Don't HR Alone · Episode 31

Employee Work Permit Expired Before Its Renewal? USCIS Extends Form I-9 Verification

January 23, 20256 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (6)

When a non-citizen employee's work permit is about to expire and their renewal is still stuck in processing, employers face a hard choice about whether that person can keep working. In this episode, Rhamy explains a USCIS change, announced as of January 2025, that gave employers far more breathing room.

He starts with the basics of Form I-9. Every new hire must complete it within the first three days of work to show they are allowed to work in the United States. U.S. citizens never need their documents reverified, but non-citizens with an expiring work permit or visa must be reverified when that document expires.

The problem was processing time. Employees can only apply to renew about six months before their document expires, and USCIS was rarely finishing renewals in that window. Under the old rule, proof of a pending renewal application for the same type of document only let an employee keep working for 180 more days. Rhamy describes a high tech client that had to lay off workers who were almost certain to be renewed.

Starting January 13, 2025, USCIS permanently extended that automatic extension from 180 days to 540 days, about a year and a half. Immigration rules change often, and this extension has since been changed for newer applications, so check current USCIS guidance before relying on it.

Rhamy closes with the process: track expiration dates for non-citizen employees, remind them to apply early, collect proof of the renewal application, and set a new reverification date.

Key takeaways

  • Complete Form I-9 for every new hire within their first three days of work.
  • Track document expiration dates for non-citizen employees, since their work authorization must be reverified when it expires.
  • Remind affected employees to apply for renewal as early as allowed, which Rhamy describes as about six months before expiration.
  • Collect proof that the employee applied to renew the same type of document, and set a new reverification date based on the extension in effect.
  • Check current USCIS guidance before applying the 540-day extension, since this January 2025 rule has since changed for newer applications.

Do I have to reverify an employee's I-9 when their work permit expires?

For non-citizens with temporary work authorization, yes. In this episode, Rhamy explains that when you hire someone, you complete Form I-9 within their first three days of work to confirm they are allowed to work in the United States. If the employee is not a U.S. citizen and their work permit or visa expires in a year or two, you have to come back at the expiration date and verify again that they are still authorized to work.

U.S. citizens are different. You do not reverify their documents, even if the driver's license they showed expires the next year. That makes tracking expiration dates for non-citizen employees an essential part of employment verification. Rules in this area change often, so check current USCIS guidance.

What is the USCIS 540-day automatic extension for work permits?

As of January 2025, when this episode was published, USCIS announced that starting January 13, 2025, it would permanently extend the automatic extension period for certain employment authorization documents from 180 days to 540 days, about a year and a half.

In practice, this applied when an employee's work permit was expiring and they had applied to renew the same type of document, but USCIS had not yet processed it. Under the old rule, proof of that pending application let the employee keep working for 180 more days. Under the January 2025 change, it covered 540 days. Rhamy noted at the time that there were no guarantees about what the next administration would do, and this extension has since been changed for newer applications. Check current USCIS guidance before relying on it.

Can an employee keep working while their work permit renewal is pending?

Under the rule described in this January 2025 episode, often yes, for a limited period. If an employee's work permit was expiring and they could show proof that they had applied to renew the same type of document, they could keep working during an automatic extension period while USCIS processed the renewal.

That period had been 180 days, and starting January 13, 2025, USCIS extended it to 540 days. Rhamy explains why this mattered: renewals could only be filed about six months before expiration, and almost no one was getting renewed within six months, so employers were being forced to let people go who were very likely to be approved. These rules have since changed for newer applications, so check current USCIS guidance before deciding whether an employee can keep working.

Why did slow USCIS processing cause layoffs?

Because the old 180-day extension often ran out before the renewal arrived. In this episode, Rhamy explains that employees could only apply to renew their work permit about six months before it expired. USCIS processing had fallen so far behind that almost no one was being renewed within six months, and few within a year.

Once the 180 days after expiration passed, the employer could no longer keep the person on the job, even with proof of a pending application. Rhamy describes a high tech client with many such employees who knew they would be renewed, yet around 90 percent were not renewed within six months and had to be laid off. Projects were delayed and the business lost people it wanted to keep.

How should employers track work permit expiration dates for I-9 compliance?

Build a simple, repeatable process. Rhamy lays out the steps in this episode. Complete the I-9 when each person starts and verify they are authorized to work. For non-citizen employees, record the expiration date on their work authorization document.

About six months before that date, remind the employee to apply for renewal as early as they can if they want to keep working. When the expiration date arrives, collect proof that they applied for the same type of document, then set a new reverification date based on the extension period in effect. As of January 2025, that was 540 days, but these rules have since changed for newer applications, so check current USCIS guidance. Keeping these dates in your HR system rather than in someone's memory avoids missed reverifications.

About this episode

Attention U.S. Employers! The 540-Day Work Permit Renewal Extension is now permanent—offering crucial relief for businesses facing delays in Employment Authorization Document (EAD) renewals. Starting January 13, 2025, the automatic renewal period for employees awaiting visa extensions will be extended from 180 to 540 days, giving employers more time to avoid layoffs and keep their workforce intact. In this episode, Rhamy Alejeal, CEO of People Processes, explains the impact of this change on Form I-9 verification and how it affects your hiring practices.