Don't HR Alone · Episode 40

When Your Job Becomes Your Identity: The Hidden Danger of Career Enmeshment

March 27, 202542 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (15)

Some of the most committed people in a company think about work from the moment they wake up until they fall asleep. Owners often see that as the ideal, but it can hide a real risk. In this episode, Rhamy talks with Dr. Janna Koretz, a clinical psychologist and the founder of Azimuth Psychological, whose practice works with high performers in high-pressure careers.

The conversation centers on career enmeshment: when a job becomes a person's whole identity, with nothing else making up who they are. Being excited about work and treating it as part of who you are is fine. The problem comes when it is the only thing. A layoff after an acquisition, a missed promotion or even selling a company can leave an enmeshed person feeling lost, and the discussion links that to mental health struggles and substance use.

For individuals, the episode offers two starting points: reconnect with friends from earlier in life, and work out your own values, then add small, regular activities that reflect them.

For companies, the guidance is to build a genuine culture rather than offer lip service, manage by relationship, and be careful with forced personal development programs, team building and events that people feel pressured to attend.

The episode closes on a nuanced note: there is no simple four-step plan. Leaders help most by showing that a life outside work is acceptable and by knowing their direct reports well enough to adjust to each person's circumstances.

Key takeaways

  • Watch for signs that a key employee's entire identity rests on their job, since a layoff, acquisition or missed promotion can then hit them as a personal crisis.
  • Encourage people to have a life outside work by modeling it yourself, rather than treating outside interests as a lack of commitment.
  • Back wellbeing offers like mental health days with a culture where people actually use them, so they are not just lip service.
  • Get to know your direct reports as people, recognize what they contribute, and adjust to their circumstances when life gets hard.
  • Avoid forcing personal development programs, team building or after-hours events on employees, and ask them what they would find useful instead.
  • Keep spans of control small enough that a manager can genuinely know and lead each person.

What is career enmeshment?

Career enmeshment is when a person's career becomes their whole identity and nothing else makes up who they are. As discussed in this episode with clinical psychologist Dr. Janna Koretz, it is not always bad, but it is often a problem, for the same reason that putting all your eggs in one basket rarely works out.

The risk shows up when something changes. People who worked hard and checked every box can lose a job when their company is acquired, fail to make partner or sell the business they built, and suddenly feel they have nothing. All of their self-worth and validation rested on a role that no longer exists. The episode describes this as closer to an existential crisis than a career setback, and notes it can send people into a tailspin of mental health issues and related problems such as substance use.

Is it bad when employees make their job part of their identity?

Not on its own. The episode's view is that moderation is key. It is good to hire people who are a strong cultural fit, excited about the work and proud to be part of the company. Having the job be part of who someone is creates no problem.

The concern is when work becomes the only thing a person has. Most people do not do well long term when their identity rests on a single thing, because life eventually gets complicated with kids, aging parents and other responsibilities. It can also cause friction at work: managers have to ask people to do or stop doing certain things, and when the job is someone's entire identity, that feedback can feel personal and draw pushback. The episode points to physicians as an example of people who can thrive with work as a big part of their identity, while still having other ways to express it.

What are the warning signs that someone is too enmeshed in their job?

One clear warning sign from this episode is when nothing outside of work brings a person joy. Being excited about work is healthy, but if someone wants to be at work, thinks about work whenever they are off, and finds that leaving early does not make them any happier, they may be heading toward having work become their whole identity.

Long days that do not need to be long are another signal, especially when someone has tied the success of their role so tightly to themselves that they overcommit. The episode notes this is trickier for business owners, because some of those hours are genuinely mandatory. The point is to look at the time that is not required. When that is a person's pattern, it is a cue to step back and reflect on who they are, what they value, how they want to spend their time and what they want their legacy to be.

How do you build an identity outside of work?

The episode suggests two practical starting points.

  1. Reconnect with your personal network. People often tend their professional network and let friendships lapse. Arrange a coffee or get families together with people you knew at different points in your life. Spending time with them helps you remember who you were and what you used to enjoy, in a low-stress, low-commitment way that does not require taking up a new hobby.
  2. Work out your own values. Many people have never thought about it or have absorbed the values around them. Ask what you would want to have done by the end of your life, then build those values into small, regular habits.

The example given is someone who realizes community service matters to them. Instead of changing careers, they might volunteer at a food pantry for three hours on the first Monday of each month. Small steps add up and build on each other.

How can a company support employee wellbeing without empty gestures?

Build a culture that is genuine rather than one that offers benefits nobody uses. The episode calls out a common pattern: a company says people can take a mental health day, but no one actually does. Real support means accepting that people need different things to recharge, and sometimes that means letting someone take time at an inconvenient moment for the business.

The other approach discussed is managing by relationship. It takes time, which is why many companies skip it, but it is easier in a smaller company. People do not want to feel like a cog in a machine. They want to be recognized for what they contribute, not only told when something is broken, and they want their circumstances seen, such as a spouse who is seriously ill. The episode also reminds owners that employees will not share an owner's goals in the same way, and that is fine.

Should companies require personal development programs for employees?

The episode is skeptical. It discusses a client who required new hires to join a morning personal development program three times a week, with journaling, for their first 60 days, paying a $2,000 bonus for completing it. A separate 90-day program, for those who signed up, paid $4,000 on completion, and participants lost $1,000 if they missed it. The company became a profitable publisher of around 40 employees, but its retention in the first six months was described as not great.

The concerns raised are that genuine change only happens when people are interested, that many workplace programs are not well grounded in research, and that the setting creates boundary problems. If the company is paying for your journaling, you may wonder whether your boss will read it and hold back. The suggestion is to be honest about why a program exists and, if the goal is employees' growth, to ask them how they would like to develop.

Should employees be required to attend team building events and holiday parties?

The episode's view is that people should not feel forced into them. Many employees do not want to attend a company holiday party, and team building activities like trust falls tend to produce people going through the expected social motions rather than real trust.

Getting to know colleagues does matter, but the more important interactions are often the small daily ones, such as chatting while waiting for others to join a video call. Even voluntary events can carry pressure. The example discussed is a new manager, just home from emergency surgery, worrying about missing an optional in-person managers' meeting. Events after hours can also clash with family duties like getting home for a child's bedtime. The guidance is that it depends on the company's size, culture, people and work, so listen to what employees actually want and offer opportunities to connect without making them feel obligated.

About this episode

How can you tell if your top employees are experiencing burn out? Is your entire identity wrapped up in your work? In this episode of Don't HR Alone, our host Rhamy Alejeal interviews clinical psychologist Dr. Janna Koretz, founder of Azimuth Psychological, to explore the hidden dangers of career enmeshment—when your job becomes your sole identity.

You'll learn: • Why career enmeshment often leads to burnout, mental health crises, and even professional collapse. • How to recognize the signs in yourself and your employees. • Actionable strategies to build a healthier, more resilient workforce.

Explore Dr. Janna Koretz’s website at https://azimuthpsych.com/ for expert insights and free resources, including a burnout calculator and values navigator.

💬 What’s your take? Have you ever struggled with separating your identity from your job? Drop a comment below—we read and respond to every one!