Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 33
Why MOST Performance Improvement Plans FAIL Completely
Chapters (10)
Performance improvement plans take a lot of manager time and often end in termination anyway, which leaves many employers unsure whether they are worth the effort. In this episode, Rhamy explains when a PIP makes sense, how to build one that works and how to end it.
Rhamy cites data showing that somewhere between 60 and 75 percent of PIPs result in termination. His view is that a PIP should not be a routine step before firing. If an employee is on a PIP, their manager usually already has enough documented to justify dismissal. A PIP is the right tool only when there is a specific, measurable issue that, once fixed, would make the person a great employee. Otherwise, it is better for everyone to part ways.
Before starting a PIP, Rhamy asks whether the issue is clear and documented, whether informal coaching has already happened, whether the manager has a real vision for success and whether the problem is fixable. A strong plan then includes SMART goals, support such as training or frequent check-ins, defined milestones and clear consequences.
For urgent problems, he recommends short daily check-ins in the first week that taper off over the following weeks. If a manager says they do not have time for that, the employee may not be worth a PIP.
The episode closes with how PIPs end: success, partial improvement with an adjusted timeline, or no improvement and a transition out. Employers do not have to wait until the end date if the answer is already clear.
Key takeaways
- Use a PIP only when fixing one or two specific, measurable issues would make the employee one of your best performers.
- Coach and hold informal conversations first, since a PIP should never be the first step.
- Write every PIP goal as a SMART goal, such as arriving by 9 a.m. on 95 percent of days for eight weeks, rather than a vague aim.
- Front-load support with short, frequent check-ins that taper off as the plan progresses.
- Tell the employee plainly that their job is at risk if the issue is not fixed, and that you want to help them fix it.
- End the plan early if the outcome is already clear, rather than waiting for the deadline.
Do most performance improvement plans end in termination?
Many do. In this episode, Rhamy cites data showing that somewhere between 60 and 75 percent of PIPs result in termination, while noting that the data varies.
He explains why that number is not the whole story. When a manager brings a performance problem to HR, Rhamy rarely recommends a PIP if it is reasonable to terminate. A PIP is meant for an employee whose manager has many good things to say about them and believes that fixing one or two specific issues would make them a great employee. In that situation, the employee has a real chance to succeed, and Rhamy says he has seen PIPs turn people around enough to become the most valuable person on the team, leading to promotions and strong career growth.
When should a manager use a performance improvement plan instead of firing?
Use a PIP when there is a specific, measurable issue that, once fixed, would make the person a great employee. In this episode, Rhamy says a manager needs to give him lots of good things about the employee before he will recommend one. If the manager's honest answer is that the person would be one of their best if they could just fix this one thing, a PIP is worth it. Otherwise, it is usually better to let the employee go and find someone new.
He also lists questions to ask first. Is the issue clear and documented with specific, factual feedback? Have informal efforts like coaching and conversations already happened? Does the manager have a clear vision for success? And is the issue fixable at all? Some problems, such as toxic behavior, may call for a different approach.
What should be included in a performance improvement plan?
A strong PIP starts with clarity and support. Rhamy lists the core pieces:
- Specific expectations written as SMART goals: specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time bound. Examples include achieving a 90 percent satisfaction rating within three months, or showing up by 9 a.m. on 95 percent of days for the next eight weeks. A goal like "make your coworkers happier" does not work.
- Support mechanisms, such as training sessions, weekly check-ins or an employee assistance program referral.
- Milestones that define when and how progress is tracked, such as an intermediate review around week four and a final assessment at week eight.
- Defined consequences, stating what happens if goals are met and what happens if they are not, such as reassignment or termination.
How often should managers check in during a PIP?
For urgent issues, start often and taper off. In this episode, Rhamy describes a schedule he often recommends: meet every day for about 20 minutes during the first week, then three times the next week, twice the week after, and then once a week for the following three weeks. The meetings do not need to be long. They are check-ins on the specific issue, progress so far and any problems the employee is running into.
When managers say they do not have time for that, Rhamy's answer is that the employee is then not worth a PIP. The plan only works if the person is worth the investment of time. Throughout the check-ins, track progress against milestones, celebrate small wins, tackle roadblocks directly and adjust the plan if needed to keep momentum.
How do you present a PIP to an employee?
Frame it as a partnership, not a punishment, and be honest about what is at stake. Rhamy explains that a PIP is a manager trying to save someone's job. Delivering it should make clear that the plan is about what you believe the employee can achieve, not about the past.
That honesty includes consequences. Rhamy gives an example of the message to an employee: the problem will cost them their job if it is not fixed, the manager wants to help fix it because they believe in the person, and the employee does many things well but has to address this specific issue. Pair that message with tangible support, such as regular training, check-ins or an employee assistance program referral, so the employee sees the plan is designed to help.
How should a performance improvement plan end?
Every PIP ends in one of three ways, according to Rhamy. With success, celebrate and reward the employee's progress. With partial improvement, you might extend the timeline or adjust expectations. With no improvement, transition the employee out. How you handle the conclusion reflects your values as a leader.
You also do not have to wait for the end date. If you set an eight week plan and the employee is late on each of the next three days, Rhamy's advice is not to wait: document it and end the employment. A PIP is not a get-out-of-firing-free card. It means increased scrutiny, mentorship and coaching to address a specific issue, and if the employee cannot fix it, the employer has to let them go.
About this episode
Are Performance Improvement Plans (PIPs) really meant to help struggling employees improve, or are they just a prelude to termination? In this episode of Don't HR Alone, Rhamy Alejeal, CEO of People Processes, breaks down:
✅ What a PIP REALLY is & how to use it effectively ✅ The BIGGEST mistakes employers make when using PIPs ✅ How to create a legally sound, results-driven Performance Improvement Plan ✅ Are PIPs a step toward termination? The HR debate explained ✅ How PIPs affect employee morale & retention
📢 COMMENT BELOW: Do you think PIPs actually help employees improve, or are they just a way to fire someone legally? Let’s discuss! ⬇️


