Don't HR Alone · Episode 3

IRS 2024 ACA Affordability Threshold Announcement

September 25, 20237 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal

Each year the IRS resets the percentage of pay that an employee can be asked to contribute for employer health coverage before it stops counting as affordable. For larger employers, missing that number can mean significant penalties. In this episode, recorded in September 2023, Rhamy explains the IRS announcement for the 2024 plan year and what employers needed to do about it.

On August 23, 2023, the IRS announced that the Affordable Care Act affordability threshold would drop to 8.39% for 2024 plan years, down from 9.12% in 2023 and below the 9.5% figure in place when the law took effect. Rhamy walks through the employer shared responsibility provision, often called pay or play, which applies to employers that averaged 50 or more full-time employees, including full-time equivalents, in the prior year. Those employers must offer affordable, minimum essential, minimum value coverage to most full-time employees and their children, or risk a penalty that is assessed by month and is not tax deductible.

Rhamy then works through what 8.39% means in dollars for lower-wage employees and why an employer facing a 10% to 15% cost increase might still have to lower what employees pay. He closes with a three-part action plan: talk to your benefits broker, review plans and contributions, and communicate changes clearly to employees. As of September 2023, the threshold changes every year, so check current guidance for the plan year you are pricing.

Key takeaways

  • Confirm the ACA affordability percentage for each plan year, since it changes annually and was 8.39% for 2024 plan years.
  • Test affordability on the cheapest employee-only option that provides minimum essential, minimum value coverage.
  • Translate the threshold into a monthly dollar cap for your lowest-paid full-time employees before setting contributions.
  • Expect that a rising premium may still require lowering the employee's share of the employee-only cost.
  • Meet with your benefits broker early to review plans, pricing and employer contributions against the new threshold.
  • Fix affordability problems quickly, because the penalty accrues month by month.
  • Tell employees clearly about any changes to their coverage or contributions.

What was the ACA affordability threshold for 2024?

For 2024 plan years, the ACA affordability threshold was 8.39%. In this episode, Rhamy explains that the IRS announced the figure on August 23, 2023, lowering it from 9.12% in 2023. The original figure when the law took effect was 9.5%.

The threshold means that, for employer coverage to be considered affordable in 2024, an employee's required contribution for employee-only coverage could not be more than 8.39% of their income. Rhamy notes that a drop of under one percentage point may look small, but it is significant for employers, because it tightens the margin on how much they can charge employees. As of September 2023, when this episode was published, the percentage was adjusted every year, so check current guidance for the plan year you are pricing.

Which employers have to offer affordable health coverage under the ACA?

The requirement applies to large employers under the ACA's employer shared responsibility provision, also known as pay or play. In this episode, Rhamy defines a large employer as one that averaged 50 or more full-time employees, including full-time equivalent employees, during the prior year.

Those employers have two main options. They can offer most full-time employees and their children coverage that is minimum essential, minimum value and affordable based on the employee-only level of coverage. Or they can choose not to offer that coverage and risk a penalty from the IRS when full-time employees get coverage through the health insurance marketplace. Rhamy describes the penalty calculation as complex and notes that it is not a deductible business expense, so it comes straight out of profit. He mentions clients that could face six or seven hundred thousand dollars in penalties for a single plan year if found noncompliant.

How do you calculate the maximum employee premium for ACA affordability?

Multiply the employee's income by the affordability percentage for the plan year. In this episode, Rhamy uses the 2024 figure of 8.39% to show how it works in dollars:

  • A full-time employee earning $1,000 a month gross could be charged no more than $83.90 a month for affordable employee-only coverage.
  • An employee earning $15 an hour works about 160 hours a month, or roughly $2,400. At 8.39%, the most the employer could charge is about $200 a month for employee-only coverage.

The test applies to employee-only coverage on a plan that is also minimum essential and minimum value. Employers can offer several plans, and only one of them has to meet the threshold, but at least one must. Because the percentage changes each year, rerun the math whenever a new figure is announced.

Can my health insurance costs go up while employee contributions have to go down?

Yes. In this episode, Rhamy points out that an employer may see a 10% or 15% increase in its health plan costs and still need to lower what employees pay for the minimum essential coverage option. That happens when the affordability percentage drops, as it did from 9.12% in 2023 to 8.39% for 2024.

The affordability test looks at the employee's required contribution compared with their income, not at the employer's total premium. When the allowed percentage falls, the dollar cap on the employee's share of employee-only coverage falls with it, regardless of what the carrier charges. The employer absorbs the difference. That is why Rhamy recommends reviewing plans, pricing and employer contributions with a benefits broker every year rather than simply passing along the increase.

How are ACA employer penalties assessed if I fix a problem mid-year?

The penalty is calculated by month, so fixing a problem partway through the year limits the exposure to the months before the fix. In this episode, Rhamy explains that if an employer does not correct an affordability problem until March, it owes the monthly share of the annual per-employee penalty for January, February and March, rather than for the full year.

That makes speed important. As soon as a new affordability percentage is announced, compare it with what you charge your lowest-paid full-time employees for employee-only coverage. If the option fails the test, work with your benefits broker to adjust contributions or plan design, then tell employees what is changing. Rhamy also notes that the penalty is not tax deductible. As of September 2023, the rules and amounts are adjusted over time, so check current guidance.

What should HR do when the ACA affordability threshold changes?

Follow a three-step plan. In this episode, Rhamy lays it out for HR professionals:

  1. Talk to your benefits broker. Start discussions early to understand the implications for your organization and the adjustments required.
  2. Review and adjust. Look at existing plans, pricing and employer contributions, and make sure they line up with the new threshold so you stay compliant and avoid IRS penalties.
  3. Educate and inform employees. Once you have a plan, employees will have questions. Set up clear communication about any changes to their coverage or contributions.

Rhamy stresses that this is not a one-time project. Because the percentage changes every year, employers need an annual conversation and plan to stay compliant. As of September 2023, check current guidance for the latest figure.

About this episode

Key Insights for Employers, HR Pros, and Employees - Stay Informed!

The IRS recently made an announcement that holds significant implications for employers and HR professionals alike: the Affordable Care Act (ACA) affordability threshold for 2024 will be adjusted to 8.39%, down from 9.12% in 2023. This change might seem minor, but it holds substantial ramifications for businesses.

🔍 What's Inside: * Clear explanations of ACA nuances and the employer shared responsibility provision. * Insightful breakdown of the 8.39% health plan affordability threshold and its implications. * Actionable advice for employers and HR professionals. * Tips for ensuring compliance and avoiding hefty IRS penalties. * The bigger picture: How the ACA aims to make healthcare accessible and affordable.

Stay ahead of the curve, protect your organization, and keep your team informed. For comprehensive resources and expert insights, visit our website at peopleprocesses.com.

Join us in staying informed and agile in the ever-evolving landscape of healthcare and employee benefits.