Don't HR Alone · Episode 20
Noncompete Ban Blocked — What do I do now?
Business owners who spent the summer of 2024 preparing for the FTC's ban on noncompete agreements suddenly had a new question: now what? In this episode, recorded in late August 2024, Rhamy explains what a Texas court ruling meant for existing noncompetes and what employers should do next.
On August 20, 2024, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas set aside the Federal Trade Commission's ban on most noncompete agreements nationwide. The ban had been set to take effect on September 4, 2024. As of August 2024, that meant existing noncompetes remained enforceable under state law in states that allow them, and the FTC had not yet filed an appeal. Rhamy cautions that the ruling did not permanently remove the possibility of a federal ban, and that states can act on their own.
He also urges employers to think about the employee side. Noncompetes carried a negative stigma after months of headlines, and just because you can use one does not mean you should. Some employers that had already planned for the ban might choose to follow through for morale reasons.
The episode closes with four steps: review existing agreements so they comply with state law and are reasonable in scope, duration and geography; get legal counsel; watch for state and federal changes; and consider alternatives such as nondisclosure, nonsolicitation and confidentiality or intellectual property agreements. Check current guidance, since the legal landscape around noncompetes continues to change.
Key takeaways
- Confirm the current federal and state rules on noncompetes before relying on one, since this episode reflects the law as of August 2024.
- Review each existing noncompete to make sure it complies with your state's law and is reasonable in scope, duration and geographic reach.
- Have legal counsel review any noncompete agreement, including one built from a sample, before you use it.
- Consider nondisclosure, nonsolicitation and confidentiality or intellectual property agreements, which can cover much of what a noncompete protects.
- Weigh the morale impact before requiring noncompetes, since just because you can use one does not mean you should.
- Track developments at both the state and federal level and adjust your agreements as the rules change.
Was the FTC noncompete ban blocked?
Yes. On August 20, 2024, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas set aside the Federal Trade Commission's ban on most noncompete agreements. The ban had been scheduled to take effect on September 4, 2024, and the ruling halted its enforcement nationwide.
As of August 2024, when this episode was recorded, the FTC had not filed an appeal, so the ruling held. Rhamy noted that the outcome of the 2024 election could shape whether the FTC pursued the ban further, and his own unscientific opinion was that the block would stay in place.
He stresses that the ruling did not permanently eliminate the possibility of a federal ban, and that the broader debate over noncompetes was far from settled. Check current guidance for the latest status at both the federal and state level.
Are noncompete agreements enforceable after the FTC ban was blocked?
As of August 2024, existing noncompete agreements remained enforceable under state law, assuming the employer is in a state that allows them. The federal ban no longer applied, but state law still governs.
Rhamy explains that the rules differ widely from state to state. Some states do not allow noncompetes at all, some have partial bans, and others have few restrictions. So the federal ruling gave businesses stability, but it did not make every noncompete valid.
Even in states that permit them, an agreement must be reasonable. Rhamy recommends reviewing every existing noncompete to make sure it complies with your state's law and is reasonable in scope, duration and geographic reach, because overly restrictive agreements can be challenged in court even without a federal ban. Check current state guidance for where your employees work.
What should employers do with noncompetes after the Texas court ruling?
Rhamy recommends four steps:
- Review your current agreements. Make sure each one complies with your state's laws and is reasonable in scope, duration and geographic reach.
- Consult legal counsel. An attorney can explain what the ruling means for your specific agreements and help prepare for future changes. Even if you start from a sample agreement, have counsel review it before using it.
- Stay informed. The legal landscape is fluid. An injunction against the federal ban does not stop states from acting in different ways, so watch both state and federal developments and be ready to adjust.
- Evaluate employee relations. Consider how noncompetes affect your relationship with employees and whether other tools could protect the business while improving satisfaction and retention.
This guidance reflects the situation as of August 2024. Check current guidance before changing your agreements.
What are alternatives to a noncompete agreement?
Rhamy points to several agreements that can cover much of what a noncompete protects, without the same scrutiny:
- Nondisclosure agreements, which he noted were not under discussion for a ban as of August 2024
- Nonsolicitation agreements covering your current clients
- Confidential information or intellectual property agreements
Used together, these can protect client relationships, sensitive information and proprietary work, which are the main reasons employers turn to noncompetes in the first place.
He suggests that alternatives may be worth considering for employee relations reasons too. After months of headlines, noncompetes for anyone below the high-level executive tier were likely to carry a negative stigma for a while. Alternatives let an employer keep investing in and trusting new employees, giving them every opportunity they can handle, while still protecting the business.
Should I keep using noncompetes even if they are legal?
Not automatically. Rhamy's advice is that just because you can, does not mean you should.
He acknowledges that noncompetes have real benefits, including allowing employers to invest more in employees without worrying they will go to a competitor at the drop of a hat. But the public debate over the FTC ban focused on employee mobility and fairness, and many employees heard that noncompetes are bad for workers and good for business. Most will not see the nuance.
For employers that had already planned how to handle the ban before the Texas ruling, Rhamy suggests it may make sense to follow through anyway, purely for morale. More broadly, he recommends using this moment to review your policies and make sure they balance the company's interests with those of employees. This reflects his view as of August 2024; check current law in your state.
About this episode
Big news for businesses! A Texas court has temporarily blocked the FTC’s proposed ban on noncompete agreements, but don’t get too comfortable—the fight isn’t over yet. Your noncompete agreements are safe, for now, but this ruling brings up critical questions: What does this mean for your business? How should you adjust your strategies? In this episode of the People Processes Podcast, we break down the court’s decision, what it means for you, and the steps you need to take to protect your company moving forward.
🚨 Key Takeaways:
Understand the current status of noncompete agreements. Learn how to review and revise your agreements to ensure compliance. Get actionable tips on how to prepare for potential changes in the law.


