Don't HR Alone · Episode 10
How to Create an Incentive Compensation Program That Works
Many owners either pay a flat salary and leave performance on the table, or put people on commission in roles where they cannot control the results. In this episode, Rhamy explains how to design an incentive compensation program that actually changes behavior.
He starts with industry norms: where a market has a common pay structure, there is usually a reason, so iterate from it rather than inventing something new. Then he works from total target income, the amount a great performer in the role should earn, and decides how much of it to put at risk. Rhamy's rules of thumb are that about 8% at risk is the minimum to affect behavior and around 50% is a highly incentivized role, with outside sales often above that. The more control a person has over results, the more of their pay can be at risk.
Rhamy then covers what to measure and how often to pay. Easy-to-measure roles can tie incentives to clear numbers, while harder roles should blend competencies, behaviors tied to core values and specific goals. Faster payout cadence influences behavior more, as long as it does not bury the company in paperwork. He explains when to use commissions versus bonuses, and why every revenue role needs a quota and a breakeven point.
The episode closes with the two most common mistakes he sees: full commission in roles without full control, and no incentive program at all.
Key takeaways
- Start from your industry's usual pay structure and adjust it, rather than designing incentives from scratch.
- Set a total target income for each role based on what a great performer should earn, then decide how much is at risk.
- Put at least about 8% of target pay at risk if you want the incentive to change behavior.
- Give more at-risk pay to roles with more control over results, from frontline staff up to executives.
- Pay incentives as often as the goal can be measured, since faster payouts influence behavior more than an annual bonus.
- For revenue roles, set a quota tied to target income and know the breakeven point where the role covers its own cost.
- Avoid full commission for roles that do not control their results.
What is total target income in compensation design?
Total target income, or TTI, is the amount you would pay a great performer in a role if everything goes well. In this episode, Rhamy calls it the basis of most compensation schemes. A company should research and benchmark it for each position, whether that is outside or inside sales, an executive, a manager or a frontline customer service role.
His example is a project manager. If they nail the job, the company wants to pay them $200,000 a year. If things go only okay, they might earn $150,000 to $170,000. That spread is the at-risk compensation: the portion of target income the person may or may not earn depending on their performance. The at-risk portion is what you use to move people from average to excellent. A useful way to set it is to treat great as the total target and think about where good would land.
What percentage of pay should be incentive or bonus pay?
In this episode, Rhamy gives these rules of thumb for how much of total target income to put at risk:
- About 8% is the minimum to affect behavior. He notes some put the figure as low as 6% and others at 10%. On a $100,000 salary, an $8,000 annual bonus is roughly the floor.
- 8% for frontline roles such as customer service reps, who have less control over results.
- 12% to 15% for department managers.
- Up to 50% for vice presidents and C-level executives, who have a large impact on how the business runs, and for highly incentivized roles like car sales, where a $40,000 salary might carry an $80,000 target.
- Above 50% is normally outside sales.
The principle is that the more control a person has over results, the more of their pay can be at risk.
How often should incentive pay be paid out?
As often as the goal can reasonably be measured. In this episode, Rhamy explains that a faster cadence influences behavior better, but the more complex the goal, the more work a fast cadence creates.
For simple, measurable results, pay quickly. A car salesperson sells a car and gets paid, and inside sales can be paid monthly, weekly or even daily. A project manager might be paid after each project closes, or monthly based on average on-time and on-budget results. Executives running large departments often have compensation that is effectively annual or even multi-year, because their results take longer to show.
Rhamy points out the weakness of an annual bonus: an 8% bonus paid once a year feels like an extra month's pay, but people tend to focus on it only in the few months around the payout. Aim for the fastest cadence you can run without drowning in administration.
What should a bonus be based on for roles without clear KPIs?
A mix of competencies, behaviors and goals. In this episode, Rhamy explains that some roles, such as a customer service manager or head of graphic design, do not have simple numbers to measure. For those, he recommends tying incentives to three things, the same structure as a typical performance review:
- Competencies, meaning the skills the person has and goals to build more, including handling more complex issues.
- Behaviors, which People Processes calls core values, often measured through peer reviews. An excellent accountant who is difficult to work with is still a problem.
- Goals, such as increasing sales by 3% or reducing returns.
For roles with clear numbers, such as cars sold, projects completed on time and on budget, or an insurance renewal rate, it is much easier to build the incentive on that number alone. Rhamy cautions against getting too caught up in pure goal setting for complex roles.
What is the difference between a commission and a bonus?
A commission is a percentage of a sale. A bonus is a payment tied to performance, often through a review on a monthly, quarterly or annual schedule. In this episode, Rhamy explains that commissions are the most direct and easiest to calculate, which is why they suit outside and inside sales. For example, a dealership might pay a flat amount per car plus a percentage of the ticket value.
Bonuses are the most common form of incentive and the traditional way to reward more complex results. A store manager might earn a quarterly bonus based on how the store performs. A project manager might earn a bonus at the end of each project. Rhamy's example: if 25% of total target income is at risk and the person runs five projects a year, each project bonus could be a flat amount of about 5% of target. The two can also be combined, such as commission paired with a quota for inside sales.
How do you set a sales quota and breakeven point?
Set the quota at the level that earns total target income, and separately know the breakeven point where the role covers its own cost. In this episode, Rhamy explains that hitting quota should earn the target, and the plan can let people earn more once they exceed it.
Breakeven applies mainly to sales, revenue and management roles with a financial component. Work out how much the person needs to sell to cover their base pay, based on your labor budget or net profit rather than gross revenue. Rhamy's example: if a $1,000,000 quota earns $200,000 a year, can $500,000 in sales cover a $100,000 salary and still leave a healthy business? If so, that is roughly the breakeven. For a role with 50% at risk, breakeven is often around half the quota.
Employees do not need to know the breakeven number, but Rhamy's view is that someone who falls below it has to be let go.
About this episode
Incentive compensation programs are primarily used to promote the efficiency and productivity of the workforce. Many organizations view incentives as an important tool for improving performance.
In this episode, learn the art and science behind crafting effective incentive programs.🔍 Explore the ins and outs of overall compensation design, with a specific focus on incentive pay. From bonuses to commissions, Rhamy guides you through building a customized compensation scheme that shapes behavior and drives results. 💡
Tune in to gain a competitive edge in talent management and business success. 🔥 Don't miss this opportunity to revolutionize your approach to incentives and maximize your team's potential.


