Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 27
Court Strikes Down 2024 Overtime Rule: What Employers MUST Do Now
Chapters (6)
Many employers spent months preparing for the 2024 overtime rule: adjusting budgets, raising salaries and reclassifying employees. Then, on November 15, 2024, a federal court blocked the Department of Labor's rule, wiping out the July 2024 changes and the larger increase planned for January 1, 2025. In this episode, Rhamy explains what the ruling meant and how to respond without damaging trust.
As of December 2024, when the episode was published, the federal salary thresholds reverted to the 2019 levels: $35,568 a year for the white collar exemptions and $107,432 for highly compensated employees. The automatic updates every three years were struck down along with the rule. Some states, such as California, set higher thresholds that the ruling did not affect.
Rhamy's main point is that the decision is now about leadership as much as compliance. Employers who already raised pay could return to the old numbers for new hires, but taking a raise back from current employees risks a wave of resignations. The salary threshold changed, yet the duties tests did not, so any classification review done to prepare was not wasted.
The episode closes with practical steps: review salaries and roles against the reverted thresholds and the duties tests, update job descriptions to match the work people actually do, explain any decision honestly to the team, and review classifications and salaries every year so the next rule change is less disruptive.
Key takeaways
- Check each exempt employee's salary against the reverted federal threshold of $35,568 a year, and against any higher state threshold that applies.
- Think carefully before taking back raises given to meet the blocked rule, since current employees may see it as a betrayal and leave.
- Keep reviewing the duties tests, because misclassification can still cost you even though the salary threshold went down.
- Update job descriptions so they reflect the work employees actually do, which also supports exemption decisions.
- Tell your team what you decided and why, whether you roll changes back, keep them or reclassify people.
- Review classifications and salaries every year so future rule changes do not catch you off guard.
What happened to the 2024 FLSA overtime rule?
On November 15, 2024, a federal court blocked the Department of Labor's 2024 overtime rule. The rule had raised the minimum salary required for exempt employees across the United States, with a first increase taking effect in July 2024 and a much larger jump scheduled for January 1, 2025.
The ruling canceled both. As of December 2024, when this episode was published, the federal salary thresholds went back to the levels set in 2019, and the rule's planned automatic updates every three years were also struck down. In this episode, Rhamy describes how this left many employers who had already raised salaries or reclassified employees wondering whether to undo that work. Federal overtime rules can change again, so check current guidance before making pay or classification decisions.
What is the salary threshold for exempt employees after the overtime rule was struck down?
As of December 2024, the federal threshold returned to the 2019 levels. In this episode, Rhamy gives the numbers as $35,568 a year as the minimum salary for the white collar exemptions, and $107,432 a year for highly compensated employees. There are no automatic increases, because the rule's plan to update the thresholds every three years was struck down along with it.
State law can set a higher bar. Some states, such as California, have higher thresholds that the federal ruling did not affect, so employers in those states still have to meet the state number. Salary is also only part of the test: an employee must meet the duties test for an exemption as well. Thresholds can change, so check current federal and state guidance.
Should I take back raises I gave to meet the 2024 overtime rule?
In most cases, Rhamy advises against it. If you raised salaries or reclassified employees to meet the July 2024 threshold, or were planning to for January 2025, undoing those changes now could feel like a betrayal to your team. Your employees are watching how you handle the reversal.
There is a middle path. Many employers have already built the new costs into their budgets. You could return to the old numbers for new hires, while leaving current employees' raises in place. Taking a raise back from people already receiving it is likely to lead to resignations, unless you are prepared for those personnel changes. Whatever you decide, make it a deliberate choice and explain the reasoning to the people it affects.
Do the FLSA duties tests still apply after the overtime rule was blocked?
Yes. The ruling changed the salary threshold, but the duties tests remain. An employee has to meet both the salary requirement and the duties test for an exemption to be classified as exempt, so misclassification can still cost you, both in fines and in credibility with your team.
In this episode, Rhamy points out that if preparing for the 2024 rule pushed you to review your employee classifications, that work was not wasted. Checking that people actually meet the duties test for their exemption is still very important. A good next step is to confirm that each exempt employee's salary meets the reverted threshold and that their real duties match the exemption, then make sure their job description reflects the work they do.
How should I explain overtime classification changes to employees?
Be honest, clear and empathetic, and tell people why. Whatever you decide after the 2024 overtime rule was blocked, whether that is rolling back adjustments, staying the course or reclassifying employees, your team deserves to understand the reasoning behind it.
In this episode, Rhamy frames the decision as a test of leadership rather than just compliance. The way you respond sets the tone for your team's trust. He encourages employers not to simply announce a change but to engage with employees, explain the why behind it and listen to their concerns. Transparent communication shows your team that you are a leader they can trust, even when the rules change mid-course.
How can employers prepare for future FLSA rule changes?
Build regular habits so the next change is a smaller disruption. In this episode, Rhamy notes that the 2024 overtime rule will not be the last compliance challenge, and the employers who handle these changes well are the ones who prepare.
He recommends three steps. First, review employee classifications and salaries every year rather than only when a rule forces it. Second, use tools or outside providers to simplify compliance and keep your processes consistent. Third, follow trusted updates so you know about changes before they take effect. Keeping job descriptions current is part of the same habit, since an accurate description of the work makes exemption decisions clearer and easier to defend.
About this episode
Don’t let this surprise ruling disrupt your business.
The 2024 FLSA Overtime Rule has been BLOCKED, throwing a major curveball for employers across the country. In this video, we break down exactly what this means for your business and what YOU need to do next to stay compliant. Whether you’ve already made adjustments or were preparing for upcoming changes, we’ll help you navigate this new legal landscape with confidence and clarity. 👉 What You'll Learn: • The key impact of the court’s decision on the 2024 FLSA Overtime Rule • Immediate actions you must take to stay compliant • How to keep your team engaged and trust intact despite changes • How to future-proof your business against future regulations


