Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 39
Building Workplace Trust: Why Employees Leave & How to Keep Them!
Chapters (10)
Many leaders believe employees should earn trust before they get it, and then wonder why engagement stays low and small problems keep turning into new rules. In this episode, Rhamy talks with Tracy LaLonde, author of The Joychiever Journey, who has 30 years of experience in training, consulting and professional development, about why trust works better when it is given first.
The conversation explains that extending trust triggers a reciprocal response, linked to the bonding hormone oxytocin, that lets trust grow faster than waiting for people to prove themselves. Trust carries risk, so it still needs sensible policies and safeguards. The payoff discussed is broad: better morale, collaboration, problem solving, productivity and psychological safety, and less stress.
A central theme is the limit of systems built only on carrots and sticks. When employees pad their time or miss expectations, a technical fix may treat the symptom without finding the cause. The episode recommends starting with a conversation about what is going on, being open about why a system is needed and involving employees in designing it. It also shows how a mandate can turn something people chose to do into something they resent.
The practical close covers treating trust as a teachable skill, avoiding habits that quietly erode it, involving people in decisions and explaining the outcome, and investing in manager training. The episode suggests roughly 40 hours a year, or about an hour a week, as a reasonable baseline.
Key takeaways
- Extend trust to new employees from the start, backed by sensible policies and safeguards, rather than making them earn it first.
- Before adding a rule or system to fix a behavior problem, talk with the employees involved to find out why it is happening.
- Explain why a new system is needed and involve employees in designing it, so it does not feel like management against staff.
- Ask for input on decisions, then go back and explain what you decided and why, including when you went a different way.
- Give specific positive feedback, since it tells people exactly what to keep doing.
- Budget around 40 hours a year, or about an hour a week, for each manager to build people management skills.
Should employers give trust first or make employees earn it?
This episode argues for giving trust first. Most people in workplace trainings say trust should be earned, but the conversation explains that extending trust creates a reciprocal effect: when someone is trusted, oxytocin, often called the bonding hormone, is released, which makes them more inclined to trust in return. That cycle lets trust grow and deepen faster than waiting for people to prove themselves.
Giving trust first does not mean being naive. Trust is inherently a risk, and the episode compares it to a handshake agreement that still gets put in writing. Employers should keep sensible policies and safeguards so there is somewhere to go if trust is broken. A few bad experiences come with the territory, and the episode cautions against letting them push a whole organization back into treating every new hire with suspicion.
Why does trust matter for business results?
Because it affects almost everything else. The episode lists the benefits of a high-trust workplace: better camaraderie and morale, stronger collaboration, more problem solving, innovation and creativity, higher productivity and, as a result, a better bottom line.
The mechanism is how trust changes the way people work. When employees feel connected and supported, they feel safe to contribute and to treat mistakes as learning moments rather than punishable ones. Psychological safety grows and stress drops, so people can do their best work instead of constantly looking over their shoulder. The episode also points to retention and productivity as measurable outcomes when managers are trained to build that kind of environment.
How do you fix employee behavior problems without micromanaging?
Start with a conversation, not just a new system. The episode uses the example of employees padding their time, such as clocking in early or not logging lunch. The usual fix is technical: scheduling rules, exceptions and points that add up over time. Those systems can help, and they signal what the business cares about, but on their own they treat the symptom rather than the cause.
The recommended approach is to sit down with the employee and ask what is happening. The reason might be child care needs or something else entirely. The conversation can make clear the behavior is not acceptable while also saying the person is valued and you want to find a way that works. Most people are well intended, and understanding the cause lets you choose a fix that actually solves the problem.
Why do return to office mandates hurt employee trust?
Because a mandate without a clear reason can signal that leaders do not trust people to be productive unless they are watched. The episode distinguishes between a business that shows employees real performance data on why time together matters and one that seemingly arbitrarily requires people to come in.
It shares the story of a high-performing employee who was already coming in three days a week when the company only encouraged two. When the company made three days mandatory, the employee was furious, even though his behavior did not change. The mandate created a perceived loss of flexibility and turned a choice he made for his own reasons into something he was told to do. The lesson is that how you introduce a policy can change intrinsic motivation into extrinsic compliance.
How can managers build trust with their teams?
Treat trust as a skill that can be learned. The episode describes several elements of trust, including competence, openness, integrity and empowerment. Openness means being transparent about why a system or decision is needed. Integrity means doing what you said you would do, and holding people accountable without making it feel like punishment, such as asking what happened with a missed deadline rather than assigning blame.
Empowerment means involving people in decisions, not handing decisions over. Ask for perspectives, then go back once the decision is made and explain how their input shaped it, or why you went another way. That also teaches judgment. The episode also names a common pitfall, the disappearing act: inviting people to come to you anytime, then being unavailable or unresponsive. Sharing each team member's trust musts, such as being on time, helps everyone avoid eroding trust without realizing it.
How much manager training should a small business provide?
The episode suggests about 40 hours a year per manager, roughly one business week or about an hour a week, as a good baseline, and says more is better. Many companies provide close to no training on how to manage people, as opposed to training on the technical work itself.
That training does not have to be expensive. Options discussed include a book club, online and self-paced resources, outside consultants and external programs. The expected results include better retention, productivity and innovation. Core skills such as delegation and feedback have an outsized effect. Clear delegation, covering what is expected, when and what it should look like, prevents rework. Specific positive feedback tells people exactly what to keep doing. For businesses that have not invested in people management yet, the return can be large.
About this episode
In this episode of Don't HR Alone, host Rhamy Alejeal welcomes Tracy LaLonde, author of The Joychiever Journey, to break down how trust works in the workplace. Should employees earn trust, or should leaders give it freely? Discover how trust affects employee engagement, retention, and productivity—and why some companies thrive while others struggle with micromanagement and turnover. Plus, Tracy shares her top strategies for creating a workplace built on mutual trust and psychological safety.
🔹 In this episode, you'll learn: ✔️ The science of trust and how it impacts team performance ✔️ The right way to handle employee accountability (without micromanagement) ✔️ The role of intrinsic vs. extrinsic motivation in leadership ✔️ A 5-step process to building trust in your company ✔️ The biggest mistakes leaders make when trying to create engagement
Visit Tracy's website at https://www.joychiever.com/ to learn more about her keynote speaking experience, programs she can deliver to your company, and to order her books.
You may also follow her at: https://www.linkedin.com/in/tracylalonde/ https://www.linkedin.com/company/joychiever
📝 Have a trust dilemma in your workplace? Drop your question in the comments!


