Don't HR Alone · Episode 74
Your Employee Handbook Is a Contract — And You Don't Even Know It
Most employers think of the employee handbook as internal guidance, protected by the at-will disclaimer on page one. In this episode, Rhamy explains why that disclaimer may not save you. Courts in several states have treated handbooks as implied contracts when they contain specific promises, have weak or missing disclaimers, or are applied inconsistently.
He opens with a New Jersey example: a handbook said employees "will receive" a verbal warning, a written warning and a final warning before termination. The company skipped those steps, and the court treated the progressive discipline section as a promise that overrode at-will employment. Rhamy points to Woolley v. Hoffmann-La Roche in New Jersey and Toussaint v. Blue Cross as cases where handbook language was held enforceable.
Rhamy identifies six words to search for: will, always, shall, permanent, guaranteed and promise. He explains what makes a disclaimer hold up (it must be conspicuous, specific and consistent with the rest of the handbook), and why enforcing a long-ignored policy against one employee looks like selective enforcement. He also covers state-specific handbook requirements and how unlimited PTO wording can still create payout obligations.
The episode closes with a five-step audit: fix the disclaimer, run the six-word search and swap in permissive language, check the handbook against actual practice, add required state provisions for every state where you have employees, and set up an annual review with new signed acknowledgments.
Key takeaways
- Put your at-will disclaimer on its own page, in bold, with a separate signature line for each employee.
- Make the disclaimer state that the handbook creates no contract of any kind and that no policy, procedure or statement in it creates a contractual obligation.
- Search your handbook for will, always, shall, permanent, guaranteed and promise, and replace them with permissive language such as may, generally or at the company's discretion.
- Compare every policy with what you actually do, then either reissue the handbook with new acknowledgments or change the policy to match practice.
- Write unlimited PTO policies to state explicitly that there is no accrual, no vesting and no payout at separation.
- Review the handbook every year, ideally in the fourth quarter, and add provisions for every state where you have employees.
Can an employee handbook be considered a contract?
Yes. In this episode, Rhamy explains that courts in multiple states have treated handbooks as implied contracts, even without a signed employment agreement. That tends to happen when three conditions are present: specific promises, a weak or missing disclaimer, and inconsistent application. The idea is the same as an owner repeatedly promising an employee a job for life or a specific raise next year; the employer's representations create obligations.
Rhamy cites Woolley v. Hoffmann-La Roche, a New Jersey case in which a progressive discipline policy was treated as a binding contract, and Toussaint v. Blue Cross, in which handbook language saying employees would be terminated only for cause was considered enforceable without a standalone contract.
The more specific and mandatory the language, the more likely a court is to treat it as a contract. That is why Rhamy focuses on the exact wording of policies, especially progressive discipline, PTO, benefits and termination procedures.
What words in an employee handbook create a contract?
Rhamy names six words to search for and replace:
- Will: "Employees will receive a verbal warning" promises a specific procedure. Use "may" or "generally."
- Always: "The company will always provide" is an unchangeable commitment. Use "typically" or "in most cases."
- Shall: "Managers shall conduct annual reviews" is a term of obligation. Use "at the company's discretion."
- Permanent: "Permanent employees" undermines at-will status. Use "regular" or "current."
- Guaranteed: explicit contractual language. Use "eligible for" or "may receive."
- Promise: an overt commitment. Delete it.
His before and after example: "Employees will receive fifteen days of paid time off per year" becomes "Eligible employees may receive up to fifteen days of paid time off per year at the company's discretion and subject to change." Pay special attention to progressive discipline, PTO, benefits and termination sections.
Does an at-will disclaimer in my handbook protect me?
Only if it passes three tests. In this episode, Rhamy explains that many employers get a false sense of security from a disclaimer on page one.
- Conspicuousness. A sentence buried in an introduction letter in normal font fails. Best practice is a dedicated page, in bold, with a separate acknowledgment the employee signs and dates.
- Specificity. "Employment is not guaranteed for any duration" only addresses duration. The disclaimer should state that the handbook does not create a contract of any kind, express or implied, and that no policy, procedure or statement in it creates a contractual obligation, covering duration, procedures and policies.
- Consistency. If page one says at-will but page 15 says employees will receive three warnings before termination, the conflict tends to favor the employee, and the specific promise wins.
Every policy should use permissive language that matches the disclaimer.
What happens if we start enforcing a handbook policy we have ignored for years?
It can look like selective enforcement. In this episode, Rhamy describes a situation shared by an HR professional: a new boss picked up a 2020 handbook and began enforcing every policy in it, even though nobody had followed those policies for years. Employees were blindsided.
The legal problem is that if you spent five years not following your progressive discipline policy and then fire someone using that exact process, a plaintiff's attorney can argue the policy was never really your standard and that you used it selectively. Selective enforcement can be offered as evidence of discrimination or retaliation. Applying a policy to one employee but not another creates the same risk.
Rhamy's fix is to audit the handbook against actual practice. If you want to start following a policy consistently, reissue the handbook, give everyone the same notice you would give a new hire, and collect updated signatures. Otherwise, remove the policy or change it to match what you actually do.
Do I have to pay out unlimited PTO when an employee leaves?
It depends on how the policy is written. Rhamy cites McPherson v. EF Intercultural Foundation, a California case in which an employer with an unlimited PTO policy argued there was nothing to pay out at termination because nothing accrued. The court disagreed, finding the employer had not shown the policy truly gave it the discretion it claimed, so the employee was owed a payout.
As of July 2026, Rhamy names California, Colorado and Illinois as states with mandatory PTO payout laws, where a handbook that creates an accrued benefit means you must pay it out. Check current state guidance.
If you offer unlimited PTO, Rhamy recommends that the handbook explicitly state no accrual, no vesting, no payout at separation, and the company's right to change the policy. Track whether employees actually use it. He also cautions that the policy should address long leaves of absence, so it is not read as promising fully paid leave for an entire FMLA period.
How often should I update my employee handbook?
Every year. Rhamy recommends an annual review cycle, usually in the fourth quarter so changes are ready for January 1. After every update, collect new employee acknowledgments, and track version numbers, effective dates and who signed what.
State requirements are a big reason. Rhamy notes that if a handbook is more than a year old, it is probably missing something. As of July 2026, he points to recent changes such as California notices on reproductive health rights, off-duty cannabis protections, bereavement leave and pay transparency; updated sexual harassment and pay transparency rules in New York; and Illinois's Paid Leave for All Workers Act. Check current guidance for each state.
If you have employees in more than one state, including remote workers, you need provisions for every state where they work. Most employers use a federal section plus a section for each state. Rhamy says attorneys often charge $3,000 to $5,000 for an annual renewal review.
About this episode
Think your employee handbook is just an internal policy document? Courts disagree. In multiple states, judges have ruled that handbooks ARE binding employment contracts when they use certain language, lack proper disclaimers, or are applied inconsistently.
In this episode, Rhamy Alejeal breaks down the 6 words that turn your policies into contractual commitments, why most at-will disclaimers are legally insufficient, and the 5-step audit that protects your business.
You'll learn:
- The 6 specific words courts look for that transform policies into binding promises
- Why your at-will disclaimer might not actually protect you
- How inconsistent enforcement creates implied contracts (even with a solid disclaimer)
- What the McPherson case taught us about unlimited PTO liability
- Why handbooks unchanged since 2020 have 6 years of compliance gaps
- The 5-step handbook audit you can run before Friday


