Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 53
Stop Losing Your Best People — Build Incentive Compensation Plans That RETAIN Top Talent
Chapters (7)
Many incentive programs feel random to the people they are meant to motivate. In this episode, Rhamy tells the story of a client who gave a top employee a $10,000 bonus, only to see that employee quit two months later. The employee had no idea why they earned it or whether they ever would again, and left for a company that spelled out how its bonuses could be earned.
Rhamy explains that incentives are messages: they tell the team what matters. Citing WorldatWork, he notes that 93% of private companies offer short-term incentive plans, yet most do not tie them to the behaviors that move the business forward.
The framework starts with Total Target Income (TTI), the amount a top performer in a role should earn, and then backs into how much is base pay and how much is at risk. A project manager worth $200,000 might get $160,000 in salary and $40,000 in performance pay. Rhamy then covers the three broad structures (commissions, bonuses and quota-based pay) and why payout cadence matters, since a smaller payout delivered fast beats a large one that arrives too late.
He walks through four common mistakes: tying pay to results people cannot control, having no incentive program at all, vague or moving targets, and paying too slowly. The episode closes with how to run the program once it is designed: track it with the right tools, communicate often, and review it every quarter.
Key takeaways
- Define Total Target Income for each role first, then decide how much of it should be base pay and how much should be at risk.
- Match the at-risk share to how much of the result the person actually controls, from around 10% for operations up to 50% or more for sales and executives.
- Choose the structure that fits the role: commissions for closing deals, bonuses for hitting set goals, and quota-based pay for leaders whose goals shift.
- Pay incentives as close to the behavior as you can, because a smaller payout delivered quickly motivates more than a large one that comes late.
- Make every goal clear enough that employees can keep their own scorecard, and be careful about changing targets midstream.
- Review the incentive plan quarterly and tell employees up front that it will be adjusted, so changes are not a surprise.
What is Total Target Income in compensation planning?
Total Target Income, or TTI, is what a top performer in a role should be able to earn in total. In this episode, Rhamy recommends setting it before talking about bonuses at all. Picture the ideal person in the job, such as a customer service rep who is always on time, never unexpectedly absent, great on the phone and well reviewed, and ask what that person is worth.
Once TTI is set, you back into the split between salary and variable pay. Rhamy's example is a project manager worth $200,000 a year: perhaps $160,000 in base salary and $40,000 in performance pay, which puts 20% of compensation at risk. That at-risk portion becomes the lever for driving performance. The point is to make the plan intentional rather than accidental, and to base the variable portion on measurable results the person controls.
How much of an employee's pay should be at risk or variable?
It depends on how much of the result the person controls. In this episode, Rhamy gives rough ranges: a sales role might have up to 50% at risk, operations roles around 10 to 15%, and executives at some large companies 50% or even 100%. In his recap, he frames a reasonable range as between 10 and 50%.
Control is the deciding factor. An independent insurance agent who finds, sells, writes and services their own business commonly works on 100% commission. A car salesperson cannot control how many people walk onto the lot, so a typical target is about 50% of TTI at risk. A customer service rep cannot control call volume or complaints caused by sales or the product, so they should have much less at risk. A CEO owns the company's results, so a very high share can make sense.
What are the main types of incentive compensation?
In this episode, Rhamy describes three broad types:
- Commissions, best for roles where closing a deal or finishing a project equals clear value. They are simple and direct, but they really only work when the person controls the whole sales pipeline.
- Bonuses, fixed payouts for hitting specific goals, such as completing a project under budget, boosting client retention or improving a safety score.
- Quota-based compensation, a mix of salary and performance thresholds, suited to leadership roles or inside sales where goals shift from quarter to quarter.
Not every incentive has to be tied to revenue. Rhamy notes that incentives can reward innovation, mentorship, turnover, quality, customer satisfaction or retention, whichever outcomes actually matter to the business.
How often should bonuses and incentives be paid out?
As often as the role allows. In this episode, Rhamy says timing is everything: the faster the payout, the stronger the motivation. Sales roles might be paid daily or weekly, sales reps on a complex product monthly, and managers or executives quarterly or annually.
What does not work is an annual bonus no one hears about until December. If it is not connected to the person's actions, it is not a motivator, just a surprise. People need reinforcement while the behavior is happening, so look for ways to tighten the cycle and reward more often. Rhamy's rule of thumb is that a smaller payout delivered fast beats a big one that comes too late. He sums up what every plan needs as clarity, control and cadence.
What are common mistakes in employee bonus programs?
In this episode, Rhamy walks through four traps he sees often:
- Tying pay to something the person cannot control. Making someone's whole paycheck hinge on a pipeline they do not manage is paralyzing, not motivating.
- Having no incentive program at all. Relying only on salary or hourly pay misses a chance to guide and reinforce performance.
- Vague goals or moving targets. If people do not understand how they earn the bonus, it is worthless and it erodes trust. Employees should be able to track the measure themselves and keep their own scorecard.
- Paying too slowly. Delayed payout means delayed motivation and delayed results.
Rhamy also warns that changing goals midstream can have major morale effects, so set expectations about when the plan will be revisited.
How big does a bonus need to be to change employee behavior?
Big enough to matter relative to pay. In this episode, Rhamy recommends that even service-oriented roles have something at risk, and he cites research suggesting that around 8.25% of compensation is enough to create significant differences in behavior. In practice he rounds that to about 10%.
His example: someone who earns $10 an hour and can earn a $1 an hour bonus will go a long way for it. If the bonus is only 25 cents an hour, they may not take as much action as you would expect. Size is not the only factor, though. A bonus also has to be clearly understood and paid quickly to drive behavior.
How do you manage an incentive compensation plan after launch?
Designing the plan is only the first step. In this episode, Rhamy outlines three habits for running it well. First, use the right tools. A spreadsheet works if you have to, but dashboard software that tracks KPIs, automates bonus reports and keeps you audit ready is better. Second, communicate clearly and often about how the plan works, how people are doing and when they will be paid, because a lack of communication breeds suspicion and confusion. Third, review the plan quarterly.
Rhamy says most companies fail not because they picked the wrong metric but because they stopped managing and updating it. If you tell employees up front that the plan will be adjusted at set times, changes are not a surprise and you avoid the morale hit. Leaving the same plan locked in for years creates an unwritten expectation that it will never change.
About this episode
Want to fix broken bonus plans before they cost you your best people?
Want an incentive plan that drives revenue—not resignations?
Confused bonus plans are driving your top talent out the door. One client gave a $10K bonus — and the employee still quit. Why? Because unclear incentives cause more damage than no incentives at all.
In this episode of Don’t HR Alone, Rhamy Alejeal breaks down: • How to design compensation plans that actually drive performance • What “Total Target Income” is — and why you must define it • The 3 types of incentive comp (and which to use when) • Common bonus mistakes that erode trust • Why even a small bonus can outperform a big one — if timed right


