Don't HR Alone · Episode 49

No One’s Applying to Your Job Posting? Fix It Fast with This 8-Step Framework

May 29, 20257 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (7)

If a job posting brings in a flood of unqualified applicants, or no applicants at all, the market may not be the only problem. In this episode, Rhamy explains why many job ads chase away the people companies want and walks through the eight-part framework his firm uses to write ads that attract the right candidates.

The core point is that a job description is not a job ad. A job description is an internal HR document that covers duties, responsibilities, physical requirements and compliance details. A job ad is a marketing tool whose purpose is to attract the right candidates, repel the wrong ones and get people to apply. Many companies paste the internal document onto a job board and hope for the best.

The eight parts are: set the stage with a bold statement about your mission or the problem you solve, introduce the team, define the culture, challenge readers to screen themselves out, describe the role in terms of impact, list what they will love about the work, describe the ideal candidate's mindset and values, and end with a strong call to action.

Rhamy shares a nonprofit client whose ad was essentially a job description and drew one or two applicants in a month. After a rewrite using the framework, it drew 47 qualified applicants in one week, and the client hired two people.

The episode closes with next steps: audit your ads, keep job descriptions and job ads separate, use the framework and share it with every hiring manager.

Key takeaways

  • Keep your job description and job ad as separate documents, since one is for HR and current employees and the other is for candidates.
  • Open the ad with a bold statement about your mission or the problem your company solves.
  • Describe your culture honestly enough that the wrong candidates decide not to apply.
  • Write responsibilities in terms of impact and what the person will enjoy, not as a list of chores.
  • Include compensation where your state requires it, and keep the ad to the highlights.
  • Audit your current job ads and rewrite anything that reads like a legal document.

What is the difference between a job description and a job ad?

They serve different audiences and purposes. In this episode, Rhamy describes a job description as an internal document for HR and existing employees. It outlines duties, responsibilities, physical requirements and compliance information. It is an important HR tool, but it does not inspire anyone to come work for you.

A job advertisement is a marketing tool. Its purpose is to attract the right candidates, repel the wrong ones and get people to actually apply.

The common mistake is treating them as the same thing: copying an internal HR document, posting it on Indeed or LinkedIn and hoping for the best. The result is often a flood of unqualified applicants or none at all. Rhamy's advice is to keep both documents, since each is needed, but write the ad the way you would write marketing for a client. His recommended order is job analysis first, then the job description and your core values, and the ad last, based on the person you want to hire.

How do I write a job ad that attracts good candidates?

Treat it like marketing and follow a clear structure. The eight-part framework in this episode is:

  1. Set the stage with a bold statement about your mission or the problem you are solving.
  2. Introduce the team and mission the person will be part of.
  3. Define the culture so the right people recognize themselves.
  4. Challenge the reader to decide whether this is really for them.
  5. Describe the role in terms of impact, not chores.
  6. List what they will love about the role, with responsibilities that sound exciting.
  7. Describe the ideal candidate, focusing on mindset and values.
  8. End with a strong call to action that invites them to apply.

Rhamy's guiding question is whether a high-quality applicant reads it and thinks, that is me. The goal is to motivate the people you want to apply, and no one else.

Why is no one applying to my job posting?

It may be the ad, not the market. In this episode, Rhamy says that if a posting draws a flood of unqualified applicants or no applicants at all, a common cause is that the company posted its job description instead of a real job ad. If it reads like a legal document rather than an invitation to something worth joining, strong candidates scroll past.

He shares a nonprofit client hiring for a key role whose ad was essentially a job description: dry, generic and forgettable. Over the course of a month it drew one or two applicants. After the ad was rewritten using the eight-part framework, it drew 47 qualified applicants in one week and almost a hundred in total. The client hired two strong team members and has used the format for every role since.

The first step is to audit your current ads and ask whether they are inspiring or merely informative.

How do you describe company culture in a job posting?

Clearly enough that some people decide not to apply. In this episode, Rhamy says culture is what makes the right people apply and sends the wrong ones running, and that is intentional.

He gives two contrasting directions. A high-performance company, run more like a pro sports team, might say it does not do mediocre, owns its results with no excuses, and moves fast to solve problems. A business that wants to grow people over the long term might describe itself as supportive, polite and responsive. Either can work. The aim is for the right reader to think, yes, that is me, and for everyone else to recognize it is not.

The framework then adds a direct challenge: invite readers who are excited to keep going and tell everyone else it is probably not their kind of place. Rhamy says this weeds out lukewarm candidates before you review a single resume.

How do you write job responsibilities in a job ad?

Write them in terms of impact and what the person will enjoy, not as a list of chores. The episode handles this in two parts of the framework.

First, describe the role in terms of impact. Rhamy's example is a manager of coaches: rather than listing tasks, the ad explains that the person will lead a team delivering transformational results and ensure clients get measurable support from every coach. Paint a picture of the change they will create.

Second, list what they will love about the role. This is where bullets belong, written to sound exciting: leading and mentoring a strong team, building and refining systems, handling high-stakes escalations, driving results with key metrics, collaborating with colleagues and building a culture of excellence.

Then describe the ideal candidate's mindset and values, such as thriving in a fast-paced environment and loving to solve complex problems. That section helps the right people feel seen.

What information should a job ad include?

The highlights that get the right people to apply. Rhamy compares a job ad to a billboard: you would never run one crammed with text. The ad should motivate action, and fuller details can come later in the process, after someone applies.

That said, some practical information belongs in the ad. As of May 2025, Rhamy notes that some states require employers to post compensation in job ads, and that including benefits information is a good idea, just as you would highlight value when trying to attract a client. Check current requirements in the states where you hire.

Beyond that, the eight-part framework covers what to include: your mission, the team, the culture, a self-screening challenge, the role's impact, what the person will love, the ideal candidate and a strong call to action. Do not overwhelm candidates with every detail from the job description. The point is to get them to apply.

About this episode

Need help fixing your hiring process?

Is Your Job Ad Actually Repelling the Right Candidates? Most job ads read like HR legal documents—boring, vague, and forgettable. If you're posting the same job description online and wondering why you're not getting quality applicants, this episode is your wake-up call.

In this episode of Don't HR Alone, Rhamy Alejeal breaks down why most job postings fail and reveals the 8 essential elements that turn boring listings into powerful recruiting tools. Whether you're getting zero applicants or the wrong ones, this framework will change the game. - Why job descriptions ≠ job ads - The secret to writing ads that attract and repel (yes, repel!) - How to define culture and impact to get the right people

Please share this with an HR leader or business owner who needs to hear it.