Don't HR Alone · Episode 25

Variable Hour Employee Health Insurance Changes: What This Means for Business Owners

November 21, 202411 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (6)

Businesses with part-time, seasonal or high-turnover staff often take up to a year to decide whether a variable hour employee works enough to qualify for health insurance. In this episode, recorded in November 2024, Rhamy explains a push in Congress to shorten that window and how employers can prepare.

Under the Affordable Care Act rule the episode calls IRS Rule 4980H, employers with 50 or more full-time equivalent employees must offer health insurance or face penalties. For variable hour employees, whose hours are changing or unknown, the IRS has allowed employers up to a year to measure whether they work full-time hours. In September 2024, Congressman Steve Cohen and other lawmakers sent the IRS a letter asking to cut that period from one year to three months, arguing the long window delays coverage for people who are effectively full time. As of November 2024, this was a request, not a final rule. Check current IRS guidance.

Rhamy illustrates the stakes with a hair salon client with more than 20 locations, where stylists' hours swing from full time to 20 hours a week to 50 at the holidays. Coverage there costs about $400 to $500 per employee per month once someone is designated full time.

His preparation steps: audit how employees are classified as full time, part time or variable; use real-time hour tracking instead of paper timesheets; and build a benefits strategy and budget for offering coverage sooner, or design part-time roles to stay under full-time hours. The episode closes on the upside: earlier benefits can improve retention and morale.

Key takeaways

  • Check current IRS guidance on the variable hour measurement period, since this episode reflects a September 2024 request from lawmakers, not a final rule.
  • Audit whether each employee is correctly classified as full time, part time or variable hour under ACA rules.
  • Classify people you know will work full time as full time rather than variable hour.
  • Design part-time roles to stay below about 29.5 hours a week and track hours to keep them there.
  • Replace paper timesheets with real-time hour tracking so you have accurate data for eligibility decisions.
  • Budget for offering health coverage sooner, or rethink whether your roles should be full time or part time.

What is IRS Rule 4980H?

IRS Rule 4980H, as the episode calls it, is part of the Affordable Care Act's health insurance eligibility rules for employers. It says that if you have 50 or more full-time equivalent employees, you need to offer health insurance or you could face penalties. Rhamy explains that full-time equivalents are calculated, so 50 full-time employees or 100 employees each working half of full time would both reach that 50 mark.

The part that matters most for many businesses is how it treats variable hour employees, meaning people whose hours change or are unknown. The IRS has allowed employers to take time, often up to a year, to measure whether those employees work enough hours to count as full time and qualify for benefits.

Rhamy notes that the variable hour measurement approach came from IRS regulations rather than the ACA statute itself, which simply says full-time employees get health coverage. Check current IRS guidance for the rules in effect today.

Is the ACA look-back period for variable hour employees changing?

As of November 2024, a change had been requested but not made. In September 2024, Congressman Steve Cohen and a group of other lawmakers sent a letter to the IRS asking it to revise the rule so that the evaluation period for variable hour employees drops from one year to three months.

Their argument was that some businesses use the long evaluation period to delay health insurance for workers who are regularly putting in full-time hours, and that those workers are entitled to coverage under the law. A shorter period would get them benefits faster, though it would mean higher costs for some employers.

Rhamy's advice was to prepare as though the change could happen, because a business that relies on the 12-month window would need to move quickly if the IRS acted. Check current IRS guidance for whether the measurement period has changed since this episode.

Why do businesses use the variable hour classification for health insurance?

It gives employers time to see whether a new employee will consistently work full-time hours before committing to expensive coverage. Rhamy says this is especially common in high-turnover, fluctuating industries such as retail, hospitality and restaurants.

His example is a hair salon client with more than 20 locations and hundreds of employees. New stylists often say they want full-time work, then work full time for a few weeks, drop to 20 hours a week, and then work 50 hours a week around Thanksgiving. Over time, many average far less. With a 12-month measurement period, the business can see who sticks around before offering affordable minimum essential coverage, which for that client costs about $400 to $500 per employee per month.

Rhamy describes the 12-month wait as legal and smart in many industries. His caution is that it was sometimes applied to people whose status could have been figured out much faster, and that approach may not hold if the period shortens.

How should employers prepare for ACA eligibility changes for variable hour employees?

Rhamy recommends four steps:

  1. Audit your classifications. Make sure people you know will work full time are designated full time, not variable. Part-time roles should be designed for fewer than about 29.5 hours a week; a week or two over will not break the bank, but the role should be built to stay under. Variable should mean you truly do not know.
  2. Upgrade hour tracking. Paper timesheets turned in at the end of the week do not work at scale. Real-time tracking gives you the accurate data a shorter window would require.
  3. Prepare your benefits strategy. Budget for offering minimum essential coverage to more employees sooner, or make the operational choice to keep part-time employees from consistently working 30 or more hours a week.
  4. Stay informed about the proposed revision.

He adds that businesses near the threshold, such as one at 40 full-time equivalents expecting to grow, should start preparing now.

Should my business use full-time and part-time roles instead of variable hour?

It may be the simpler strategy if the measurement window gets shorter. Rhamy suggests that some businesses will decide not to use variable hour at all. If there are only three months to figure out status anyway, it can make sense to have clearly defined full-time roles and clearly defined part-time roles.

In that model, full-time roles go to specific people and carry benefits. Part-time roles have a hard cap below full-time hours. Employees are promoted from part time to full time when they show they can handle it.

The alternative, which Rhamy calls going "loosey goosey" with variable hour, offers less advantage once the long evaluation period is gone. He frames the choice as part of a broader HR strategy about attracting and retaining the right people. Offering health insurance sooner can help employees feel secure and valued, which can improve retention and morale and reduce turnover.

About this episode

In this episode of Don't HR Alone, Rhamy discusses potential changes to IRS Rule 4980H, which governs health insurance eligibility under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). The proposed change, supported by Congressman Steve Cohen and other congressional members, would reduce the evaluation period for determining health insurance eligibility for variable hour employees from one year to three months.

This episode explores the implications for businesses with high labor turnover and variable hour staff, practical strategies to prepare for the changes, and the importance of upgrading HR tracking systems and auditing employee classifications.

⚡️ Don’t get left behind! 👉