Don't HR Alone · Episode 8
Crucial FLSA Update: Independent Contractor vs. Employee Classification Final Rule
Many small businesses pay some workers as 1099 independent contractors without testing whether the relationship would hold up under the Fair Labor Standards Act. In January 2024, the Department of Labor issued a final rule changing how that test works, effective March 11, 2024. In this episode, Rhamy explains what the rule meant for employers at the time and why they needed to review their contractors.
The classic independent contractor is a business you hire, such as a painter who has many clients, brings their own tools and decides how to get the job done. Many working relationships are less clear. Under the FLSA, the question is economic dependence: is the worker economically dependent on the business for work, or in business for themselves?
As of January 2024, the rule moved away from the prior 2021 approach, which gave two core factors extra weight, and back to a review of the totality of the circumstances using six factors: opportunity for profit or loss, investments by the worker and the business, permanence of the relationship, nature and degree of control, whether the work is integral to the business, and skill and initiative. No single factor decides the outcome.
The episode closes with the point that what happens in practice matters more than what a contract says, and with Rhamy's advice to review every independent contractor relationship. This rule has been subject to later change, so check current Department of Labor guidance before relying on it.
Key takeaways
- Review every worker you pay as an independent contractor against the federal economic reality test, not just the job title or contract.
- Ask whether the worker is economically dependent on your business or genuinely in business for themselves.
- Weigh all of the factors together, since under the January 2024 rule no single factor decides the outcome.
- Treat a worker whose only way to earn more is working more hours as a likely employee.
- Make sure day-to-day practice matches the contract, because actual practice outweighs what is written down.
- Check current Department of Labor guidance before relying on this rule, since federal contractor rules have changed more than once.
What changed in the 2024 DOL independent contractor rule?
In January 2024, the Department of Labor issued a final rule under the Fair Labor Standards Act on classifying workers as employees or independent contractors, effective March 11, 2024. In this episode, Rhamy explains that the rule moved away from the 2021 approach, which allowed a two-factor test where two core factors carried the most weight.
Under the 2024 rule, employers had to look at six economic reality factors and then assess the relationship based on the totality of the circumstances. No single factor or subset of factors is necessarily decisive, the weight of each depends on the facts, and the six factors are not exhaustive.
Rhamy's practical message at the time was to review existing independent contractors for compliance before the effective date. As of January 2024, this was the federal standard. Federal contractor rules have changed more than once, so check current Department of Labor guidance before relying on it.
What is the economic reality test for independent contractors?
The economic reality test is how the Department of Labor determines whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor under the Fair Labor Standards Act. In this episode, Rhamy explains that the core question is economic dependence. A worker is an employee if, as a matter of economic reality, they are economically dependent on the business for work. They are an independent contractor if they are, as a matter of economic reality, in business for themselves.
The classic contractor example is a painter hired to paint an office. The painter holds themselves out as a business, has many clients, possibly including your competitors, provides their own tools and decides the methods, software and processes to deliver the job at the lowest cost. Many relationships are less clear than that, which is where the factors come in. As of January 2024, check current guidance, since the federal test has changed over time.
How do profit, loss and investment affect independent contractor status?
Under the January 2024 rule, two of the six factors look at the worker's business. The first is the opportunity for profit or loss depending on managerial skill. Relevant facts include whether the worker sets or negotiates their pay, accepts or declines jobs, markets their services, and decides to hire helpers, buy materials and equipment, or rent space. If the only way a worker can earn more is to work more hours or take more jobs at a fixed rate, that points toward employee status. Rhamy gives examples of business decisions that do count, such as choosing tools and software or buying a bigger truck.
The second is investments by the worker and the business. Investments that are capital or entrepreneurial in nature, such as ones that let the worker take on more or different work or reach more customers, point toward contractor status. Tools bought for one specific job do not. As of January 2024; check current guidance.
How do control and permanence affect worker classification?
Both are factors in the January 2024 rule's six-factor test.
Nature and degree of control. Signs of employee status include the business setting the worker's schedule, supervising the work, limiting their ability to work for others, monitoring them through technology, reserving the right to discipline, or controlling the prices they charge. Steps taken solely to comply with a specific law or regulation do not count as control. More control by the business points toward employee; more control by the worker points toward contractor.
Permanence of the relationship. A relationship that is indefinite, continuous or exclusive points toward employee status. One that is definite in duration, non-exclusive, project-based or sporadic points toward contractor status. In this episode, Rhamy gives the example of a one-time project to redo a website. Seasonal work alone does not make someone a contractor. As of January 2024; check current guidance.
Does it matter if the work is a core part of my business?
Yes. Under the January 2024 rule, one of the six factors is whether the work is an integral part of the business. It looks at whether the function the worker performs is critical, necessary or central to the business's principal work. If it is, that points toward employee status.
In this episode, Rhamy uses his own company as an example. People Processes is an HR company. A client can hire an HR consultant as an independent contractor to work on its business, because that consultant controls their own schedule and how they deliver the project. It is much harder for an HR company to use independent contractors to consult for its own clients, because that work is its core service.
A related factor is skill and initiative. Specialized skill on its own does not make someone a contractor, since employees can be skilled too. What matters is using that skill with business-like initiative. As of January 2024; check current guidance.
Does an independent contractor agreement make someone a contractor?
No. In this episode, Rhamy stresses that actual practice matters more than what the contract says. A business can write an agreement that gives a worker control over their schedule and the right to turn down jobs, but if in reality the worker cannot decline work or set their own hours, the agreement will not carry much weight.
The point is to classify workers according to the economic realities of the work, not just the terms of the contract. Writing things down differently while continuing the same day-to-day practices does not change the analysis. When reviewing contractors, look at how the relationship actually operates: who sets the schedule, who decides which jobs get done, whether the worker can work for others, and whether they can grow their earnings through business decisions rather than more hours. As of January 2024, check current Department of Labor guidance.
About this episode
The U.S. Department of Labor published the issuance of the final rule under The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) regarding Employee or Independent Contractor Classification. 🎙️ In this episode, Rhamy Alejeal, CEO of People Processes, breaks down the major Fair Labor Standards Act update arriving in March 2024. Discover the key changes impacting the classification of independent contractors and employees.
📆 Mark your calendar for the effective date! March 11, 2024, is approaching, and it's time to reevaluate your independent contractors' status to guarantee compliance. Learn how these changes affect your workforce and the steps you need to take.
🔗 For more insights and assistance in navigating these updates, visit https://peopleprocesses.com. Our team at People Processes is here to support organizations across the United States in handling HR with expertise and precision.


