Don't HR Alone · Episode 23

FLSA Compliance for Inside Sales Reps: Avoid Misclassification & Overtime Penalties

October 23, 20248 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (7)

Many businesses pay their phone-based customer service and inside sales staff a good salary plus commission and treat them as exempt from overtime. In this episode, recorded in October 2024, Rhamy explains why that classification is often wrong and what it can cost.

Exempt employees are not entitled to overtime and typically work in executive, administrative or professional roles, where both the job duties and the salary must meet specific criteria. Everyone else is non-exempt by default and earns overtime for hours over 40 in a workweek. That includes some salaried employees who do not meet a duties test.

As of October 2024, Rhamy points to a recent First Circuit ruling involving a parts distributor that classified its inside sales reps as administrative employees. The court found their primary duty was making sales, which did not meet the administrative exemption. His takeaway: if your customer service or phone team routinely makes sales, they are likely misclassified as exempt, even if they are well paid. The exposure includes back pay for overtime going back two or three years, penalties and potential lawsuits, and missing time records can make the back pay larger.

The fix has four steps: audit the classification of anyone involved in sales, estimate the added overtime cost, communicate the change openly because it can feel like a demotion, and set up time tracking and payroll for overtime. The episode closes with a reminder that state overtime rules, such as daily overtime, can differ from federal law. Check current guidance for your state.

Key takeaways

  • Review the classification of every phone-based customer service or inside sales employee whose work is primarily selling.
  • Do not rely on the administrative exemption for employees whose primary duty is making sales.
  • Remember that a good salary alone does not make someone exempt; the job duties must also qualify.
  • Estimate the added overtime cost before reclassifying, and consider schedule adjustments to manage it.
  • Explain reclassification openly to affected employees, including the benefit of overtime pay.
  • Set up time tracking and update payroll so overtime is calculated correctly, including under your state's rules.

Are inside sales reps exempt from overtime?

Often, no. As of October 2024, Rhamy points to a recent First Circuit ruling that inside sales representatives were not exempt from FLSA overtime requirements, clarifying what he describes as a long-standing position.

The case involved a parts distributor that classified its inside sales reps as administrative employees. The reps took calls from customers, handled problems and took orders, such as a customer calling in for 300 of a particular part. The court found that their primary duty was making sales, not administering part of the business, so they did not meet the administrative exemption.

Rhamy's practical rule: if your customer service or phone team routinely or consistently makes sales, they are likely improperly classified as exempt. That is true even when they sit at desks next to genuinely exempt staff, are paid a salary and earn commission. Classification depends on duties, not just pay or setting. Check current guidance and your state's rules.

What is the difference between exempt and non-exempt employees?

Under the FLSA, exempt employees are not entitled to overtime pay. They typically work in executive, administrative or professional roles, and to qualify, both their job duties and their salary must meet specific criteria. The salary piece means a guaranteed amount of pay each week.

Non-exempt is the default. Non-exempt employees are entitled to minimum wage and to overtime when they work more than 40 hours in a workweek. That covers nearly all hourly workers and, importantly, some salaried employees who do not meet a duties test, such as inside sales reps whose main job is selling.

The key point for employers is that paying someone a salary does not by itself make them exempt. In Rhamy's opening example, a team paid $60,000 a year in salary plus commission on every deal still faces back pay and penalties because their duties did not qualify for an exemption.

What happens if I misclassify employees as exempt?

The costs can be significant. Rhamy lists three main risks:

  • Back pay. You may be ordered to pay overtime for hours worked going back two or three years. If you never tracked their hours because you treated them as exempt, the estimated numbers can be quite large.
  • Penalties for failing to properly pay employees money they were owed at the time.
  • Lawsuits if employees take action over unpaid overtime.

He adds that there is also reputational damage from being associated with any labor law violation.

Beyond the legal exposure, fixing a misclassification affects the business. Reclassifying employees can hurt morale and operational efficiency, so the transition needs to be handled carefully while still staying within legal boundaries. Rhamy's advice is to act now rather than wait for a letter about misclassification to arrive.

How do I reclassify sales employees as non-exempt?

Rhamy lays out four steps:

  1. Conduct a classification audit. Review every classification, especially phone-based inside sales and customer service staff. Look at anyone taking orders, anyone whose duties focus primarily on selling, and anyone paid spiffs or commission. Even purely salaried employees who mostly take orders may not qualify for the administrative exemption.
  2. Estimate overtime costs. Calculate the additional payroll you will need. Busy seasons often push these roles past 40 hours, so consider adjusting schedules to manage costs.
  3. Communicate the change. Moving from exempt to non-exempt can feel like a demotion. Explain openly why compliance matters and how it benefits employees, including access to overtime pay.
  4. Update payroll and time tracking. If you treated these employees as exempt, you may not track their hours. Put time tracking tools in place and update payroll to calculate overtime accurately.

Do state overtime rules differ from the FLSA?

Yes. Rhamy notes that the FLSA is federal law, and each state also has its own rules about overtime and minimum salary. Most states follow the federal approach, but the details vary.

The biggest practical difference is when overtime starts. Under federal law, overtime is owed for hours over 40 in a workweek. Depending on the state, an employer may also owe overtime after eight hours in a single day or for working a sixth or seventh day in a row.

That matters for anyone reclassifying sales or customer service staff. Your time tracking and payroll setup need to calculate overtime according to the rules for the state where each employee works, not only the federal 40-hour rule. Check your state's current overtime rules when setting up the system.

About this episode

The First Circuit Court ruled that inside sales representatives are not exempt from FLSA overtime requirements, making them eligible for overtime pay. In this episode of the People Processes Podcast, we'll discuss how misclassifying your sales team can lead to significant legal and financial consequences. We’ll guide you through essential steps to ensure your business stays compliant and protected.

Share your thoughts in the comments below! Have you ever faced issues with employee classification?