Don't HR Alone ยท Episode 16
Performance Punishment: The Unseen Side of Success
A business owner's best employee, the one everyone relies on, hands in notice. The underperformer never leaves. In this episode, Rhamy looks at the idea of "performance punishment," the claim popular on social media that doing great work only earns you more work, and explains what it means for employees and for employers.
For employees, Rhamy agrees that the reward for good work early on is often more work: harder clients, tougher problems, more responsibility. He argues that this is normal and not a reason to slow down. Hiring is uncertain, and it often takes three months at a minimum, and more like six to 18 months, to judge someone's real trajectory. Consistent, high-quality work over time is what stands out. He cites a St. Louis Fed article showing that the link between hours worked and lifetime pay is not linear: people who worked 50 percent more hours earned well over 100 percent more over their careers.
For employers, Rhamy says that losing top performers is usually a symptom of lazy management, not malice. Owners spend their time on whatever is broken, while the people holding things together get overloaded and burn out. Complaints about favoritism, politics or lack of growth point to the same issue.
The episode closes with practical steps on both sides. Employers should evaluate overperformers as carefully as underperformers, reward them with pay, titles and training, and never refuse a promotion because someone is too valuable in their current role. Employees should keep records of their results and advocate for themselves.
Key takeaways
- Evaluate your top performers as deliberately as your underperformers, and give them new opportunities once you are reasonably sure they are overperforming.
- Never refuse a promotion because the person is too valuable in their current job; build the backup so they can move up.
- Spend some of your management time on the areas that are working, since overloaded top performers will eventually burn out.
- Consider early performance reviews, such as at three months, six months and one year, with a modest motivational increase or spot bonus for standout work.
- Reward top performers with title recognition, training and growth, not only money.
- As an employee, keep your own records of results and tell your manager you are ready for a performance conversation.
What is performance punishment at work?
Performance punishment is the idea that strong performers are rewarded with more work instead of recognition. On social media, it often comes with advice to slow down, avoid outshining coworkers and "sandbag" your effort.
In this episode, Rhamy describes how it happens. A new hire in a group of similar employees starts finishing work faster and with fewer errors. A few months later, they are handed the angriest clients, the hardest engineering problems and the jobs nobody else can handle. The reward for competence starts to feel like a penalty.
Rhamy says that pattern is real and, early on, it is normal. Where he disagrees is with the conclusion. He argues that in most organizations, consistent strong performance is noticed and rewarded over time. The organizations where it truly goes unrewarded exist, but he describes them as rare and says they tend not to last.
Does working harder actually lead to higher pay?
In most cases, yes, and often more than proportionally. Rhamy cites a St. Louis Fed article that tracked a group of men aged 25 to 55 over their careers and looked at the relationship between average weekly hours worked and pay. Hours are an imperfect stand-in for performance, but the pattern is clear: the relationship is not linear.
According to the episode, people who worked 50 percent more hours did not earn 50 percent more. They earned well over 100 percent more over their careers. People who worked half as many hours earned about 20 percent of the money, not 50 percent.
Rhamy adds his own experience as someone who has employed hundreds of people. Average employees tend to follow an average path, while exceptional, consistent performers are able to skip rungs and move up quickly. The exceptions, in his view, are bad employers, which he believes are relatively rare.
How long does it take to know if a new employee is a top performer?
Longer than most people expect. Rhamy says that in his business and most of his clients' businesses, it takes a minimum of three months, and more often six to 18 months, to have a strong sense of a person's trajectory.
Early results can mislead. Some people hit the ground running and shine for the first six to 13 weeks because they learn quickly. When the work becomes routine, detailed and complex, slower learners who show up every day and get it right sometimes overtake them. Some fast starters lose focus once the job is no longer new.
Rhamy also notes that even good hiring is uncertain. Employers aim for roughly an 80 percent chance that a hire will not fail, and landing a true superstar is closer to winning the lottery. That is why he advises employees to focus on consistency over time, and employers to evaluate potential continually rather than judging from the first few weeks.
Why do top performers quit small businesses?
Rhamy's answer is that it is usually a management problem rather than bad intent. Business owners naturally spend their time on whatever is broken. The areas run by top performers are not on fire, so they get less attention, even as the work in those areas keeps growing.
The result is that the best people get flooded with more responsibility, become the go-to for every problem, and get little in return. They can handle it for a while, but over time they burn out or accept another offer. Meanwhile, the employee who does little and has no other options rarely leaves.
Rhamy points to warning signs: an owner who feels only a few people can be trusted with the work, and exit interviews mentioning favoritism, political behavior or little room for growth. He describes these as symptoms of the same lazy management style, and says owners must regularly spend time growing the resources, rewards and opportunities of the people making things work.
How should I reward high-performing employees?
Rhamy recommends a combination of early recognition and real growth opportunities:
- Early evaluations. He suggests performance reviews at three months, six months and one year, with a motivational increase for standout performers. It does not have to be large, only enough to recognize outstanding work.
- Spot bonuses. His own company uses them, though he admits it is an imperfect science and some people bonused at three months were gone by six.
- Stretch opportunities. Evaluate entry-level employees for leadership potential and give them chances to show it.
- Full rewards. When they succeed, recognize them financially and with title, training and growth.
He also warns against siloing top entry-level performers with work only they can do. Others should learn that work so the top performer can take on new things. For larger organizations, he stresses continuity planning so key people can keep growing.
Is it wrong to say an employee is too valuable to promote?
Yes. Rhamy calls it a clear sign that an employer is doing it wrong. Refusing to promote someone, such as a key employee named Josh, because no one else can do his job means great talent is being held back by the company, and that person is likely to leave.
His advice is to act immediately. When someone is excelling, work with them and their manager to duplicate what they do as well as possible, by training others and building internal continuity, so the person can move up. The business probably needs someone with those skills in other roles too.
He frames it as a duty employers owe their top performers: more opportunity and more reward, delivered as soon as you can reasonably be confident the person is in fact an overperformer. In his view, the roughly one in 10 employees who are pulling the organization forward deserve close attention, because they are also the people with the most options elsewhere.
About this episode
๐ Dive into the controversial concept of "performance punishment" in organizations. Working hard can be seen as punishment because initially, high performers might get more challenging tasks due to their abilities. This extra workload can feel unfair and overwhelming - leading to the perception that hard work is punished.
๐ Discover why exceptional performance shouldn't go unrewarded and how organizations can foster a culture of appreciation and growth. Don't miss out on valuable tips for both employees and employers to thrive in today's competitive landscape.


