Don't HR Alone · Episode 44

At-Will Employment EXPLAINED: How to Fire Without Getting Sued

April 24, 202510 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (6)

Many owners treat "we are an at-will employer" as a free pass to fire anyone at any time. In this episode, Rhamy explains what at-will employment actually means, where it stops protecting you, and how to use it without ending up in a lawsuit or damaging your culture.

At-will employment, the default in most of the United States, means either the employer or the employee can end the relationship at any time, for any legal reason or no reason at all, with no contract and no required notice. Rhamy walks through the pros and cons on both sides: employers can restructure quickly and employees can leave a bad job or negotiate, but it also creates uncertainty, can breed fear, and gives some managers the false idea that documentation does not matter.

The heart of the episode is the exceptions. You cannot fire someone for exercising a legal right, such as reporting harassment, taking medical leave or filing for workers' compensation. Terminations cannot be based on a protected characteristic. Offer letters, verbal promises, handbook wording and even probationary periods can create an implied contract. Some states require good faith, so you cannot fire someone to avoid paying a bonus or commission. And Montana requires good cause once a probationary period ends.

The episode closes with four steps: audit your handbook and offer letters, train managers, document performance issues through progressive discipline, and build a culture where people do not fear being fired for no reason.

Key takeaways

  • Treat at-will as permission to end employment for any legal reason, not as protection against claims of discrimination or retaliation.
  • Audit your handbook, onboarding materials and offer letters so they state your at-will policy clearly and consistently.
  • Remove language that promises job security, including probationary periods after which employees seem protected from being fired.
  • Do not time terminations to avoid paying an earned bonus or commission.
  • Train managers on what at-will means and how to carry out a proper termination.
  • Document performance problems through progressive discipline so you can show the real reason for any termination.

What does at-will employment mean?

At-will employment means either party, the employer or the employee, can end the working relationship at any time, for any legal reason or for no reason at all. There is no need for a contract and no required notice. It is the default in most of the United States.

That cuts both ways. An office manager can drop their keys on your desk and leave without two weeks' notice, and an employer can make a fast staffing change. In this episode, Rhamy calls it the beautiful and brutal reality of at-will employment.

The key phrase is "legal reason." Rhamy puts it this way: you can fire someone for no reason, but not for any reason. If an employee believes the termination was based on discrimination, retaliation or a protected activity, at-will status will not protect you. Just because you can terminate someone does not mean you should, especially without documentation, consistency or a clear process.

What are the exceptions to at-will employment?

At-will is not absolute. The episode covers five exceptions that can undo a termination:

  1. Public policy. You cannot fire someone for exercising a legal right, such as reporting harassment, taking medical leave, filing for workers' compensation or reporting an injury.
  2. Discrimination. Terminations cannot be based on race, gender, age, religion, disability or another protected characteristic, or produce a pattern of that discrimination.
  3. Implied contracts. Verbal promises, offer letters or poorly worded handbooks can create job security a court may treat as a contract.
  4. Good faith and fair dealing. Some states require employers to act in good faith, so you cannot fire someone to avoid paying a bonus or commission.
  5. Montana. The one state where at-will does not apply after a probationary period. After that, you need good cause.

Exceptions vary by state, so check the current law where your employees work.

Can a probationary period hurt at-will employment?

It can. In this episode, Rhamy says probationary periods are one of the most common problems he has seen in court cases his firm has worked on.

The typical setup goes like this: an employer hires a stylist for a salon with a four- or eight-week probationary period, during which they can be fired for any reason if it is not working out. After that, they become a regular employee. The problem is the implication. If you can fire someone for any legal reason during probation, what changes when probation ends? By using that wording, you suggest the employee now has job security, which can create an implied contract and give up your at-will status without meaning to.

Rhamy sees this most in long-established businesses still using older handbook language. The fix is to review your offer letters and handbook and remove wording that implies employees can only be let go at will during a set period.

What is an implied employment contract?

An implied contract is job security your company created without meaning to. As explained in this episode, verbal promises, offer letters or poorly written handbook language can lead a court to treat the employment relationship like a contract, whether you intended it or not, and even if your documents also say employment is at will.

Common examples include telling someone they will have a job here for as long as they want, or using a probationary period that suggests employees are protected once it ends.

The protection is to audit your handbook, onboarding materials and offer letters. They should clearly state your at-will policy, say the same thing across every document, and avoid promises of permanent employment. Train managers not to make verbal promises of job security either.

Can I fire an employee right before their bonus is paid?

It can create legal risk. One of the at-will exceptions covered in this episode is the duty of good faith and fair dealing. Some states, though not all, require employers to act in good faith, which means you cannot terminate someone just to avoid paying a bonus or commission they were on track to earn.

Rhamy's example: a company tells employees that annual bonuses are paid in December based on the year's work, then lets a group of people go in November. In many states, that pattern can look like a good faith and fair dealing violation.

If you do need to end someone's employment near a bonus or commission date, make sure the real reason is documented and unrelated to the payment, and check your state's current law and the terms of your incentive plan before acting.

Is Montana an at-will employment state?

No. In this episode, Rhamy describes Montana as the only state in the US where at-will employment does not apply once an employee has finished a probationary period. After that point, an employer needs good cause to terminate.

That is a different standard from every other state. Elsewhere, an employer can generally end employment for any legal reason or no reason. In Montana, after probation, the employer has to be able to show a good cause reason for the termination.

If you have employees working in Montana, review how your probationary period is set up and make sure managers understand that the at-will rules they may know from other states do not apply there. As with any state-specific rule, check current Montana law or get local guidance before making a termination decision.

How do employers protect themselves when firing an at-will employee?

The episode lays out four steps:

  1. Audit your documents. Review handbooks, onboarding materials and offer letters so they clearly and consistently state your at-will policy, without implied promises of job security.
  2. Train your managers. They are your first line of defense and your first line of legal risk. Make sure they know what at-will means and how to conduct a proper termination.
  3. Document everything. Even in an at-will state, use progressive discipline, take notes, report incidents and send follow-ups. If someone claims an illegal termination, you need records showing the real reason, such as being late 27 times in a row.
  4. Build a strong culture. If your workplace is a revolving door, Rhamy says that is a leadership problem, not a policy problem. Invest in clarity, communication and consistency.

Being at will should give you flexibility, not make employees feel they could be fired tomorrow for no reason.

About this episode

Think you can fire anyone at any time because you're in an at-will state? Think again. In this episode of Don't HR Alone, Rhamy Alejeal, CEO of People Processes, breaks down the truth behind at-will employment — and how to avoid the lawsuits that come with getting it wrong.

What you’ll learn: • What “at-will” actually means • Legal exceptions that can ruin your case • The discipline strategy that helps you prove good faith • How to terminate while protecting your company

What’s your biggest question about firing employees legally? Drop it below 👇