Don't HR Alone · Episode 7

1099 Contractor to W2 Employee: Misclassification of Employees FIXED

December 20, 202311 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal

Some small businesses discover that workers they have paid as 1099 independent contractors should have been W-2 employees all along. That can mean unpaid employment taxes, overtime and benefits. In this episode, Rhamy explains what to do once you find the problem, and how an IRS program can limit the damage if you act before an audit.

Rhamy notes that neither the employer nor the worker gets to pick a worker's classification. The IRS, the Fair Labor Standards Act, the National Labor Relations Act and the EEOC all have their own rules. In his experience, misclassification often comes to light when a long-time contractor is let go and files for unemployment.

If an employer is already under audit for worker classification, Rhamy's advice is to call a lawyer, because the exposure can include all the employment taxes, benefits and overtime that should have been paid. If not, the IRS Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (VCSP) offers a way out. Employers that consistently treated the workers as nonemployees and filed their 1099s can apply on Form 8952, pay 10% of the employment tax liability for the most recent tax year, and avoid interest, penalties and a classification audit for prior years.

The episode closes with how to explain the change to workers and onboard them properly as employees. As of December 2023, check current IRS guidance before applying.

Key takeaways

  • Do not choose a worker's classification by preference, because the IRS and other federal agencies apply their own tests.
  • If you are already under audit for worker classification, talk to a lawyer before doing anything else.
  • If you are not under audit, look at the IRS Voluntary Classification Settlement Program and Form 8952.
  • Check that you treated the workers consistently as contractors and filed all required 1099s before applying.
  • Submit Form 8952 well ahead of the reclassification date, at least 60 days and ideally 120 days before.
  • Tell reclassified workers the change is about compliance, not their performance, and explain what changes day to day.
  • Onboard reclassified workers fully as employees, including a W-4, an I-9 and any state-required training.

What happens if I misclassify an employee as an independent contractor?

If misclassification is found in an audit, the employer can be liable for everything it would have owed as an employer. In this episode, Rhamy explains that this can include the employment taxes the employer should have paid, the employee's share of taxes, benefits the worker would have been eligible for, vacation time, sick leave where a state requires it, and overtime that was never calculated, plus taxes, penalties and interest.

Rhamy says that, in his experience, the most common trigger is ending a long-time contractor relationship. The worker files for unemployment, says they have worked at the business for years, and that brings the Department of Labor in. He also stresses that neither the employer nor the worker gets to decide classification. The IRS, the Fair Labor Standards Act, the National Labor Relations Act and the EEOC each have rules about who is an employee.

What is the IRS Voluntary Classification Settlement Program?

The Voluntary Classification Settlement Program, or VCSP, is an IRS program that lets employers reclassify workers from independent contractors to employees going forward with limited consequences. In this episode, Rhamy calls it the ticket out for employers who discover the problem before an audit.

Under the VCSP, as Rhamy describes it as of December 2023, the employer agrees to pay 10% of the employment tax liability on compensation paid to the reclassified workers for the most recent tax year. Rhamy estimates that this comes to about 1% of those workers' wages. The employer is not liable for interest or penalties on that amount and is not subject to an employment tax audit on the classification of those workers for prior years. In exchange, the reclassification is permanent: the workers must be treated as employees for future tax periods. Check current IRS guidance before applying.

Who qualifies for the IRS Voluntary Classification Settlement Program?

In this episode, Rhamy explains three main requirements:

  1. Consistent treatment. You must have consistently treated the workers as nonemployees. That rules out cases where people in the same position were split between employees and contractors, or where a worker switched back and forth from year to year.
  2. Filed 1099s. You must have filed all required 1099 forms for the workers, showing you were not paying them under the table. Rhamy notes that late 1099s can still be filed, with some penalties.
  3. No current audit. You cannot currently be under audit for worker classification by the IRS, the Department of Labor or a state agency. If an agency is already investigating, Rhamy's advice is to call a lawyer.

As of December 2023, check current IRS guidance for the full eligibility rules.

How do I apply for the VCSP with Form 8952?

File IRS Form 8952, the Application for Voluntary Classification Settlement Program. In this episode, Rhamy explains that the form must be submitted at least 60 days before the date you plan to start treating the workers as employees, and he recommends 120 days. On the form you list the workers and the jobs being reclassified.

The taxpayer, meaning the business, must sign Form 8952 itself, not a representative. A lawyer or other representative with power of attorney can be involved in the process, but the settlement belongs to the business, so the owner needs to understand it. After the IRS reviews the application and verifies eligibility, it contacts the business or its representative to complete the process. The business must pay the full amount due under the closing agreement when it enters the program. As of December 2023, check current IRS instructions for the form.

How do I tell contractors they are being reclassified as employees?

Be transparent and explain exactly what changes. In this episode, Rhamy calls this communication delicate. Explain the change in classification, the effective date, and how it will affect day-to-day work: access to employee benefits and protections, tracking hours and clocking in and out for overtime, or being paid a salary if the role is exempt.

Assure workers that the reclassification is about complying with tax law and is not a reflection of their work or the value they bring. Some may see becoming an employee as a step down, but Rhamy expects most will be pleased, since it lowers their tax bill.

Then treat them as you would any new employee. Rhamy lists a handbook, a job offer letter, a W-4, an I-9 for employment eligibility, and sexual harassment training in states that require it. All the usual onboarding applies.

What are the downsides of the Voluntary Classification Settlement Program?

In this episode, Rhamy names two main tradeoffs. First, it requires an upfront payment: the employer must pay the full amount due under the closing agreement when entering the program. He estimates this at around 1% of the misclassified workers' wages, which can still be a significant sum for a small business.

Second, the change is permanent. Once an employer enters the VCSP, it must treat those workers as employees for future tax periods. Rhamy warns against reclassifying and then drifting back to old habits.

On the other side of the ledger, the program costs far less than the taxes, interest and penalties that could follow if the IRS discovered the misclassification on its own, and it closes off a classification audit of those workers for prior years. Rhamy recommends weighing the pros and cons, confirming eligibility and considering a conversation with a lawyer before applying. As of December 2023, check current guidance.

About this episode

🤯 Are your workers 1099 contractors when they should be W2 employees? 😱 Dive into our latest episode for a step-by-step guide to rectify the situation of employee misclassification. Learn how the Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (VCSP) can save you from hefty penalties and reshape your tax compliance.