Don't HR Alone · Episode 35

STOP Hiring the Wrong People! Learn the Secret to Building a Dream Team

February 20, 202516 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (7)

Many small businesses keep hiring people who do not work out, and the cause usually sits long before the interview. In this episode, Rhamy explains that hiring well starts with knowing exactly what a role needs, then filtering a large pool of applicants down step by step.

The groundwork has three parts. Job analysis means talking to leaders, managers and people in the role to learn what success and failure look like. A job description turns that into a list of 10 to no more than 20 competencies. A job advertisement then markets the role to the right people, rather than reposting the job description. Rhamy notes that this may mean spending money on advertising, just as a business does to win clients.

With applicants in hand, the hiring process becomes a funnel. Rhamy says his company sees around 100 to 120 applicants for every hire. Resume screening, including knockout questions, should remove 80 to 90 percent. A short screening call confirms the person can book a time, show up and communicate, and about half fail it. The main interview walks through each prior job against the job description, scoring each competency from one to three. A final interview with the most senior person available checks fit.

The episode closes with a tip on references: ask for contact details for real coworkers and bosses from recent jobs, not just the names listed on a resume.

Key takeaways

  • Start every hire with job analysis: ask leaders, managers and people in the role what makes someone succeed or fail in it.
  • Keep job descriptions to 10, and no more than 20, competencies the person must have.
  • Write the job advertisement to attract the right people and make them want to apply, instead of posting the job description.
  • Add a few yes or no knockout questions to the application so screening removes unqualified applicants quickly.
  • Use a 10 to 15 minute screening call to confirm candidates can schedule, show up on time and communicate.
  • In the main interview, ask about each recent job for stories that prove each competency, and score them one to three.

What is job analysis and why does it matter for hiring?

Job analysis is figuring out what a role actually does and what makes people succeed or fail in it, before you hire. In this episode, Rhamy explains that hiring correctly requires the executive to know what the company needs. He uses McDonald's as an example: it knows exactly what it needs from a fry cook, which is why it can hire broadly and quickly.

The quick version is to talk to the organization's leaders, the managers and, if possible, people currently in the role. Ask what the job does, what good and bad performance look like, what is most likely to go wrong and what the signs of success are. Then look for the common thread. A detail-heavy bookkeeping role and a door-to-door sales role need very different people, and an ad that does not reflect that will attract the wrong ones.

What is the difference between a job description and a job advertisement?

A job description defines the work. A job advertisement sells the job. In this episode, Rhamy describes a job description as a list of usually 10, and no more than 20, competencies the person must have, with optional KPIs and any relevant conditions, such as working in the cold while counting inventory.

A job advertisement is marketing. It should attract the right people and make them want to take action. Rhamy points out that most job ads are just the job description posted online, which does little to draw applicants. The ad also has to match the real role. Marketing for one kind of person and then delivering a very different job will not work, just as a firm that advertises deep financial analysis but delivers surface-level reports will lose those clients.

How many applicants does it take to make one good hire?

Often far more than owners expect. In this episode, Rhamy says his company receives around 100 to 120 applicants for every person it hires. He estimates that even with a well-written ad, only about 10 percent of applicants are actually decent, because many people click apply regardless of fit. He also cites a 192 percent rise in applications over the six months before the episode, as tools make it faster for people to apply with custom cover letters.

Volume at the top of the funnel matters because filtering is what produces a good hire. Rhamy compares hiring to sales: just as only a share of prospects become clients, only a share of applicants become hires. If free job board postings do not bring enough applicants, he says to pay for advertising. In a small market, such as a town with only 30 plumbers, contact them directly instead.

How do you screen job applicants quickly?

Use knockout questions and a fast resume review, then a short screening call. Rhamy recommends adding a question or three to the application, such as a yes or no on whether the applicant has a required four-year degree, and removing applicants who do not meet it. Then look through resumes for gaps, relevant experience and skills that fit the role. This basic screening should eliminate 80 to 90 percent of applicants. High-volume employers may use resume screening tools.

Next comes a screening call of about 10 to 15 minutes, which candidates book themselves through a scheduling link. Its purpose is to confirm the person can make an appointment, show up on time, join the call and communicate clearly. Rhamy says about half of candidates fail this step, which is normal. A candidate who emails ahead to reschedule is still communicating.

How should I run a main job interview?

Hold the candidate's resume in one hand and the job description in the other. In this episode, Rhamy explains that the main interview means walking through each of the candidate's recent jobs, usually three to five, and asking questions that make them tell stories proving they have the abilities on the job description.

For entry-level roles without required competencies, write down what you are looking for instead: someone who can learn, shows up on time, takes advantage of training and steps up to lead. Then ask about experiences that would show those traits. Score each competency on a simple scale: one is so-so, two is pretty good, three is excellent, and there should not be many threes. Rhamy says this step typically eliminates about another half, leaving perhaps three candidates out of a hundred.

What is the purpose of a final interview?

The final interview is a gut check on fit. In this episode, Rhamy calls it a smell check, done by the highest-level person in the organization who can take part. At larger companies it might instead be a fit interview, such as meeting several future coworkers in person or on a video call.

The reason is simple: part of any job is whether the person can work with their boss and the people around them. Rhamy notes that some people who work well with him would not work well with his business partner, and the reverse, without either being a bad employee. After the final interview, an offer is followed by pre-hire steps such as background checks, credit checks and skills testing, depending on the role.

How do you get useful job references from candidates?

Ask for the people they actually worked with, not the references they chose. Rhamy's tip is to build it into the main interview. As you walk through each prior job, ask about teammates: who they liked working with, who they did not, what frustrated them and what their ideal teammate looks like.

Then ask for the name and phone number of a team member you can call to learn what working with the candidate is like, along with the name and contact information of their boss. Rhamy says he does not put much weight on the references listed on a resume. He wants the people the candidate worked with and reported to, going back through recent jobs. That makes reference checking one of the most useful steps at the end of the process.

About this episode

Struggling to find the right employees? Hiring the right team isn’t about luck—it’s about job analysis, job descriptions, and filtering bad applicants early. In this episode, Rhamy Alejeal breaks down how to hire correctly and how to structure a bulletproof hiring process.

📢 Key Takeaways: ✔️ Job Analysis: The critical (but often skipped) first step to hiring. ✔️ Job Descriptions vs. Job Ads: Why they are NOT the same thing. ✔️ The Four-Stage Hiring Funnel: How to filter out bad candidates. ✔️ The Final Interview: Why culture fit matters.

💬 Drop a comment – What’s your biggest hiring challenge? We reply to every comment! 👇