Don't HR Alone · Episode 73
You Just Hired Your First Out-of-State Employee - Here's What You Missed
Hiring a remote employee in another state feels simple: add them to payroll with a new address and move on. In this episode, Rhamy explains why it is not. When an employee works from home in a new state, it is much like opening a branch office there, without any of the planning that would normally come with one.
His example is a 20-person Ohio company that hires its first employee working from home in Pennsylvania. That one hire can mean Pennsylvania income tax withholding, Pennsylvania unemployment insurance registration, workers' compensation coverage for Pennsylvania, and compliance with Pennsylvania's employment laws, posters and local ordinances. It can also create sales tax and corporate income tax obligations. Rhamy notes that one of the first things he often fixes is workers' compensation that does not cover remote employees.
The costs of missing this add up. Withholding for the wrong state can leave a company owing the correct state back taxes, interest and penalties while trying to recover money from the wrong one. Workers' compensation fines can accrue daily.
Rhamy's six-step checklist is to register for state withholding, unemployment and workers' compensation before day one; withhold based on where the work is performed; check state employment laws; check city and county rules; talk to a CPA about sales and corporate income tax; and keep a multi-state compliance tracker.
The episode closes with a priority order for employers already behind: fix workers' compensation first, then income tax withholding, then unemployment, then employment law and handbook updates.
Key takeaways
- Before a remote employee's first day in a new state, register for state income tax withholding and unemployment insurance and confirm workers' compensation covers that state.
- Set the employee's work location in payroll to their home when they work from home, so taxes are withheld for the state where the work is performed.
- Check the new state's leave, sick leave, wage and hour, final paycheck and vacation payout rules, plus any city or county ordinances.
- Ask your CPA whether the new employee creates sales tax or corporate income tax obligations in that state.
- Keep one spreadsheet listing every state where you have employees and what you are registered for, and update it with each new-state hire.
- If you already have remote employees in other states, fix workers' compensation first, then withholding, then unemployment, then employment law.
What do I need to do when I hire an employee in another state?
Rhamy's checklist has six steps:
- Register with the state before the first day for income tax withholding and unemployment insurance, and talk to your broker about workers' compensation. Most registration can be done online in an afternoon, though numbers can take a week or two to arrive.
- Set up withholding based on where the work is performed.
- Review state employment laws, including paid family and sick leave, state versions of FMLA and the ADA, continuation coverage, minimum wage, overtime, breaks, final paycheck timing and vacation payout.
- Check local obligations in cities and counties with their own ordinances.
- Talk to your CPA about sales tax and corporate income tax nexus.
- Keep a compliance tracker listing every state, every registration, applicable laws, renewal dates and filing deadlines.
Rhamy stresses doing this before the hire whenever possible, rather than waiting for a penalty notice or audit.
Which state do I withhold income tax for a remote employee?
Generally the state where the work is performed. In this episode, Rhamy explains the distinction with an Ohio company. If an employee lives in Pennsylvania but commutes to work in Ohio, the work is in Ohio, so Ohio applies. If that same employee works from home in Pennsylvania, the work is in Pennsylvania, and you owe Pennsylvania withholding.
The trap is in payroll setup. Payroll systems often store the employee's home address separately from their work location, and unless the work location is updated to the employee's home, the system may keep withholding for the headquarters state.
Getting it wrong is costly. Rhamy describes a New York company that withholds New York tax for an employee working in North Carolina. The company can end up owing North Carolina the full amount plus penalties back to day one, while the money paid to New York may already have been refunded to the employee. He notes that reciprocity agreements between some states can change the answer, so check them.
Does my workers' comp policy cover remote employees in other states?
Often it does not. In this episode, Rhamy explains that every state has its own workers' compensation system, and a policy written for your home state does not automatically cover an employee working from home somewhere else. Some policies cover multiple states, but not necessarily every state, so talk to your insurance broker before the employee starts.
Rhamy says that workers' compensation that does not cover remote employees is one of the first problems he cleans up when brought into a company, and he puts it first in priority because it carries the biggest fines and liability. Most states require coverage for even one employee, and fines can be assessed per day rather than per incident.
He gives two examples. A client came to his team with an $89,000 bill after hiring in New York without workers' compensation coverage. In California, he notes, operating without coverage can bring a fine of up to $10,000 and is a misdemeanor.
Does one remote employee create sales tax nexus?
It can. In this episode, Rhamy explains that having an employee in a state is the oldest form of nexus, the legal connection that ties a business to a state's tax system. That can apply even if you have no office, inventory or customers there.
As a result, one remote hire may mean the company has to collect and remit sales tax on sales to customers in that state, and may need to file a corporate income tax return there, possibly even a zero return. Rhamy calls sales tax a huge sleeper issue: a company that hires one person in a state and does not catch it can end up owing sales tax on sales into that state going back years, which can be painful in an audit.
Rhamy is clear that this is outside HR and that every state is different. His advice is to talk to your CPA about sales tax and corporate income tax whenever you hire in a new state.
Do city employment laws apply to remote employees?
Yes, if the employee works in a city or county with its own rules. In this episode, Rhamy points out that compliance is not just 50 states but hundreds of local jurisdictions layered on top of them. Examples he gives:
- San Francisco: a higher minimum wage, paid sick leave, a health care security ordinance and a fair chance ordinance.
- Seattle: a higher minimum wage, paid sick leave and secure scheduling rules that limit schedule changes.
- New York City: paid sick and safe leave and salary transparency rules.
- Philadelphia: fair scheduling and ban-the-box rules.
If a remote employee lives and works in a major city, check that city's employment ordinances alongside the state's laws. Rhamy also recommends recording local obligations in your multi-state compliance tracker so they are not missed when someone else in that city is hired.
What if I already have remote employees in states where I never registered?
Fix the problems in order of risk rather than all at once. Rhamy's priority order:
- Workers' compensation, because it carries the biggest fines, penalties and liability.
- State income tax withholding, since taxes paid to the wrong state lead to back taxes, interest and penalties.
- State unemployment insurance, in case you are insuring employees in the wrong state.
- State employment laws, including leave and wage rules.
- Handbook and related items.
He explains the reasoning: being out of step with leave laws is a risk, but workers' compensation and tax errors are actively accumulating penalties. Rhamy estimates that withholding for the wrong state for three years can easily mean $10,000 to $50,000 in back taxes, interest and penalties for a single employee, reaching six figures across several employees. Then build a tracker so the next new-state hire is set up before day one.
About this episode
One remote hire in a new state can trigger payroll tax withholding, unemployment insurance registration, workers' comp requirements, state leave laws, corporate income tax filing, AND sales tax obligations.
Most small businesses find out at audit time. Rhamy Alejeal walks you through exactly what gets triggered and the 6-step checklist that keeps you compliant.


