Don't HR Alone · Episode 17

FLSA Overtime Exemptions: Big Changes Coming for Salaried Employees

May 1, 20249 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal

Many small businesses pay office staff a modest salary and treat them as exempt from overtime. In this episode, recorded in May 2024, Rhamy explains how the Department of Labor's new overtime rule would have changed that, and how employers were planning to respond.

As of May 2024, the rule raised the minimum salary for the white-collar exemptions under FLSA Section 13(a)(1) (executive, administrative, professional and certain computer roles) to $43,888 a year on July 1, 2024, and then to $58,656 on January 1, 2025. The duties tests did not change. Rhamy notes the $58,656 figure was set at the 35th percentile of salaried earnings in the lowest-cost census region, the South, and that the rule built in updates every three years. This 2024 rule was later struck down, so these thresholds describe the plan as of May 2024, not current law. Check current guidance before acting.

Rhamy illustrates the choices through Sarah, an administrator earning $43,000 who works long hours in busy seasons and leaves early in summer. Her employer could raise her salary to stay above the threshold, move her to hourly pay with overtime, or pay a non-exempt salary that still requires clocking in and overtime. Each option shifts cost and flexibility differently, for both the business and the employee.

The episode closes with a practical first step: list every salaried employee, sort them by which deadline would affect them, and make an individual plan for each, rather than waiting until the last minute.

Key takeaways

  • Before relying on any salary threshold, check current Department of Labor guidance, since the 2024 rule described here was later struck down.
  • List every salaried employee and compare each salary to the threshold that applies to them.
  • Remember that exemption requires meeting both a duties test and a salary test; a qualifying job title alone is not enough.
  • For each employee below the threshold, choose deliberately between a raise, hourly pay with overtime, or a non-exempt salary.
  • Talk with affected employees about how reclassification changes their pay, flexibility and schedule before making the switch.

What was the 2024 FLSA overtime salary threshold rule?

As of May 2024, a new Department of Labor rule, issued at the end of April 2024, raised the minimum salary an employee must earn to be exempt from overtime under the FLSA's white-collar exemptions. The standard threshold was set to rise to $43,888 a year on July 1, 2024, and then to $58,656 a year on January 1, 2025.

The change applied to the Section 13(a)(1) exemptions for executive, administrative, professional and certain computer-related employees. Those employees must meet both a duties test and a salary test. The rule changed only the salary test.

Rhamy notes that the rule also built in future updates every three years, so a raise to $58,656 might hold an employee in place for only about three years before the next increase.

This 2024 rule was later struck down, so these numbers describe the rule as of May 2024 and are not current law. Check current Department of Labor guidance for the threshold in effect today.

How was the $58,656 overtime salary threshold calculated?

According to the episode, the $58,656 figure was set at the 35th percentile of salaried earnings in the lowest-cost census region, which is the South.

Rhamy's reading of that number is that roughly 35 percent of salaried employees in the South would have needed either a raise or a move to hourly pay by January 1, 2025, a third of salaried workers in that region. He also points out that the rule baked the 35th percentile into future updates. Every three years, the Department of Labor would look at the salaried workforce again and reset the threshold at that same percentile, which means employers could have faced repeated increases.

This was the design of the 2024 rule as of May 2024. That rule was later struck down, so check current guidance for how the salary threshold is set now.

What are my options if a salaried employee falls below the overtime threshold?

Rhamy lays out three options, using the example of Sarah, an administrator earning $43,000 a year:

  1. Raise the salary above the threshold so the employee stays exempt. In the 2024 rule's case, that meant moving Sarah from $43,000 to more than $58,000.
  2. Move the employee to hourly pay. At $43,000, Sarah's rate works out to roughly $20 to $21 an hour. She would earn overtime in busy weeks, but less in slower weeks when she leaves early.
  3. Pay a non-exempt salary. Sarah keeps a flat salary but still clocks in and out and earns overtime for hours over 40. Rhamy notes this is uncommon and expensive, since the employer pays at least 40 hours even in short weeks and also pays overtime.

None of these is perfect. The right choice depends on the role, the budget and what works for the employee.

How does reclassifying salaried employees to hourly affect them?

Reclassification changes both pay and flexibility. In the episode's example, Sarah works late during peak project seasons and leaves early in summer to catch her son's baseball games. As a salaried employee, her pay stays steady through both.

If she moves to hourly, she earns overtime in heavy weeks but is paid less in light weeks. Rhamy notes several ways that can play out. It may work well for both sides. Or the employer may not be able to afford her overtime, which limits how much she can do in busy periods. Or, needing a steadier paycheck, she may look for extra work in summer instead of leaving early.

The common thread is that the employer loses some of the flexibility of a salaried role. Rhamy recommends that owners talk directly with affected employees, and that employees talk with their managers, to find the best path forward.

How should employers prepare for a change in the FLSA salary threshold?

Start with a list. Rhamy recommends pulling every currently salaried employee and sorting them by the deadline that affects them. Under the 2024 rule as of May 2024, that meant one group needing a decision by July 1, 2024, and another by January 1, 2025.

Then make a plan for each person. It does not have to be the same plan for everyone. Some employees may get raises to stay exempt; others may move to a non-exempt structure, which brings more management work, timekeeping and overtime pay.

Rhamy frames the decision as a balance of compliance, cost and care for employees. Raising salaries may stabilize the workforce, while reclassifying can give more flexibility to manage labor costs when workloads fluctuate. His strongest advice is not to wait until the last minute. Since the 2024 rule was later struck down, check current guidance for the threshold that applies today.

About this episode

Is YOUR Salary About to Change? The Department of Labor's (DOL) final rule on overtime exemptions increases minimum salary requirements for white-collar workers. A pivotal change set to take effect on July 1, 2024. These regulations will dramatically alter the salary threshold for exempt employees, impacting countless workers across the United States, including those like Sarah, who balances intense work periods with cherished personal time.

In this episode, you'll:

Understand the New Overtime Rule: What the increased salary threshold means and how it affects both employees and employers. The new salary requirements go into effect July 1st and January 1.

Real-Life Impact: Explore how these changes will reshape the work-life balance for employees like Sarah, who find themselves juggling between professional responsibilities and personal engagements.

Practical Strategies: Gain insights into how businesses can navigate these changes effectively without disrupting their operations or compromising employee satisfaction.

Expert Advice: Equip yourself with knowledge and strategies to ensure compliance and maintain efficiency in your workplace.

Whether you're an employer wondering how to adjust salaries and manage labor costs, or an employee concerned about how these changes might affect your work arrangement and income, this episode is packed with essential information to help you prepare for the upcoming changes.

👍 Like, comment, and share this video to help spread the word about these crucial updates!