Don't HR Alone · Episode 75

The ADA Doesn't Care If You're Fair | Here's What It Actually Requires

August 6, 202617 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal

When an employee says they are struggling with anxiety and asks to work from home, many owners answer, "We treat everyone the same here." It sounds fair, but under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) that answer is likely a violation. In this episode, Part 1 of a series on accommodation, Rhamy explains what the ADA actually requires and where its limits are.

The ADA is an exception to the usual rule of applying policies uniformly. It requires an individualized interactive process with the specific employee, and refusing to have that conversation can lose a case even when the requested accommodation would have been unreasonable. Rhamy notes that mental health accommodation requests are up 125% since 2021, that remote work is now the most requested accommodation, and that the average ADA settlement is now over $125,000.

He walks through a five-step interactive process: recognize the request, engage in a documented good faith conversation, explore accommodations, implement with check-ins at 30, 60 and 90 days, and document every step.

The episode then covers the first three situations where an employer does not have to say yes: accommodations that cause undue hardship, which is weighed against the employer's size and resources; requests that would eliminate an essential function; and demands for a preferred accommodation when another effective option exists.

Part 2 covers the remaining limits, including indefinite leave, direct threat, conduct standards and documentation requests. This episode covers the ADA standard only, which differs from the standards for pregnancy and religious accommodation.

Key takeaways

  • Never answer an accommodation request with "we treat everyone the same"; the ADA requires an individualized look at each request.
  • Train managers to recognize a request whenever an employee connects a medical condition to a need for a change, even without the words ADA or accommodation and even if it is not in writing.
  • Hold a documented, good faith, back-and-forth conversation about the employee's limitations, the job functions affected and what would help.
  • Put the chosen accommodation in place with a trial period and check in at 30, 60 and 90 days to see if it is working.
  • Document every conversation, every option considered and every reason for a decision, because your documentation is your defense.
  • You may choose a cheaper or easier accommodation as long as it is effective, and you never have to eliminate an essential function.
  • Weigh undue hardship against your company's size and resources, since the standard is proportional by design.

Can I deny an ADA accommodation request because we treat all employees the same?

No. Most employment law rewards consistency, but the ADA is the exception. An accommodation, by definition, means modifying a rule, a schedule or a condition for one person because of their disability. The ADA does not ask whether you treat everyone the same. It asks whether you engaged in an individualized interactive process with that specific employee to try to find an accommodation.

Answering "we treat everyone the same" refuses that individualized analysis, which is why it fails. In this episode, Rhamy explains that failing to engage in the interactive process is itself treated as a failure under the law. Even if what the employee asked for would have been unreasonable, an employer can lose the case just by refusing to have the conversation. The safer response is to start the conversation, not to close it.

Does an employee have to say "ADA" or put an accommodation request in writing?

No. An accommodation request does not need magic words. It does not need to mention the ADA or use the word accommodation, and it does not need to be in writing. A statement like "I'm having a hard time with my anxiety, and I need to work from home sometimes" counts as an accommodation request.

The test is whether the employee connects a medical condition to a need for a change at work. Once that connection is made, the process has started. In this episode, Rhamy notes that this is the first place many employers trip up, by assuming the employee never really asked and only said they were sick. Rhamy recommends training managers to recognize these requests, since a casual comment can start the clock.

What are the steps of the ADA interactive process?

The episode lays out five steps:

  1. Receive the request. Recognize it when an employee connects a medical condition to a need for a change, with or without formal wording.
  2. Engage in the interactive process. Have a documented, good faith conversation, usually more than once, about the employee's limitations, which job functions are affected and what would help. This is the step small businesses most often skip.
  3. Explore accommodations. Options can include remote work, a flexible schedule, modified duties, additional breaks, a quiet workspace, reduced stimulation or reassignment. The accommodation must be effective but does not have to be the one requested.
  4. Implement and monitor. Put it in place with a trial period and check in at 30, 60 and 90 days.
  5. Document. Record each conversation, every option considered and every reason for a decision.

How many employees does a business need before the ADA applies?

The federal ADA applies to employers with 15 or more employees. In this episode, Rhamy points out that many states have their own disability laws that bring that threshold down to five employees, or even one. Depending on where a business operates, the number that matters may be 15, five or one.

