Don't HR Alone · Episode 18

Non-Compete Clauses BANNED?! How to Protect Your Business (After the FTC Ruling)

May 7, 20246 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal

For years, business owners have used noncompete agreements to keep trained employees, trade secrets and client relationships from walking out the door to a competitor. In this episode, recorded in May 2024, Rhamy explains what the Federal Trade Commission's new rule banning most noncompete clauses would mean for that protection and how to prepare.

As of May 2024, the FTC rule meant the vast majority of workers, from frontline employees to mid-level managers, would no longer be bound by noncompetes. The main exception was for senior executives in policy-making roles earning over $151,164 a year, a small fraction of the workforce. The FTC argued the rule would increase wage mobility and competition. Rhamy, who says he does not usually hold strong opinions on regulation, is not a fan. He worries it will make employers hesitant to invest in training and make it easier for departing employees to take clients with them.

His practical answer has three parts. Lean on nonsolicitation and confidentiality agreements, which remained legal and protect client relationships and proprietary information, though less strongly than noncompetes. Build a culture, and pay, that people do not want to leave. And plan as if the rule will take effect, even though legal challenges, including from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, were expected.

The FTC rule was later blocked in court, so this episode reflects the situation as of May 2024. Check current guidance and state law before relying on or dropping a noncompete.

Key takeaways

  • Check the current status of the FTC noncompete rule and your state's law before relying on or removing a noncompete, since the rule discussed here was later blocked.
  • Review your existing employment agreements and understand which employees any exemption would cover.
  • Use nonsolicitation and confidentiality agreements to protect client relationships and proprietary information.
  • Invest in engagement, satisfaction, loyalty and fair compensation so your best people choose to stay.
  • Do not build your plan around a court or election overturning a rule; prepare for it to apply while your counsel monitors the legal challenges.

What did the FTC noncompete ban do?

As of May 2024, the Federal Trade Commission had issued a rule banning most noncompete clauses for workers. Under the rule as described in this episode, the vast majority of workers, from frontline employees to mid-level managers, would no longer be bound by noncompetes.

The FTC argued that the change would increase wage mobility, foster competition and boost the economy. Rhamy acknowledges those goals but focuses on the cost to employers: noncompetes have long protected investments in training, sensitive information and business strategy, and helped keep departing employees from taking skills, trade secrets and clients straight to a competitor.

The rule was expected to face legal challenges when this episode was recorded, and it was later blocked in court. This page reflects the rule as of May 2024. Check current federal guidance and your state's noncompete law before making decisions.

Who was exempt from the FTC noncompete ban?

As of May 2024, the main exemption in the FTC rule was for senior executives. According to the episode, noncompetes could still apply to people in policy-making roles earning over $151,164 a year.

Rhamy points out that this group is a minuscule fraction of the workforce. For most small and mid-size businesses, the employees who drive day-to-day operations, such as trained technicians, marketers, managers and frontline staff, would fall outside the exemption.

That is why he recommends reviewing your current employment agreements and understanding exactly which employees, if any, an exemption would cover. Because the FTC rule was later blocked, the exemption described here reflects the situation as of May 2024. Noncompete rules also vary by state, so check current guidance for where your employees work.

How can I protect my business without a noncompete agreement?

Rhamy recommends two kinds of agreements that remained legal under the FTC rule as of May 2024:

  • Nonsolicitation agreements, which help keep departing employees from taking your clients
  • Confidentiality agreements, which help protect proprietary information

He calls these your "new best friends," while being clear that they protect client relationships and proprietary information to a much lesser extent than a noncompete.

The third tool is not a contract at all. Rhamy stresses building a workplace that employees do not want to leave. Engagement, satisfaction, loyalty and compensation can all be powerful tools for retaining talent.

His overall advice is to strengthen these areas of your contractual relationship with employees now, rather than relying on a single agreement to hold people in place.

Should employers wait for court challenges to the FTC noncompete rule?

Rhamy advises against it. When this episode was recorded in May 2024, it was almost certain the FTC rule would be challenged in court, and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce had already signaled its intent to sue, arguing the rule overstepped the FTC's authority.

Even so, he calls betting on an injunction, a court ruling or an election to undo the rule a risky strategy. Legal battles can drag on for years with no guarantee of success, and a business that waits could be left exposed and unprepared if a challenge fails.

His recommended approach is two-sided. Plan as if the rule will be enforced as scheduled: review agreements, understand the exemptions and strengthen nonsolicitation and confidentiality protections. At the same time, work with legal counsel to monitor the court cases and adjust as they develop. The rule was later blocked, which shows why ongoing monitoring matters. Check current guidance before acting.

Why do businesses use noncompete agreements?

Businesses use noncompete agreements to protect what they have invested in their people. As Rhamy describes it, noncompetes help make sure that employee training, knowledge of sensitive information and key business strategies do not walk out the door when someone leaves.

He gives two common concerns. First, an employer that has trained a team of skilled technicians or innovative marketers does not want them to take those newly built skills, or worse, trade secrets and clients, straight to a direct competitor. Second, the relationships employees build with clients are often the backbone of a company's success, and losing them can hurt growth and the ability to hire more people.

Rhamy's worry about losing that protection is that employers may become hesitant to invest deeply in employee development if the return on that investment can simply leave.

About this episode

The Federal Trade Commission's recent decision to ban non-compete clauses for most workers is a major shakeup for businesses. Is this the end of protecting your trade secrets and client relationships? In this episode, learn about alternative strategies, legal considerations & how to build a winning workplace culture. Don't get caught off guard!

👍 Like and share to spread awareness!