Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 65
Why Your Best Employees Are Leaving | Stay Interviews
Chapters (6)
When a good employee resigns, managers often say they never saw it coming. In this episode, Rhamy explains that the resignation was rarely sudden. It just was not visible, because most companies have no system for understanding what motivates their people, what frustrates them and what might push them out the door.
Performance reviews do not fill that gap. They look backward, they are stressful and they are built for evaluation, not engagement. Exit interviews come too late, after the decision to leave is already made.
The tool Rhamy recommends is the stay interview: a quarterly conversation of about 30 minutes, based on a structure long recommended by executive coach Marshall Goldsmith and others. It follows six steps: share where the company is heading, ask where the employee wants to go, acknowledge what is going well, ask for the one improvement that matters most, ask how the manager can support them, and ask for feed forward on what the manager should do differently.
Rhamy stresses that most turnover comes from people leaving their manager rather than their job, so the main effect of a stay interview is changing how the manager leads each person. Patterns across interviews also reveal process, clarity and training problems at the company level.
The episode closes with the follow-through: summarize what you heard, agree on one or two concrete actions, revisit them next quarter, and, for owners, standardize the questions and train managers on the intent behind them.
Key takeaways
- Hold a stay interview with each direct report every quarter, keeping it to about 30 minutes with no slides or forms.
- Open by sharing in plain language where the company is heading this quarter, then ask how that direction lands with the employee.
- Ask for the one thing that would most improve the employee's work, and listen without defending or explaining.
- End every stay interview by summarizing what you heard and agreeing on one or two concrete actions you will follow through on.
- If you manage managers, standardize the questions, train managers on the intent behind each one and review themes at the leadership level.
- Treat repeated themes across employees as process, clarity or training problems rather than individual people problems.
What is a stay interview?
A stay interview is a short, regular conversation between a manager and a direct report about what keeps that person engaged, what frustrates them and where they want to go. Unlike an exit interview, it happens while the employee is still there and the manager can still act.
In this episode, Rhamy describes it as part of a company's leadership operating system rather than an HR gimmick. Managers are usually good at the operational parts of the job, such as workloads, schedules, quality and discipline, but understanding their people is almost never systematized. A stay interview fills that gap. It helps a manager learn what motivates each person, what drains them, and what someone else could offer that would make them leave. Rhamy recommends running them quarterly, in about 30 minutes, following a simple structure based on one long recommended by executive coach Marshall Goldsmith and others.
What questions should I ask in a stay interview?
Rhamy's structure has six parts, each with a question or two and then listening:
- Where the company is heading. Give a short, plain language update on this quarter's priorities, then ask how that direction lands and what feels unclear.
- Where the employee is heading. Ask what skills they want to build, what work gives them energy and how the role fits their longer term goals.
- What is going well. Go first with specific praise, then ask what part of the job feels most satisfying.
- One key improvement. Ask for one thing, not a list: "If I could fix one thing for you, what should it be?"
- How you can support them. Ask what they need more of from you and whether anything you do gets in the way.
- Feed forward. Ask what you could do differently going forward, more of or less of.
You do not need a script, but consistent questions matter in a larger organization.
Are exit interviews useful for reducing turnover?
Not for retention. In this episode, Rhamy points out that exit interviews happen after the employee has already decided to leave, so any information they produce arrives when it is too late to act on. He adds that it is rare for them to produce useful information at all.
Performance reviews are not the answer either. They have their place as a tool for driving behavior and competence, but they are backward looking, stressful and built around judgment and evaluation, which tends to make people defensive rather than engaged.
For engagement and retention, Rhamy recommends shifting the focus to the quarterly stay interview. It asks forward looking questions while the employee is still there, and it gives the manager time to adjust before a frustration turns into a resignation.
Why do good employees quit without warning?
Usually the warning signs were there, but nobody had a system to see them. In this episode, Rhamy explains that when managers say "I didn't see that coming" or "they never said anything," the problem is typically a leadership understanding problem rather than an employee problem.
He notes that the majority of turnover comes from people leaving their manager, not their job. One of the most predictable causes is a mismatch between what someone wants to grow into and the reality of their role, which is almost always visible early if a manager asks. Another is breaking what already works: taking someone who loves mentoring and isolating them, or burying a problem solver in admin work.
Rhamy also estimates that most employees give only 20 to 30% of their discretionary effort by default, and that effort can double or triple when people feel trusted, understood and supported.
What should a manager do after a stay interview?
Follow through. Rhamy calls what happens next the most important part of the process. At the end of the conversation, the manager should summarize what they heard, agree on one or two concrete actions, and then revisit them at the next quarterly conversation.
Asking thoughtful questions and then doing nothing does real damage, because employees quickly stop being honest. Small, consistent follow-through is what builds trust over time. If an employee's request is too big to deliver, Rhamy suggests stepping it back to a concrete action you can agree to work on over the next quarter.
The conversation should also change how the manager leads. By understanding what each person wants, a manager learns to treat one employee differently from another, and Rhamy argues that this variation in leadership style is where large productivity gains come from.
How do I roll out stay interviews across my managers?
If you are an owner who manages managers, you do not need to conduct every stay interview yourself. In this episode, Rhamy explains that your leverage is teaching your managers to do them well, which makes leadership quality more consistent across the organization.
He lists the owner's steps: standardize the questions, train managers on the intent behind them rather than on scripts, set expectations on scope, require simple documentation, and review the themes at the leadership level. Owners should also run stay interviews with their own executives.
The themes matter because they surface systemic problems. If several people say a product launch is confusing, that is a process issue. If many describe unclear priorities, that is a clarity problem. If recognition is inconsistent across teams, there is a training gap or a missing tool for rewarding good work. Rhamy ranks the quarterly stay interview second only to the weekly one-on-one.
About this episode
Most resignations don’t come out of nowhere. They happen because leaders lack a system to identify the warning signs. If managers are saying “I didn’t see that coming”, the problem isn’t your people, it’s your leadership process.
In this episode, Rhamy Alejeal breaks down: • Why performance reviews and exit interviews fail at retention • The 6-question stay interview framework that surfaces problems early • How managers unintentionally lose discretionary effort • Why most turnover is caused by manager behavior, not compensation • How to systematize leadership conversations without HR bloat


