Don't HR Alone · Episode 19

The Secret Weapon for Managing Employee Social Media

June 14, 202415 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal

An employee mocks a coworker on Facebook. Another posts offensive political statements on a profile that names the company. A third shares a photo from a client meeting with confidential details in the background. In this episode, Rhamy explains how employers can handle problem social media use without overstepping employees' legal rights.

The foundation is a clear social media policy. You cannot expect people to follow rules you have never stated. A good policy defines terms, explains its purpose, covers confidentiality and productivity, sets expectations for behavior and spells out consequences.

There are limits. Under the National Labor Relations Act, employees have the right to engage in protected concerted activity, including discussing working conditions, pay and employment issues, and that protection extends to social media. Overly broad policies that stop employees from discussing working conditions or making complaints can lead to unfair labor practice charges. On the other hand, employers do need to act on posts that are discriminatory, harassing, disclose confidential information or seriously threaten safety or the company's reputation.

Rhamy walks through three cases (coworker harassment, a confidentiality leak and offensive political posts) using the same pattern: a clear policy, a private one-on-one meeting that shows the specific posts, a documented warning, training where it helps and a follow-up. He also suggests holding managers and executives to a higher standard.

The episode closes on culture: train employees, not just write rules, and encourage the same grown-up behavior online that you expect in the break room.

Key takeaways

  • Write a social media policy that defines terms, covers confidentiality and sets out expected behavior and consequences.
  • Do not discipline employees for discussing pay, working conditions or employment issues online, since the NLRA protects that activity.
  • Act on posts that harass or discriminate against coworkers, because tolerating them can create a hostile work environment.
  • Prohibit sharing client details, project information or photos from client meetings on social media.
  • Handle violations in a private, documented one-on-one meeting that shows the specific posts and explains the policy they break.
  • Hold managers and executives to a higher standard for public posts, since their statements affect the team and the company's reputation.
  • Train employees on the policy instead of only putting it in the handbook.

What should an employee social media policy include?

An effective social media policy tells employees what the rules and hard lines are, because you cannot hold people to expectations you have never stated. Rhamy recommends that a policy:

  • Define what you mean by social media and social networking, along with other key terms
  • Establish a clear purpose and acknowledge the benefits of social media while setting boundaries
  • Align with current laws and regulations, especially employees' rights under the National Labor Relations Act
  • Address confidentiality and productivity, including proprietary information and when social media use at work is appropriate
  • Set expectations for behavior, such as professional, respectful conduct and no harassment of colleagues
  • Outline consequences for violations, up to and including termination where appropriate

He adds two practical points. Ask employees who post about controversial issues to make clear their views are personal and do not represent the company. And pair the written policy with training, since teaching people why the rules matter does more than a handbook page alone.

Can I fire an employee for complaining about work on social media?

Often, no. As of June 2024, the episode explains that employees have the right to engage in protected concerted activity under the National Labor Relations Act, which includes discussing working conditions, pay and employment issues. That protection extends to social media posts.

Rhamy's example is an employee posting that the company does not keep enough toilet paper in the bathroom. That is a complaint about working conditions, and there is not much an employer can do about it from a disciplinary standpoint. Overly broad social media policies that bar employees from discussing working conditions or making complaints can lead to unfair labor practice charges.

That does not mean anything goes. Employers still need to act on posts that are discriminatory, harassing, disclose confidential information or pose a significant risk to workplace safety or the company's reputation. When a post is about the employer itself, Rhamy advises being especially careful before taking action. Check current NLRB guidance.

How should I handle an employee harassing a coworker on social media?

Treat it the same way you would treat the behavior in the office. In the episode's example, Sarah posts a series of Facebook comments mocking her coworker John's work and personal life, and other employees see them. Rhamy's test: if she stood up in a meeting and said the same things out loud, it would be harassment. Online is no different.

The steps he recommends:

  1. Make sure your policy clearly prohibits online harassment, including derogatory comments, offensive jokes and personal attacks on colleagues, and states the consequences.
  2. Have Sarah's manager meet with her privately, respectfully but firmly.
  3. Show the specific posts and explain how they violate the policy.
  4. Give a written warning describing the issue and the expected change.
  5. Offer training on appropriate social media use and schedule a follow-up meeting.

The response can scale up for repeat behavior or down to a verbal warning for a first offense. Ignoring it risks a hostile work environment claim.

What if an employee posts confidential company information online?

Address it quickly, even when it was an accident. In the episode's example, Alex in marketing excitedly posts a photo from a client meeting, and a laptop in the background shows confidential details about the client and an upcoming project. The disclosure draws attention from the media and the client, creating a PR problem and the risk of losing the client.

Rhamy recommends a confidentiality policy that bars sharing confidential company information on social media or other public platforms, including details about clients, projects and internal matters, and that addresses photos taken in client meetings or the office.

When it happens, the manager should meet with the employee one on one, show the post, explain the seriousness of the breach and its consequences, issue a written warning, document the incident, provide refresher training if needed and keep a closer eye on the employee's posts for a few months. Unauthorized disclosure can bring legal action from clients, or from the government in the case of some health and financial data.

Can employers discipline employees for political posts on social media?

It depends on what the posts say and who is posting. Rhamy calls this the hardest of the common cases. In his example, Michael posts offensive political statements on a profile that clearly lists his employer. Coworkers are uncomfortable, and a client has asked the company about the posts.

His bright line: ordinary political opinions are fine, but posts that cross into discrimination or harassment require action, since they can lead to legal claims from affected employees. Controversial statements by a higher-level employee can also harm the company's reputation and their working relationships, which is worth addressing.

Rhamy suggests the policy encourage employees to express views responsibly and use a disclaimer that their views are personal and do not represent the company. He also suggests holding managers and executives to a higher standard. If action is needed, hold a one-on-one, show the specific posts, explain how they conflict with the policy, document the conversation and provide training on respectful communication.

About this episode

Is your employee bad-mouthing coworkers online? Leaking confidential info? Our latest episode tackles managing employee social media to avoid PR disasters!

Social media can be a goldmine for businesses but it can also turn into a nightmare when employees overshare or post inappropriately. This episode dives deep into the common pitfalls of employee social media use and equips you with the tools to avoid them.

Here's what you'll learn: • How to craft a bulletproof social media policy that protects your company's reputation. ️ • When (and how) to intervene in employee social media mishaps. • The legal boundaries of employee free speech online. ⚖️ • Real-world examples of employee social media disasters (and how to prevent them!).

Stop employee social media meltdowns before they happen!

Let us know in the comments below! • Have you ever dealt with an employee social media issue? • What are your biggest concerns about employee social media use?