Don't HR Alone · Episode 68

Your Company's Never Had HR | Here's What to Fix First

April 13, 202614 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (12)

Many small businesses run for years with the owner, or an office manager who started out ordering supplies, handling hiring, firing, payroll and compliance. When a company like that finally brings in HR, the gaps can be startling. Rhamy opens with a case shared online: the first HR manager at a business of about 90 employees found that not one employee had a verified I-9 form.

In this episode, Rhamy explains how he approaches a company that has never had HR: a structured audit across 18 areas of HR, from recruiting and onboarding to timekeeping, leave, payroll and offboarding. The most useful questions are the ones owners have never thought about, such as whether personnel, medical and I-9 files are kept separately, whether interviews use standard questions and scoring, and whether employees attest to their time each payroll.

The findings fall into two parts. The first is compliance deficiencies, rated critical, high or medium, such as missing state-specific policies for multi-state employees, missing job descriptions that leave FLSA classifications undefended, mixed timekeeping, and contractors who should be employees. The second, which Rhamy says surprises owners most, is labor return on investment: money lost to slow onboarding, unstructured hiring, missing career paths, scattered timekeeping and unexamined benefits.

The episode closes with what to do next: review every finding with the owner, let the owner's goals set the priority, and build an action plan for what to fix this month, this quarter and this year.

Key takeaways

  • Before fixing anything, audit every area of HR so you know what is missing and can rank it by risk and by return.
  • Confirm every employee has a completed I-9, and keep personnel, medical and I-9 files in three separate places.
  • If you have employees in more than one state, add state-specific policies or handbook addenda for each location.
  • Write job descriptions for every role so you can defend how each position is classified under the FLSA.
  • Move everyone onto one timekeeping method and have employees attest to their time each payroll.
  • Have the owner set priorities after the gaps are identified, and build a plan for this month, this quarter and this year.

What should a company do first when it has never had HR?

Start with an audit, not with fixes. In this episode, Rhamy explains that a business that has never had HR usually does not know what it does not know, so the first step is a structured review of every area of HR. His approach covers 18 domains, including recruiting, onboarding, performance, compensation, legal compliance, risk, culture, training, retention, communication, the handbook, timekeeping, leave, payroll, offboarding and analytics.

The results should then be reviewed with the owner, finding by finding. Rhamy stresses that the owner sets the priority order, because the right sequence depends on the business: whether it is raising money, expanding into a new state or struggling with turnover. The outcome is a prioritized action plan for what to fix this month, this quarter and this year. As he puts it, you cannot fix what you do not know about, and you cannot prioritize what you have not measured.

What are the most common HR compliance gaps in small businesses?

After doing hundreds of audits, Rhamy says the compliance gaps tend to repeat. Common examples from this episode:

  • I-9 forms. He opens with a company of about 90 employees where not one had a verified I-9.
  • File separation. Personnel, medical or confidential, and I-9 files are often not kept in three separate places.
  • Time attestation. Many employees never attest to accurate time each payroll, which creates wage and hour exposure.
  • One handbook for every state, or no handbook at all, when employees in different states need different policies.
  • Missing job descriptions, which leave exemption classifications undefended.
  • Mixed timekeeping, with no overtime policy or meal break tracking.
  • Contractors who should be W-2 employees.

Rhamy notes that the owner or a long-time office manager is usually handling HR, and the honest answer to many audit questions is "no" or "not sure."

Why do I need job descriptions for FLSA classification?

Because without them you have little to show that a role is properly classified. In this episode, Rhamy explains that job descriptions are not a nice-to-have. If you have classified someone as exempt and they are actually doing non-exempt work, you owe back overtime, and a written job description is a key part of defending how a role is classified.

Rhamy estimates misclassification exposure at $75,000 to $150,000 for a small company. He rates missing job descriptions as a high-level deficiency, alongside wage and hour gaps such as mixed timekeeping methods, no overtime policy, no meal break tracking and employees not attesting to their time, each of which he estimates at $25,000 to $75,000 of exposure in a small company. These figures are his own estimates from audit work, not statutory amounts, and the real exposure depends on the facts.

What does misclassifying an independent contractor cost?

More than most owners expect. In this episode, Rhamy estimates that reclassifying a single contractor earning $60,000 as a W-2 employee costs $25,000 to $35,000 in back taxes, penalties and interest. Multiply that across several contractors and the total reaches six figures quickly.

He lists contractor misclassification among the high-level deficiencies that turn up in audits of companies that have never had HR, alongside missing job descriptions and wage and hour gaps. The pattern is common in businesses where the owner has handled HR informally: people are paid on a 1099 because it was simple at the time, without anyone checking whether the working relationship actually fits contractor status. Rhamy's estimate is a planning figure from his audit experience rather than a fixed penalty, so the actual cost depends on the facts and the jurisdictions involved.

Do I need state-specific HR policies for remote employees in other states?

Yes. Rhamy rates multi-state compliance gaps as a critical deficiency. If you have employees in California, for example, you need California-specific policies and practices, including wage statements, meal and rest break tracking and attestation, and harassment training. He notes that a single disgruntled employee in California can file a claim under the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA).

His example from a recent audit: a company of 13 employees spread across Florida, Georgia and California had zero state-specific policies, which he describes as a ticking time bomb. Many companies have one handbook for everyone, and some have none.

The fix starts with a state-specific handbook addendum for each location where you have employees, along with the payroll and timekeeping practices that each state requires.

How can HR save a small business money?

Beyond avoiding fines, Rhamy argues that the bigger dollars are in what he calls labor return on investment. Examples from this episode, all his own estimates:

  • Structured onboarding. Time to productivity is often 120 days or more. A 30, 60, 90 day program can bring it near 60 days, which he puts at $30,000 to $50,000 a year in recovered productivity for a company hiring six people a year.
  • Structured hiring. Unstructured interviews can mean a mis-hire rate of 30 to 40%, with each bad hire costing $25,000 to $40,000. Bringing that to 20% saves real money even at a few hires a year.
  • Benefits review. A competitive package can reduce the wage premium needed to attract talent by about 10%, or $100,000 on a $1 million payroll.
  • Career ladders and clear mission and values, which support retention, and consistent timekeeping, which cuts wage and hour exposure and gives insight to manage overtime.

He estimates even a 10 to 12 person company typically has $100,000 to $200,000 in these opportunities.

About this episode

Your company's never had an HR person, and now it's YOUR problem. But here's what most people don't realize: the compliance gaps are the EASY part. The expensive part is the $100K-$200K in waste and risk you don't even know about.

In this episode, Rhamy Alejeal pulls back the curtain on the HR Strategic Audit, the exact process People Processes uses to evaluate companies that have never had formal HR. He walks through what they ask (18 domains, 137 questions), what they find (deficiencies rated CRITICAL/HIGH/MEDIUM with real dollar impacts), and the part that surprises everyone: the Labor ROI Opportunities that show you where you're quietly losing $100K+ a year.