Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 22
FLSA 2025 Salary Threshold Update: Are You Ready for the January 1st Increase?
Chapters (10)
Employers had barely finished adjusting to the July 2024 overtime changes when a much bigger increase loomed for January 2025. In this episode, recorded in October 2024, Rhamy walks through how to decide between raising salaries and reclassifying exempt employees, and how to handle the people side of that change.
As of October 2024, the Department of Labor's rule was set to raise the minimum salary for most exempt employees from $43,888 to $58,656 a year ($1,128 a week) on January 1, 2025, and the highly compensated employee threshold from $132,964 to $151,164. That rule was later blocked by a federal court and the salary minimum reverted to $684 a week, so the numbers here reflect the plan as of October 2024. Check current guidance before acting.
The decision framework still applies to any threshold change. Rhamy recommends listing exempt employees below the threshold, comparing the cost of raises against the cost of overtime, and checking for salary compression, since raising entry-level pay can squeeze the gap between staff and their managers. As a rough starting point, he suggests leaders earn about 20 percent more than the people they manage.
If employees are reclassified, communication matters most. Moving from salary to hourly can feel like a demotion, so explain the change early, train employees and managers on timekeeping and overtime, and set up a two-step timesheet approval. For employees who stay exempt, update job descriptions so they match the duties test. The episode closes with a reminder to check state rules, which can be stricter than federal law.
Key takeaways
- Check the current federal salary threshold before acting, since the January 2025 increase described here was later blocked.
- List every exempt employee who earns below the threshold and decide individually whether to raise pay or reclassify.
- Compare the long-term cost of salary increases against the cost of overtime before choosing.
- When you raise entry-level pay, check for salary compression and keep a meaningful gap between staff and their managers.
- Tell reclassified employees early and explain the change, since moving to hourly can feel like a demotion.
- Train reclassified employees and their managers on timekeeping, overtime and timesheet approval.
- For employees who stay exempt, make sure their job descriptions match the duties test, and check your state's rules too.
What was the January 2025 FLSA salary threshold?
As of October 2024, the Department of Labor's rule was set to raise the minimum salary for an exempt employee, in almost all of the white-collar exemption categories, to $58,656 a year, or $1,128 a week, on January 1, 2025. That followed a July 2024 increase to $43,888.
The same rule raised the threshold for highly compensated employees (HCEs) from $132,964 to $151,164. Rhamy notes that most organizations have few HCEs, but their pay still needed review.
A federal court later blocked the increase and the salary minimum reverted to $684 a week. The January 2025 numbers described here therefore reflect the rule as of October 2024, not current law. The planning steps in this episode still apply whenever a threshold changes. Check current Department of Labor guidance for the threshold in effect today.
Should I raise salaries or reclassify employees as non-exempt?
It depends on the employee and your budget, and both options carry costs. Rhamy frames it as a decision to make person by person.
Raising salaries keeps the employee exempt and preserves flexibility, but it is a long-term commitment. In the episode's example, an increase of $10,000 or more per employee is not a one-year fix, and it can trigger raises for managers to avoid salary compression.
Reclassifying to non-exempt makes the employee eligible for overtime and requires detailed time records. Overtime can be unpredictable and hard to budget, it adds administrative work, and employees used to flexible hours may struggle with timekeeping. It can also hurt morale, since many people see the switch as a demotion or a loss of autonomy.
Rhamy expects many employers to lean toward reclassification. Either way, his advice is to evaluate the cost of each option for each employee, plan for years ahead and not wait until the last minute.
What is salary compression and how do I avoid it?
Salary compression happens when pay for lower-level roles rises close to, or above, pay for the roles that manage them. A threshold increase can cause it quickly.
Rhamy's example: an entry-level role pays $48,000, a newer manager earns $55,000 and an experienced manager earns $65,000. Raise the entry-level role to $58,000 to keep it exempt, and the managers are suddenly earning about the same or less than the people they lead. You would need to adjust management and leadership pay too.
To avoid it, start with the employees below the threshold, then step back and review the pay structure above them. As a back-of-the-napkin starting point, Rhamy suggests that someone in charge of a team should earn about 20 percent more than the people they manage. He is clear that this is not exact and varies by industry, but being in charge takes real effort, and without a meaningful gap the role is not worth taking.
How do I move a salaried employee to hourly?
Treat it as a change project, not a payroll setting. Rhamy outlines the key pieces:
- Communicate early and openly. These conversations are not easy, and employees may feel demoted. Be transparent, empathize with their concerns and explain the benefit of overtime eligibility. Surprises that affect paychecks rarely go well.
- Train employees on timekeeping. They need to clock in and out, review their timesheets, fix errors and submit change requests when they forget to clock out.
- Train managers on their role. Direct supervisors know when people showed up, so they should review and sign off on time. Rhamy recommends at least a two-tier approval: the employee confirms the hours, then the manager approves them.
Mismanaging the transition can lead to penalties, fines and lawsuits, so allow real time to prepare rather than announcing the change a week before it takes effect.
What else should employers check when salary thresholds change?
Rhamy points to three things beyond the salary number.
Job descriptions. For employees you keep exempt, salary is only half the test. Make sure their job descriptions reflect the work they actually do and line up with the FLSA duties test, because misclassification can be very costly.
State law. Some states have stricter overtime rules or higher salary thresholds than federal law. Rhamy notes, for example, that California was already above the federal level, so employers need to be compliant on all fronts.
Legal challenges. In October 2024, some employers expected legal challenges to stop the January increase, as happened with the 2016 rule. Rhamy advised against gambling on that. The increase was in fact later blocked, but his broader point stands: failure to comply can mean fines, back pay claims and reputational damage, so plan for the rule on the books while watching for changes. Check current guidance.
About this episode
Is your business ready for the major FLSA salary threshold increase hitting in January 2025? This change could significantly impact your payroll, employee classifications, and bottom line.
In this episode, you'll: - Understand how the minimum salary for exempt employees jumps from $43,888 to $58,656 annually ($1,128 per week). - Discover key steps to avoid costly mistakes and ensure compliance with the new FLSA regulations. - Learn when to raise salaries or reclassify employees for optimal business outcomes.
👍 Like, comment, and share this video to help spread the word about these crucial updates!


