. An employer that issues 50 or more W-2s but does not do the required Form 1095 reporting or offer coverage is likely to get a letter, even if its full-time equivalent count is actually under 50.
The second is an employee's application for coverage elsewhere. When someone applies through healthcare.gov or a state exchange, they are asked whether their employer offers coverage and whether it is affordable. If a full-time employee says it is not and gets coverage there, the employer can receive a penalty letter.
Either way, you need records proving compliance or showing the rules do not apply to you. Rhamy says his firm sees these letters for different clients every year.
Do seasonal and part-time employees count for ACA coverage?
They can, and getting this wrong is one of the biggest compliance mistakes Rhamy sees. The ACA looks at hours worked, not the label you give someone. If an hourly employee you call part-time actually averages 30 or more hours a week, they are full-time for ACA purposes and must be counted in the 95% of full-time employees offered coverage.
Seasonal employees are a common blind spot. Rhamy says there is no real seasonal discount: someone who will only work for six months may still need to be offered coverage if they work full-time hours. There are ways to structure your measurement period that give some leeway, but only if you set them up and track hours.
The practical steps are to track every employee's hours, review classifications of part-time, variable-hour and seasonal staff, and document your measurement period. Without that, you are open to an audit you cannot answer.
How do I avoid ACA penalties as an employer?
The episode closes with a five-step checklist:
- Confirm ALE status. Run the 50-or-more full-time and full-time equivalent test using last year's numbers.
- Review the health plan. Ask your broker to confirm it meets minimum essential coverage and minimum value.
- Test affordability. Compare the plan's cost against payroll so no employee pays more than the affordability percentage of income for individual coverage, which as of April 2025 is 9.02%.
- Check classifications. Make sure part-time and seasonal employees are correctly classified and should not be full-time.
- Document everything. If audited, you need accurate records proving compliance.
Rhamy stresses that the IRS is actively enforcing these rules and that he sees penalty letters every year. Because thresholds and penalty amounts change annually, recheck them each year against current IRS guidance.
About this episode
Are you an employer with 50 or more W-2s? You could be at risk for massive IRS penalties under the Affordable Care Act. In this episode of Don't HR Alone, Rhamy Alejeal breaks down everything you need to know to stay compliant with ACA regulations in 2025 — and avoid receiving the dreaded IRS Letter 226-J.
You’ll learn: ✅ How to calculate your Applicable Large Employer (ALE) status ✅ What triggers ACA penalties A and B — and how to prevent them ✅ How to ensure your health plan meets Minimum Essential Coverage (MEC) and Affordability requirements ✅ The right way to track employee hours, classifications, and safe harbors ✅ What to do immediately if you receive an ACA penalty notice