That means a small employer should not assume it is exempt from accommodation obligations just because it is under 15 employees. The practical step is to look up the disability discrimination law in each state where you have employees and confirm which threshold applies. Because state laws change, check current guidance for your state rather than relying on a number you learned years ago.

What counts as an undue hardship under the ADA for a small business?

An employer never has to provide an accommodation that causes undue hardship, which the ADA defines as significant difficulty or expense. The key point for small businesses is that the law weighs the cost against the employer's size and resources. In this episode, Rhamy gives an example: a $10,000 accommodation is a rounding error for a 5,000 person company, but for a 20 person shop it can be a genuine undue hardship. Same accommodation, different answer.

That proportionality is written into the statute, so small businesses reach the undue hardship ceiling much faster. Undue hardship is also not limited to cost. Accommodations that are unduly extensive or disruptive can qualify, such as a schedule change for one employee that would stop other employees from doing their jobs. Document the reasoning behind any undue hardship decision.

Do I have to remove essential job functions to accommodate an employee?

No. An accommodation helps the employee perform the essential functions of the job; it does not delete them. Employers can reassign minor, marginal tasks, but they never have to eliminate an essential function.

The episode gives a client example. At a business with roughly 25 to 30 employees, two workers on a truck normally traded off driving and hooking up loads of about 40 to 50 pounds. One worker was told by his doctor not to lift over 20 pounds for 8 to 12 weeks. Because hooking up was shared work rather than a core function of his role, he could drive while his coworker handled the hookups, a reasonable accommodation.

If the job had required one person to both drive and hook up alone, the only fix would have been a second worker, which would remove a core function and likely be unreasonable.

Do I have to give an employee the specific accommodation they ask for?

No. The employee is entitled to an effective accommodation, not necessarily their preferred one. In this episode, Rhamy explains that the EEOC is explicit on this point: if two accommodations both work, the employer can choose the one that is cheaper or easier to provide.

For example, an employee with anxiety might ask for a private office. If a quieter work location, a white noise machine or noise-canceling headphones would effectively solve the concentration problem, the employer can provide that instead of building an office. The employee's preference should still get primary consideration, and the conversation should start by asking what they need. But the final choice among effective options belongs to the employer. Document which options were considered and why the chosen one is effective.

Is remote work a reasonable accommodation for anxiety or depression?

It can be, and it is now common. In this episode, Rhamy notes that remote work has become the most requested accommodation, and that it is requested for mental health conditions such as anxiety, depression, PTSD and ADHD more than for any other condition. These are recognized disabilities, so a remote work request tied to one of them deserves the full interactive process.

Remote work is not automatic, though. As of August 2026, the episode notes the EEOC reaffirmed in 2025 that in-person presence can be an essential function, and that pandemic remote work did not make every job remote eligible. Federal appeals courts, including in a case involving Ford Motor Co., have held that regular attendance was essential. Rhamy's example is an opening baker who must be there at 4:00 AM to run the oven. Because this area is changing, check current guidance.

About this episode

Mental health accommodation requests have surged 125% since 2021, and the #1 most requested accommodation is now remote work. When an employee says "I'm struggling with anxiety, and I need to work from home," most business owners respond with "we treat everyone the same." Under the ADA, that response is a violation.

But here's what most HR content won't tell you: the ADA is NOT a blank check. There are clear, legally recognized limits to what you have to do. In this episode, Rhamy Alejeal walks through the interactive process that protects you AND the eight situations where you do NOT have to grant an accommodation.

You'll learn:

  • Why "treating everyone the same" is actually illegal under the ADA
  • The 5-step interactive process that is your legal defense
  • The 8 situations where you do NOT have to accommodate (undue hardship, essential functions, indefinite leave, direct threat, and more)
  • Why the ADA's undue hardship standard protects SMALL businesses specifically
  • How you get to choose the accommodation — not the employee
  • When you can require medical documentation
  • Why you never have to lower performance standards or tolerate misconduct

IMPORTANT CLARIFICATION: This episode covers the ADA standard ("significant difficulty or expense"). This is DIFFERENT from the religious accommodation standard (covered in a separate episode). Don't mix them up.

This episode is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.