Don't HR Alone · Episode 59

Wage Garnishment Compliance: Protect Your Business (and Employees)

September 4, 202519 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (6)

A certified letter arrives with a 17-page court order telling you to take money out of an employee's paycheck. Ignoring it, over-deducting or talking about it around the office can all create liability. In this episode, Rhamy walks employers through how to handle wage garnishments step by step. The rules described reflect federal and state law as of September 2025, so check current guidance for your state.

Rhamy explains that a garnishment is a legal order, not a request from the employee, and that the employer must follow it or formally contest it with the issuing agency. He covers the usual priority order, from child and spousal support through tax levies and federal student loans to consumer debts, and the federal limits under Title III of the Consumer Credit Protection Act, including the 25% of disposable earnings cap for most garnishments and the higher limits for child support.

The core of the episode is a six-step process: verify the order and the employee, respond to the issuer by the deadline, notify the employee, calculate the withholding, remit on schedule, and monitor until the order is released. Along the way he explains how to share only the records the issuer needs, how multiple orders and bankruptcy notices change things, and how admin fees and limits differ in Tennessee, California, New York, Illinois and Florida.

He closes with the common mistakes that turn a routine order into a liability, including ignoring the order, miscalculating disposable earnings and disciplining an employee over a single garnishment.

Key takeaways

  • Confirm every garnishment order is authentic and matches the right employee, including the Social Security number, before withholding anything.
  • Return the employer answer form by the deadline, which can be as short as seven days, even if the person no longer works for you.
  • Calculate disposable earnings as gross pay minus legally required deductions, without subtracting voluntary deductions like health premiums or 401(k) contributions.
  • Keep garnishments confidential to payroll and HR, and redact anything the issuer did not ask for before sending records.
  • Remit withheld money on schedule and keep withholding until the issuing court or agency sends a release, not when the employee says the debt is paid.
  • Never fire or discipline an employee because of a single garnishment.

What should an employer do when they receive a wage garnishment order?

Follow the order or formally contest it through the issuing agency; you cannot simply ignore it, even if the employee asks you to. In this episode, Rhamy lays out six steps:

  1. Verify the order, the issuing court, agency or sheriff, and that it applies to the right employee.
  2. Respond to the issuer on the employer answer form, confirming employment status, pay frequency and disposable earnings.
  3. Notify the employee with a neutral, factual notice where your state requires it, including who to contact to contest.
  4. Calculate the withholding using the correct cap.
  5. Remit the money with the case number and employee ID, on schedule.
  6. Monitor the order until you receive a release or termination from the issuer.

Rhamy warns that an employer who ignores an order can become liable for the entire debt. As of September 2025; check current guidance for your state.

How much can be garnished from an employee's paycheck?

For most garnishments, federal law caps the amount at 25% of disposable earnings or the amount by which weekly disposable earnings exceed 30 times the federal minimum wage, whichever is less. In this episode, Rhamy explains this comes from Title III of the Consumer Credit Protection Act. His example: an employee with $1,000 a week in disposable earnings can have at most $250 withheld for a consumer debt, even if the order asks for $400.

Other limits apply to other debts. Rhamy notes child support can take much more, commonly 50% and as much as 65% depending on the situation. Federal student loan garnishments are limited to 15%. For IRS tax levies, the IRS provides an exemption table in Publication 1494 that sets how to calculate the amount. States can set stricter limits. These figures reflect the rules as of September 2025, so check current guidance.

What counts as disposable earnings for wage garnishment?

Disposable earnings are gross pay minus legally required deductions, which mainly means taxes. In this episode, Rhamy stresses that voluntary deductions, such as health insurance premiums and 401(k) contributions, do not reduce disposable earnings.

This matters because the garnishment caps are percentages of disposable earnings. One of the common mistakes Rhamy sees is employers subtracting voluntary deductions first, for example treating health insurance as if it should come out before applying the 25% limit. That miscalculates the base and the withholding. Rhamy notes there is some nuance to the definition, so read the instructions that come with the order, which usually include a link or a long description of the rules, and call the issuing agency if you are unsure. As of September 2025; check current guidance.

What is the priority order for multiple wage garnishments?

In this episode, Rhamy gives the general order as child and spousal support first, then federal tax levies, then state tax levies, then federal student loans and administrative debts owed to the government, and finally consumer debts and judgments. The most common orders employers see are child support and consumer debts.

When orders compete, higher priority comes first. If a child support order calls for $300 but the cap allows only $250, you withhold $250 for support and notify the issuer that the cap prevents the full deduction; other creditors wait. Multiple child support orders are more complicated: depending on the state, they may share the available funds proportionally, which may mean recalculating every order when a new one arrives. Rhamy notes some small business payroll systems cannot handle multiple support orders, and suggests calling the agency for help with the calculation. As of September 2025; check current guidance.

Can you fire an employee for having a wage garnishment?

Not for a single garnishment. In this episode, Rhamy explains that federal law prohibits firing an employee because their wages are garnished for one debt. Employers can sometimes act when there is more than one, but how multiple debts are treated varies by state, so check your rules before doing anything.

Rhamy treats a garnishment as a private payroll matter, not a disciplinary event. Only payroll and HR need to know; the employee's manager does not. Records belong in secure HR files, and the employee notice should be neutral and factual: the company received an order, is required by law to withhold a stated amount, and here is who to contact to contest it, which is the issuing court or agency rather than your HR team. Rhamy warns that firing or disciplining someone over a first garnishment is an easy way to get into trouble. As of September 2025; check current guidance.

Can employers charge an admin fee for processing garnishments?

In many states, yes. In this episode, recorded in September 2025, Rhamy gives examples of state rules on admin fees: California allows $1.50, Tennessee $5, Illinois $5, New York $2 per check, and Florida none. He notes some states instead allow a percentage of the garnishment. Charging the fee is optional; it is meant to cover the work of processing and sending payments.

He also highlights other state differences. Tennessee has strong creditor rights, so garnishments are relatively easy to obtain. Florida limits consumer debt garnishments more tightly and has a head of family exemption. California ties its limits to the state minimum wage and has large penalties for noncompliance. Rhamy notes that New York's limit for consumer debt garnishments is lower than the federal one, so check the New York rule. Illinois uses 15% of gross or 25% of disposable earnings, whichever is better for the employee. Check current state guidance before setting fees or limits.

What are common wage garnishment mistakes employers make?

In this episode, Rhamy lists the issues he sees most often:

  • Ignoring the order, which can make the employer liable for the entire debt.
  • Withholding for the wrong person. He describes an order for a common name that matched a client's employee but turned out to be someone else, caught by checking the Social Security number.
  • Miscomputing disposable earnings by subtracting voluntary deductions.
  • Over-disclosing personal information, internally to managers or coworkers, or externally by sending HRIS printouts that include unrequested details such as discipline or training history.
  • Remitting to the wrong place. Child support goes to the state disbursement unit, not the courthouse.
  • Holding withheld money. Rhamy warns that keeping money withheld from a paycheck instead of sending it on amounts to taking it from the employee.
  • Stopping too early on the employee's word instead of a release from the issuer, or failing to tell the issuer the employee has left.

Also note that a bankruptcy notice stops garnishments except child support. As of September 2025; check current guidance.

About this episode

Risk Alert: Mishandling wage garnishments can make YOUR business liable for an employee’s debt. Rhamy Alejeal breaks down:

  • Federal CCPA limits (25% rule, minimum wage rule)
  • Child support, tax levies, consumer debt — priority order explained
  • State-by-state admin fee rules (TN, CA, NY, IL, FL)
  • How to reply to court orders without oversharing PII