Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 37
New York Employees Can Now Claim Workers Comp for Workplace Stress! Are You Ready?
Chapters (6)
Every job has stressful days, but New York employers now face a harder question: when does workplace stress become a workers' compensation claim? In this episode, Rhamy explains a New York change, signed by Governor Kathy Hochul, that took effect January 1, 2025, and what employers should do about it. This page reflects the law as of March 2025, so check current guidance.
Under the change, employees can file workers' compensation claims for extraordinary work-related stress without proving that their stress is worse than what is normal for their job or worse than their coworkers' stress. The law does not define extraordinary stress, so the Workers' Compensation Board will decide claims case by case. Stress can come from a single event or build up over time, and claims need medical documentation.
Rhamy expects more mental health related claims, higher workers' compensation premiums and added legal costs for employers who contest claims. One possible upside is fewer emotional distress lawsuits, since some employees may file through workers' compensation instead. He also explains that employees can still sue in some situations, such as when an employer lacks proper coverage or the claim involves intentional emotional distress.
The episode closes with practical steps: review workers' compensation coverage, document workplace stressors, make job descriptions match the real workload, train managers to handle stress complaints and strengthen employee support programs. Rhamy also notes that other states are watching New York and may follow.
Key takeaways
- Review your workers' compensation coverage with your carrier to understand how stress-related mental health claims will be handled.
- Document workplace stressors such as excessive overtime, tight deadlines and management issues, since records are your best defense if a claim is filed.
- Make sure job descriptions reflect the real workload and pressure of each role, so they can show what stress is expected in the job.
- Train managers to respond well to employee stress complaints before a small issue grows into a claim or lawsuit.
- Strengthen employee support programs and mental health resources to reduce stress before it becomes a claim.
Can New York employees get workers' comp for workplace stress?
Yes, under a change that took effect January 1, 2025, as described in this March 2025 episode. Employees in New York can file workers' compensation claims for extraordinary work-related stress. The amendment, signed by Governor Kathy Hochul, removed the need for employees to prove that their stress is worse than what is normal for their job or worse than what their coworkers experience.
Rhamy notes that the law does not define what counts as extraordinary stress. That will be decided case by case by the New York Workers' Compensation Board. Stress can come from a single event or build up over time, and employees will need medical documentation to support a claim, although that does not stop them from filing one. Because the law is new and will be shaped by board decisions, check current guidance.
What counts as extraordinary work-related stress in New York?
The law does not say. In this episode, Rhamy explains that New York's amendment leaves extraordinary stress undefined, so each claim becomes a judgment call by the Workers' Compensation Board. What is clear, as of March 2025, is that employees do not have to prove their stress is worse than their coworkers', that the stress can come from one event or accumulate over time, and that medical documentation is required.
Rhamy points to high-pressure roles such as emergency room nurses and corporate attorneys. Stress is built into those jobs, so a claim that it became extraordinary will be hard to judge. That is one reason he recommends that employers make sure job descriptions describe the real pressures of each role. Board decisions will shape the definition over time, so check current guidance.
How will New York's workplace stress law affect employer costs?
Rhamy expects costs to rise. In this episode, he explains that more mental health related claims will likely mean higher workers' compensation insurance premiums, since more claims lead to higher costs. Employers who contest claims should also expect legal fees and compliance costs.
There may be one offsetting effect. Some employees who might otherwise sue for emotional distress damages may file a workers' compensation claim instead, which could reduce some lawsuits. Rhamy describes the overall financial picture as mixed, but says the law shifts risk onto employers. He also notes that other states are watching New York, so employers outside the state may see similar laws. This reflects the law as of March 2025; check current guidance.
Can employees still sue employers for workplace stress if workers' comp applies?
Sometimes. Rhamy explains that the workers' compensation exclusivity rule usually means an employee who receives workers' compensation cannot also sue the employer for the same injury. That is why the New York change could reduce some emotional distress lawsuits.
He describes two big exceptions. First, if an employer does not carry proper workers' compensation insurance, employees may be able to sue. Second, an employee may still bring a claim for intentional emotional distress, such as one tied to harassment or a toxic work environment. So while the law may move some disputes into the workers' compensation system, employers still need strong HR policies and good management to keep complaints from escalating. Check current guidance with counsel, since this area is evolving.
How should employers prepare for workplace stress claims?
Rhamy recommends five steps in this episode:
- Review your workers' compensation coverage so you understand how mental health claims will be handled.
- Track and document workplace stressors, such as excessive overtime, deadlines or management issues. If a claim is filed, documentation is your best defense.
- Review job descriptions and expectations so they match the real workload. If an employee claims stress beyond what is expected, the job description can be key evidence.
- Train your managers, because a poorly handled stress complaint can turn a simple issue into a lawsuit.
- Strengthen employee support programs, including mental health resources.
He stresses being proactive, both in New York and in other states that may adopt similar laws.
About this episode
Employers, Are You Ready for the New Workers' Comp Law? New York just changed the game—employees can now file for workers' comp due to workplace stress, and other states may follow soon. This could mean more claims, higher insurance premiums, and major HR headaches. So how can you protect your business? In this episode, Rhamy Alejeal breaks down:
✅ What this new law means for employers ✅ The risks of rising mental health claims ✅ How to update your HR policies and insurance NOW ✅ Actionable steps to protect your business


