Don't HR Alone · Episode 36

🚨 ICE Audits Are Surging – Are Your I-9s Ready?

February 27, 202514 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (7)

A letter from the Department of Homeland Security asking to inspect your I-9 records is one of the more stressful things an employer can receive, especially when the files have not been checked in years. In this episode, Rhamy explains why I-9 audits were expected to rise in 2025 and how to run an internal audit before an agent asks.

Rhamy cites ICE audit numbers rising from around 1,400 in 2017 to 6,400 in 2019, with plans for 15,000 in 2020 before the pandemic interrupted them. As of February 2025, he expected another surge, with construction, agriculture and manufacturing most exposed. Auditors look for paperwork errors as well as unauthorized workers. He gives the penalty ranges in effect as of January 2025: $288 to $2,861 per form for paperwork violations, and $716 to $28,619 per individual for knowingly employing unauthorized workers. He describes a client that lost several employees in an audit and went out of business within weeks.

The internal audit he lays out starts with an audit log. Separate current and terminated employees, compare forms against payroll, complete any missing forms with a memo explaining the gap, and check every form for blanks and errors. Corrections are made on the form, initialed and dated, and recorded in the log, which shows good faith.

The episode closes with prevention: use the current form, train everyone who handles I-9s, consider E-Verify, and use software that flags missing forms and expiring documents. Enforcement and penalty amounts change, so check current guidance.

Key takeaways

  • Start an audit log that records each I-9 problem found, the corrective action taken and the dates it was identified and fixed.
  • Compare your payroll roster against your I-9 files and have any employee with a missing form complete one right away, with a memo explaining the gap.
  • Check Section 1 for blanks and enter N/A for anything that does not apply, such as a missing middle name or apartment number.
  • Correct errors directly on the form, ideally in a different colored pen, then initial and date the correction.
  • Keep terminated employees' I-9s for three years after the hire date or one year after termination, whichever is later.
  • Train everyone who completes I-9s, store the forms separately from personnel files and consider enrolling in E-Verify.

Are ICE I-9 audits increasing?

As of February 2025, when this episode was published, Rhamy expected them to. He cites ICE conducting around 1,400 audits in 2017, rising to 6,400 in 2019, with plans for 15,000 in 2020 before the pandemic disrupted those efforts. With renewed focus on immigration enforcement, he expected another surge.

He notes that construction, agriculture and manufacturing are the industries most likely to be targeted, and that businesses in those industries that do not use E-Verify are at higher risk. Audits range from a full inspection, where an agent asks to see your I-9 files, sometimes with only two or three days' notice, to smaller paper requests for a handful of recent hires. Enforcement priorities change, so check current guidance for your industry and state.

What are the fines for I-9 violations?

Rhamy gives the penalty ranges in effect as of January 2025. Paperwork violations alone, such as missing signatures, incorrect dates or incomplete forms, run from $288 to $2,861 per form. Knowingly employing unauthorized workers is separate and runs from $716 to $28,619 per individual, depending mainly on prior offenses. These amounts are adjusted over time, so check current figures.

The cost goes beyond fines. Rhamy describes a client that had an ICE audit in November. Seven or eight of its 30 to 40 employees were not authorized to work, and after losing them and then others who resigned in the turmoil during the holiday season, the business was closed by mid-December. He stresses that knowingly employing someone who is not authorized to work puts the entire business at risk.

How do I conduct an internal I-9 audit?

Rhamy lays out a step-by-step process:

  1. Create an audit log, such as a spreadsheet, to track every issue you find.
  2. Gather all I-9s and separate them into current and terminated employees.
  3. Compare against your payroll roster to find missing forms. Have those employees complete one promptly, and attach a memo explaining the oversight.
  4. Review each form for errors, starting with Section 1. No blanks are allowed: enter N/A for things like a missing middle name.
  5. Correct errors directly on the form, initial and date the change, and record it in the log. For major errors, complete a new form and keep the old one with it.
  6. Log unfixable errors for former employees too.

The audit log shows good faith if ICE arrives.

How do you correct a mistake on Form I-9?

Correct it directly on the form, then initial and date the change. Rhamy recommends using a different colored pen so the correction stands out. Record each correction in your audit log, noting what was wrong, when you found it and what you did. Electronic I-9 systems usually have their own correction process.

For major problems, such as badly transposed numbers from a passport, it can be easier to complete a new form. Keep the original, place the new form with it, and note the reason in the audit log. For employees who have already left, some errors cannot be fixed, such as a missing signature. Rhamy's advice is to document those in the log rather than create a new form, which still shows a good faith effort to comply.

How long do employers have to keep I-9 forms?

For current employees, keep an I-9 for everyone on payroll. For employees who have left, Rhamy explains that you must keep the form for three years after the hire date or one year after termination, whichever is later.

He gives two examples. If someone worked for you for five years and then leaves, you only need to keep their I-9 for one more year. If someone worked for you for three months, you have to keep it until three years after they were hired. During an internal audit, check that terminated employees' forms are retained for the right period. Rhamy also notes that most employers store I-9s separately from employee files, so the forms are easy to produce if an auditor asks for them.

Which version of Form I-9 should employers use?

Use the current version, because an outdated one does not count. As of February 2025, Rhamy says the acceptable version is the one dated August 1, 2023, with an expiration date of 2026 or 2027. He notes that a new version could follow, so check the USCIS site for the current edition before relying on this.

Using an old form is one of the most common mistakes he sees, along with incomplete forms, missing forms and failing to reverify employees whose work authorization expires. Even well-meaning employers get this wrong. A common example is a hiring manager who looks at an employee's ID and signs Section 2 without filling in the document information. Training everyone involved in hiring on the process prevents many of these errors.

Should a small business use E-Verify?

Rhamy suggests considering it, especially in higher-risk industries. E-Verify is a government online program that checks the information on an employee's I-9 against government records. Some employers are already required to use it, including certain government contractors and employers in states that mandate it, with size thresholds that vary by state.

If you are not required to use it, Rhamy recommends considering voluntary enrollment, particularly in construction, manufacturing or agriculture. In his view, clean E-Verify records that line up with the number of W-2s you issue lower your audit risk. He also recommends HR software or an HR provider that tracks I-9 compliance, flags missing forms and alerts you to upcoming expiration dates. Requirements change, so check current federal and state rules.

About this episode

Under the Trump administration, ICE Audits are on the rise—if an auditor knocked on your door tomorrow, would you be ready? Construction, agriculture and manufacturing industries may be more likely to be audited, and mistakes can cost up to $28,000 PER EMPLOYEE... not to mention the risk of business closure.

In this episode of Don’t HR Alone, Rhamy Alejeal, CEO of People Processes, breaks down what business owners & HR pros MUST do to stay compliant and avoid massive fines.

You’ll learn: - What triggers an I-9 audit (and industries at risk) - The biggest mistakes employers make & how to fix them - How to conduct a self-audit before ICE does it for you - E-Verify: Do you really need it? - Simple steps to protect your business starting today!