Don't HR Alone · Episode 9
Employer didn't withhold enough Federal Income Tax
Every W-2 season, employees come to their employer asking why not enough federal income tax came out of their paychecks, or why they got an unexpectedly large refund. In this episode, Rhamy explains how federal income tax withholding actually works and what employees can do about it.
The first point is that withholding is not the same as your taxes. Withholding is money taken from each paycheck and sent to the IRS in the employee's name, where it acts as a credit against the tax bill calculated when they file. That final bill depends on things the employer has no way of knowing, such as a spouse's income, a side business, rental income or other payments.
Employers calculate withholding by following IRS Publication 15-T, using the employee's taxable wages and the information on their Form W-4. Rhamy walks through the current W-4, which since the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act no longer uses a count of allowances. Instead, employees choose a filing status, can claim dependents as dollar amounts, and can add other income, deductions or extra withholding each pay period. He then shows how payroll turns a paycheck into an annual figure before applying the withholding tables.
The episode closes with the practical fix: if an employee owes a lot at tax time or gets too large a refund, the answer is usually not the paycheck but their W-4, so they should review it with their tax preparer and submit a new one. As of January 2024, check the current year's W-4 and Publication 15-T.
Key takeaways
- Explain to employees that withholding is a prepayment credited against their tax bill, not the tax itself.
- Calculate federal income tax withholding from IRS Publication 15-T using taxable wages and the employee's Form W-4.
- Remind employees that the employer cannot see outside income, a spouse's earnings or other deductions that change what they owe.
- Point employees who owe at tax time or get a large refund to update their W-4 rather than assuming payroll made an error.
- Have employees use W-4 Step 4 to add other income, deductions or a fixed extra amount to withhold each pay period.
- Collect a new W-4 from every new employee, and let employees submit a new one whenever their situation changes.
Why didn't my employer withhold enough federal income tax?
Usually, the paycheck is not the problem. In this episode, Rhamy explains that employers calculate withholding by following IRS Publication 15-T, based on the employee's taxable wages and the information on their Form W-4. If the W-4 does not reflect the employee's full situation, the amount withheld will not match what they owe.
The tax owed when someone files can differ widely from what was withheld, for reasons the employer cannot see: a spouse's income, a side business, rental income, annuity payments or other income, or deductions the employee does or does not qualify for. Withholding is a prepayment, not the final tax calculation. If an employee owes more than expected, or gets too large a refund, Rhamy's advice is to talk with whoever prepared their taxes, or read Publication 15-T, and decide what their W-4 should say for the next year.
What is the difference between withholding and income tax?
Withholding is money taken out of each paycheck and sent to the IRS on the employee's behalf. Income tax is what the employee actually owes for the year, calculated when they file their return. In this episode, Rhamy explains that the withheld money sits with the IRS as a credit against the employee's annual tax bill. When the return is filed, the IRS compares what has already been paid in with what is owed.
If more was withheld than owed, the employee gets a refund. If less was withheld, they owe the difference. Because the final bill depends on the employee's whole financial picture, including income and deductions the employer knows nothing about, the two numbers rarely match exactly. Understanding this distinction helps employees see that a large tax bill or refund usually points to their W-4 settings, not to a payroll mistake.
How does the current Form W-4 work?
In this episode, Rhamy walks through the W-4 used since the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, which no longer has employees write in a number of allowances.
- Filing status. Mark single or married filing separately, married filing jointly, or head of household.
- Dependents (optional). Employees with income of $200,000 or less, or $400,000 or less if married filing jointly, multiply the number of qualifying children under 17 by $2,000 and other dependents by $500.
- Other adjustments (optional). Step 4 lets employees add other income, claim other deductions, or set an extra amount to withhold each pay period.
Someone with significant rental income, for example, can list it in Step 4 so more is withheld from their paycheck. As of January 2024, these are the figures on the 2024 form; check the current year's W-4, since amounts can change.
How do employers calculate federal income tax withholding?
Employers follow IRS Publication 15-T, usually through payroll software. In this episode, Rhamy explains that the publication tells employers how much to withhold based on the information on the employee's Form W-4 and the taxable wages paid.
He walks through how it works. Payroll starts with taxable pay for the period, meaning gross pay minus any tax-qualified deductions, and multiplies it by the number of pay periods to get an annual amount. For example, $4,000 per semimonthly paycheck becomes $96,000 a year. Payroll then adds other income from the W-4, subtracts deductions and a standard amount based on filing status, such as $12,900 for married filing jointly in his example, and divides back down to a per-pay-period figure. That figure is matched to the withholding tables in Publication 15-T. As of January 2024, check the current year's Publication 15-T for updated amounts.
What is the difference between a W-2 and a W-4?
A W-4 tells the employer how much federal income tax to withhold from an employee's paychecks. A W-2 reports what the employee earned, and what was withheld, for the previous year. The employee fills out the W-4; the employer issues the W-2.
As the episode's show notes explain, every employee needs to complete a W-4, and submitting a new one is an important step with each new employer. Employees can also submit an updated W-4 at any time to change their withholding. An incorrectly completed W-4 can mean too little tax is paid during the year. Businesses of every size must issue W-2s. In this episode, Rhamy recommends that an employee who is surprised by their result at W-2 time review their return with their tax preparer and adjust their W-4 for the year ahead.
About this episode
Understanding withholding tax is crucial for financial control. Employers withhold a set amount from an employee's paycheck, directly remitting it to the IRS in their name. This withheld money acts as a credit against the employee's annual income tax bill.
Discover the reasons behind unexpected refunds and what happens when your employer falls short on Federal Income Tax withholdings!
🔍 Key Takeaways:
- Employees use the W-4 form to guide employers on tax withholding, based on factors like filing status, dependents, and deductions.
- Incorrectly filled W-4 forms may result in insufficient income tax payment throughout the year.
- Employees can adjust withholding by submitting a new W-4, a crucial step with each new employer.
🤔 Difference Between W-2 and W-4: W-4 informs the employer how much to withhold from an employee's paycheck. W-2 reports the employee's earnings to the IRS for the previous year. Small and large businesses must submit Form W-2, while every employee must file a W-4.
🚀 Maximize your financial knowledge and gain confidence in managing your tax withholdings. Whether you're a seasoned professional or a newcomer to the workforce, this episode provides valuable insights to navigate the complexities of tax season.


