Don't HR Alone · Episode 29

Save Money on Taxes - 831(b) Plans for Small Businesses (Rhamy Alejeal & Van Carlson)

January 9, 202546 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (13)

Many small business owners first hear about 831(b) plans as a way to save thousands in taxes, and some of what they hear is set up badly. In this episode, Rhamy talks with Van Carlson, founder and CEO of 831b.com, about what these plans are, who they suit and where the catches are.

Van describes an 831(b) plan as a small insurance company that a business owner forms, much as a 401(k) is a structure set out in the tax code. It dates to the Tax Reform Act of 1986. The operating business pays premiums into the plan as a business expense to cover risks it would otherwise carry on its own, such as gaps in cyber coverage, third party business interruption, lawsuits and warranty claims. The plan is a C corporation, and Van explains that it is taxed only on realized investment gains while the money stays inside.

The plan has to work like real insurance, with a formal claims process and pooled risk shared with other participants. Van is candid that this pooling is the main catch, since part of an owner's premium can go to pay other companies' claims.

The conversation also covers limits based on gross revenue, minimum practical funding, setup and annual costs, and how plans wind down. The episode closes on two plain points: Van calls the plan another tool in the toolbox, not a silver bullet, and Rhamy warns that no one should start one without good advisors.

Key takeaways

  • Start with a review of your current insurance to find the sub-limits, exclusions and uncovered risks you are already carrying yourself.
  • Treat an 831(b) plan as a long-term risk management strategy, not a one-year tax move.
  • Expect real insurance mechanics, including a formal claims process and pooled risk where part of your premium can pay other participants' claims.
  • Check whether your business can sensibly fund at least about $80,000 a year, which Van gives as the practical minimum given the fees.
  • Do not set up an 831(b) plan without experienced advisors, since plans run as personal tax shelters are what draw scrutiny.

What is an 831(b) plan for small businesses?

An 831(b) plan is a small insurance company that a business owner forms to cover risks the business would otherwise carry on its own. In this episode, Van Carlson, founder and CEO of 831b.com, compares it to a 401(k): it is a structure set out in the tax code, introduced with the Tax Reform Act of 1986, and it needs an administrator who knows the rules.

The plan is its own entity, a C corporation that elects to be taxed under section 831(b). The operating business pays premiums into it, and Van explains that those premiums are not recognized as taxable income inside the plan. The only thing taxed there is realized investment gains. The owner of the operating company owns the plan, and the money builds up as a reserve for the specific risks the plan covers.

What kinds of business risks can an 831(b) plan cover?

It is meant for risks a business is self-insuring, either because traditional insurance does not cover them or because coverage has gaps. Van Carlson says many package policies carry sub-limits of around $50,000 for areas like employment practices liability and cyber, which is a drop in the bucket for a real claim.

Examples discussed in the episode include brand and reputation damage after a data breach, third party business interruption when a cloud or software provider you depend on goes down, the legal costs and business disruption of a lawsuit, supply chain disruption, and warranty obligations. Rhamy adds that being sued is a major drain even with insurance, because gathering records, preparing narratives and conducting interviews takes enormous time. Van recommends starting with a full review of current coverage to see where the gaps actually are.

How are 831(b) plans taxed?

As Van Carlson explains it, the operating business deducts premiums paid into the plan as an ordinary and necessary business expense, like any other insurance premium. Inside the plan, the premiums themselves are not taxed. The plan pays corporate income tax only in years when it has realized investment gains. For example, if $200,000 earns 5 percent in a money market account, the plan pays tax on the roughly $10,000 of gains that year.

When money comes out to the owner as a shareholder, it is taxed as a dividend or as capital gains. If a claim is paid, Van says the business typically would not also be deducting that loss, so it should net out to making the business whole. These are tax questions with real consequences, so confirm the details with your own tax advisors before acting.

How much can a business put into an 831(b) plan?

There is a legal ceiling and a practical one. Van Carlson puts the annual maximum premium going into 2025 at roughly $2.8 million, a limit that is indexed and changes, so check current guidance. Hitting the maximum is not the goal: premiums have to be tied to an underwriting method based on the business's real risks.

Van's firm caps premiums at 10 percent of gross revenue, with no more than 2 percent per risk. A $2 million company wanting to put away $200,000 would need at least five real risks it is self-insuring. Insurers look at gross revenue rather than profit. On the low end, Van says about $80,000 a year is the minimum that makes the fees worthwhile, and most clients do not fund the full 10 percent every year.

What are the risks of an 831(b) captive insurance plan?

The main catch is pooled risk. Van Carlson explains that for a plan to count as insurance, risk must be both transferred and distributed, which means sharing it with other businesses under the law of large numbers. His firm pools 500 to 700 companies for a given coverage, shared pro rata, and he says pools typically bear about 30 percent of a claim, with an annual loss ratio of about 6 percent. Part of your premium can pay other owners' claims.

There is also the risk of setting one up badly. Rhamy notes that people with bad advisors push these plans to the point where it no longer looks like insurance, such as putting away $2 million on $2 million of income every year and never paying taxes. His advice is direct: do not get into an 831(b) without good advisors.

How much does it cost to set up and run an 831(b) plan?

Van Carlson gives his firm's numbers in the episode: $6,000 to form a plan, which covers creating the corporation, its EIN, shareholders and domicile setup, and then about $6,000 a year to maintain it, whether or not risk is placed in it that year. That annual cost covers the tax return, administration and domicile fees, and it is paid by the plan entity. His firm also charges a retained liability fee and shares in clients' risk.

Winding a plan down is also a cost. Van says shutting one down runs about $3,000 to cover final tax returns and administration fees, and the owner pays capital gains on what is distributed. He adds that his firm runs solvency testing around years three and five, and may require a distribution if the plan holds more than its coverage needs.

Can an 831(b) plan help when selling a business?

It can, according to Van Carlson. Because the plan is a separate C corporation owned by the shareholders, it is not sold with the operating business. That lets owners keep covering risks that follow a sale, which Van calls transactional risk, such as being sued over the representations and warranties made to the buyer.

Warranties are a common example. Many businesses, from contractors to software providers, carry warranty obligations that are an unfunded liability, and buyers may try to lower the price because of them. Van describes owners setting aside money in the plan to cover warranty claims as they run off over the next few years, so the obligation does not drag down the sale price. He says some owners also move part of their sale proceeds into the plan.

About this episode

Are you a small business owner looking to better manage risk and save on taxes? In this episode of Don't HR Alone, Rhamy Alejeal sits down with Van Carlson, Founder and CEO of 831b.com, to explore how an 831(b) plan can act as a game-changing tool for businesses. Learn how this plan protects against unexpected risks, provides tax-deferred savings, and fills gaps in traditional insurance.

Van shares real-world examples, expert advice, and actionable insights to help you safeguard your business and its future. Don’t miss this opportunity to gain a competitive edge in your industry!

👉 Learn more and connect with Van, visit https://www.linkedin.com/in/vancarlson/

Website: https://www.831b.com/ https://linkedin.com/company/sra-831b https://instagram.com/sra831b https://facebook.com/SRA831b