Don't HR Alone · Episode 46

Fired an Employee? They Might Still Get Unemployment

May 8, 202510 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (9)

An owner lets someone go, maybe for poor performance, maybe for something serious like theft, and then a notice arrives that the former employee has filed for unemployment. Many owners assume a firing means no benefits. In this episode, Rhamy explains what actually disqualifies someone and how to respond to claims so you are not blindsided.

Unemployment claims affect both budget and workload, and mishandled claims can lead to higher insurance premiums and unexpected costs. Rhamy stresses that most employees are not trying to game the system. The system is confusing for everyone.

He walks through seven common reasons a person may be disqualified: quitting without good cause, being fired for misconduct, refusing suitable work, not looking for work, receiving severance or wages in lieu of notice, not being able or available to work, and misrepresenting the facts of their claim. A key distinction is that poor performance is a legitimate reason to terminate, but it is not misconduct, so the person will likely still qualify.

The episode closes with an employer playbook: document every exit, put severance amounts and the period they cover in writing, send job offers and changes in writing, and respond to claim notices promptly. Rhamy says employers often have around 10 business days, and a late reply can mean the claim is approved by default. Rules vary by state, so check your state's current requirements.

Key takeaways

  • Keep resignation emails, written warnings and termination notes for every exit so the reason for separation is clear.
  • Do not expect a termination for poor performance or poor fit to block unemployment, since that is generally not misconduct.
  • Put any severance or wages in lieu of notice in writing, including the amount and the number of weeks it covers, and include it in your claim response.
  • Send rehire offers and changes to someone's role in writing with title, pay, location and start date, and ask for a written acceptance or refusal.
  • Respond to every unemployment claim notice before your state's deadline, including accurate pay information.
  • When answering a claim, share only what you know and what the employee disclosed, and do not speculate.

Can an employee get unemployment if they are fired?

Often, yes. In this episode, Rhamy explains that not every firing disqualifies someone. Being fired for misconduct can, and he lists violence, theft, harassment, drug violations and repeated, well-documented policy breaches as examples. Mediocre performance, attitude problems or not being a good fit generally do not count as misconduct.

That is an important distinction. Poor performance is a completely legitimate reason to terminate someone, and Rhamy says it is why most people should be terminated. But the person will still likely qualify for unemployment because it was not misconduct. The same goes for layoffs, which he calls the most common reason someone receives benefits.

Misconduct determinations normally require an investigation and a conclusion. If you believe a termination was for misconduct, you need documentation that supports it. Rules vary by state, so check how your state defines misconduct.

What disqualifies someone from unemployment benefits?

The episode covers seven common disqualifiers:

  1. Quitting without good cause. Good cause exceptions include unsafe conditions, harassment, military spouse relocation and medical issues with proof.
  2. Being fired for misconduct, such as violence, theft, harassment, drug violations or repeated documented policy breaches.
  3. Refusing suitable work, meaning a job with similar pay, skills and conditions.
  4. Not actively looking for work. Most states require job hunting.
  5. Severance or wages in lieu of notice, which can delay benefits, and in some states unused PTO payouts can too.
  6. Not being able or available to work, such as recovering from surgery or traveling abroad.
  7. Misrepresentation, such as claiming a layoff after quitting or hiding side work.

Several of these make someone only temporarily ineligible. Eligibility rules are set by each state, so check your state's current requirements.

Can an employee get unemployment if they quit?

Usually not, but there are exceptions. In this episode, Rhamy explains that most people who quit voluntarily are not eligible for unemployment unless they had good cause. The good cause examples he gives are unsafe working conditions, harassment, military spouse relocation and medical issues with proof.

He flags medical situations in particular. Some people become too sick to keep doing their job and have to quit, and smaller employers may not be required to provide protected leave. In that situation the person may still qualify for unemployment.

For employers, the practical step is to know why someone is leaving and keep a record of it. Save resignation emails, letters and exit notes, and make sure the reason recorded is clear and is the employee's own. Someone who quits to go back to school, for example, has left voluntarily for a reason that generally does not qualify. State rules differ, so check yours.

Does severance affect unemployment benefits?

It can. Rhamy calls this the area where many companies trip up. As explained in this episode, if you paid severance or wages in lieu of notice, the state may delay the start of benefits by the number of weeks that payment covers. Depending on the state, payouts for unused PTO can have the same effect.

The point is that if you have already paid someone through severance, you should not end up paying again through unemployment insurance. Severance is common in terminations that are not driven by misconduct and in layoffs, which are the most common reason someone receives benefits.

To make it count, keep a record of how much you paid and how many weeks of regular pay it covers, put that in writing at the time of separation, and include it in your response to the unemployment claim. Rules on severance and PTO payouts differ by state, so check your state's current guidance.

What counts as refusing suitable work for unemployment?

Suitable work, as described in this episode, is a position with similar pay, skills and conditions to what the person was doing. If you offer someone their job back or another suitable position and they turn it down without a valid reason, they may be disqualified, because declining it looks more like quitting than being let go.

Rhamy applies the same logic to changes in duties. If you adjust someone's role and they quit over it, but the new work has similar pay, skills and conditions, that may count as refusing suitable work.

The protection is documentation. Always send rehire offers and job description changes in writing, including job title, pay, location and start date, and ask for a written acceptance or refusal. An email reply will normally do, but a signature on the actual job description is even better. Having a record of what the person did before and what you offered helps you answer a claim. State standards vary.

How long do employers have to respond to an unemployment claim?

In this episode, Rhamy says employers normally have about two weeks, often 10 business days, to respond once they receive a claim notice by mail or electronically. If you miss the deadline, the claim can be approved by default, and you have effectively not contested it. Deadlines are set by each state, so check yours.

Not every claim needs to be contested. If you laid someone off, or let them go because they were not a good fit, they will likely get benefits and that is fine. But you usually still need to reply, both to contest a claim where you have grounds and to confirm how much the person was paid. Rhamy notes some claimants report higher pay than they earned, which would raise their benefit.

A basic response covers payroll information, whether you are contesting the claim, and if so why, with supporting documents. Share only what you know, and if you have documentation that contradicts a claim, include it.

How should employers prepare for unemployment claims?

The episode lays out a playbook to follow for every exit:

  1. Document everything. Save resignation emails, written warnings and termination notes.
  2. Clarify severance. Put the payout and the period it covers in writing.
  3. Send offers in writing. Whether it is a rehire, an alternative job or an original hire, document it and get an acknowledgment.
  4. Respond to claims promptly. Meet your state's deadline so the claim is not approved by default.
  5. Systematize the process. Exit workflows should log documents, alert payroll and prepare claim responses.

Rhamy's view is that unemployment claims are not scary if you are prepared. You need to know how much the employee was paid and whether they quit or were terminated for a reason that qualifies, or whether they are eligible at all. With records in place, you can respond clearly, confidently and compassionately. Check your state's current rules.

About this episode

You fired someone for misconduct—or poor performance—and days later, you get hit with their unemployment claim. Can they really still qualify?

In this episode of Don't HR Alone, Rhamy Alejeal breaks down exactly what disqualifies an employee from receiving unemployment benefits—even when they quit or you terminated them. He covers the 7 official disqualifiers, common employer mistakes, and how to protect your business with smart systems and better documentation. 👉 If you've ever been blindsided by an unemployment claim, this episode is a must-watch.