Don't HR Alone · Episode 13
Demotion: When It Hurts and When It Works
When an employee is failing in a role, or has been caught in misconduct, many managers reach for demotion because it feels kinder or safer than firing. In this episode, Rhamy explains why that instinct is usually wrong, and the narrow situation where a demotion does work.
Rhamy describes two common triggers: skill-based problems, where someone cannot meet the job's expectations, and disciplinary situations following an investigation. In both, he warns that a demotion is an adverse employment action. It carries the same legal risk as a termination and needs the same justification, so it is not a way to reduce the chance of a lawsuit. It also creates a disgruntled employee who stays inside the company for months, often next to the people they used to manage.
He contrasts two client cases from the same day. In the first, a company wanted to demote a newly hired director who was not ready to lead, mainly out of fear of a legal claim. Rhamy recommended treating it as a termination: set expectations, show the gap, give a fair chance to improve and document it. In the second, a long-time sales star promoted to director was struggling with budgeting, strategy and work across departments. The company offered him a choice between severance and returning to team lead, and he took the team lead role happily and has thrived since.
The episode closes with Rhamy's test: demotion only makes sense when there is a realistic path that keeps the employee and leaves them happy.
Key takeaways
- Do not use demotion as a softer or safer substitute for firing someone who cannot do the job.
- Treat a demotion as an adverse employment action that needs the same justification and documentation as a termination.
- Expect a demoted employee to be unhappy for at least a few months, and weigh that cost before deciding.
- Before any demotion or termination for performance, set clear expectations, show the gap and give a reasonable chance to improve.
- Consider demotion when a strong performer was promoted into a role that does not fit and would be happier in their former role.
- Offer the employee a real choice, such as severance or a step back to the role they excelled in.
Should I demote an employee instead of firing them?
Usually not. In this episode, Rhamy explains that most managers who ask about demotion either are afraid to fire someone or believe a demotion will hurt less. Neither is a good reason.
A demotion is not legally safer. Rhamy explains that a demotion is an adverse employment action and carries the same risk as a termination, so it needs the same justification. It is also often harder on the business. Nobody likes being demoted, especially with a pay cut, but even with the same pay the person now carries a lesser title and may be peers with people they used to manage. You end up with a disgruntled employee inside the company for months, often talking to coworkers about how they were treated. If someone cannot do the job, Rhamy's advice is to handle it as a termination done properly, not to soften it into a demotion.
Is a demotion legally risky?
Yes, as risky as a termination. In this episode, Rhamy explains that a demotion is an adverse employment action. From a legal claims perspective, demoting someone is just as dangerous as firing them, and the employer needs the exact same justification.
He gives the example of a client that wanted to demote, rather than fire, its only minority director because it believed a demotion would make a lawsuit less likely. Rhamy told them that reasoning was wrong: if the person cannot do the job, the employer is carrying the full risk either way.
The protection comes from the process, not the choice between demotion and termination. Lay out the job expectations, show the gap between those expectations and the employee's performance, give the employee a reasonable opportunity to close the gap in a professional, mentoring way, and document each step. That record shows the employer tried.
When does demoting an employee actually work?
When there is a realistic path that keeps the employee and leaves them genuinely happy. In this episode, Rhamy describes a salesperson with nearly eight years at a company who excelled in sales, then as a team lead over five salespeople. About four months after being promoted to director of sales over five teams, it was clearly not working.
The director job required budgeting, deciding raises, strategic planning and constant coordination with marketing, product development and accounting. He just wanted to sell. Rhamy recommended offering two paths: a severance, acknowledging the company's mistake in promoting him, or a step back to team lead. The employee took the team lead role happily. Two or three years later, Rhamy says, his team, one of five, brings in three-fifths of the company's sales, and he negotiated pay that now exceeds the director's. That is the kind of case where demotion makes sense.
How do you offer an employee a demotion?
Be direct about the gap and give them a real choice. In this episode, Rhamy recommends sitting down with the employee, walking through what the job requires, and explaining where you see them falling short. Then lay out the paths forward honestly.
In his sales director example, the conversation acknowledged that the employee was not ready for the director role and might never want it. The company then offered two options. The first was a severance, in that case two months, recognizing that the company had made a mistake by putting him in the role. The second was to step back down to team lead and focus on the sales work he was so good at.
The choice matters. It treats the employee with respect, makes clear the current situation cannot continue, and shows whether they genuinely want to stay in the role you are offering. A demotion someone chooses is far more likely to work than one imposed on them.
Should demotion be used as discipline for misconduct?
Rarely. In this episode, Rhamy describes disciplinary demotions as one of the two common reasons managers raise the idea. A manager is investigated for misconduct, and the company either is afraid to fire them or decides the behavior does not quite justify termination, so it reaches for demotion instead.
Rhamy's concern is that the same problems apply as with any demotion. It is an adverse employment action that needs the same justification as a termination, and it leaves an unhappy employee in the workplace. The decision should come back to the two things every performance evaluation rests on: behaviors, meaning whether the person acts professionally and is someone the team wants to work with, and skills. If the behavior is serious enough to warrant action, deal with it directly. In Rhamy's view, there are a few exceptions, but in general the answer is no demotions.
About this episode
In this video, we'll discuss the delicate subject of employee demotions and when and how to have the conversation. Learn about the potential benefits and drawbacks of demotions and how to handle them in a respectful and professional manner.
If you're facing the difficult decision of demoting an employee, this video will provide valuable insight and guidance. From tips on communication to understanding the legal implications, we'll cover everything you need to know about navigating the demotion process. Shield your business!


