Don't HR Alone · Episode 12
How to choose: Employee, independent contractor, or both?
An employee owns a side business, and the company would like to hire that business for a project. Can the same person be a W-2 employee and a 1099 independent contractor for the same employer at once? In this episode, Rhamy explains when dual classification is possible and how to evaluate it.
The short answer is yes, in limited situations. Rhamy walks through examples such as an executive assistant whose cleaning company cleans the employer's offices in the evening, an IT help desk associate who designs a new company logo through a graphic design side business, and a school custodian who also runs a snow plowing service the county contracts with.
The key is that any extra work must be evaluated on its own against the Department of Labor and IRS factors. If the employer still controls the person in the second role, the work is simply an extension of their job and must be treated as employment. If the factors show a genuine independent contractor relationship, most often because the employee has an established outside business, the employer can treat that work as contract work. Rhamy outlines the IRS's three areas to review: behavioral control, financial control and the relationship of the parties.
The episode closes with a reminder that employers who are unsure can ask the IRS for a determination using Form SS-8. As of March 2024, federal classification standards have continued to change, so check current guidance.
Key takeaways
- Evaluate any extra work a current employee does for you separately against the IRS and Department of Labor factors.
- Treat the extra work as employment if you still control how, when or what the person does in that role.
- Consider independent contractor treatment for the extra work mainly when the employee runs an established outside business.
- Review behavioral control, financial control and the relationship of the parties before issuing a 1099 to a current employee.
- Expect the person to receive a W-2 for the employee work and a 1099 for any properly classified contract work.
- Ask the IRS for a determination on Form SS-8 if the classification is unclear.
Can someone be both an employee and an independent contractor for the same company?
Yes, in limited situations. In this episode, Rhamy explains that a person can hold dual classification when the extra work they do for their employer genuinely qualifies as independent contractor work on its own. In that case, they receive a W-2 for their employee work and a 1099 for the contract work.
The rule is that any extra work a current employee takes on must be evaluated against the Department of Labor and IRS factors. If that review shows the employer still controls the person in the secondary role, the work is just an extension of their employment duties and cannot be treated as contract work. If the factors show a true independent contractor relationship, the employer can choose to treat that extra work as contract work. Rhamy notes this is most common when the employee has an established outside business. As of March 2024, check current guidance, since federal classification standards have changed over time.
What are examples of an employee who is also an independent contractor?
In this episode, Rhamy gives several examples of possible dual classification:
- Executive assistant who owns a cleaning service, when the employer contracts with that cleaning company to clean the offices in the evenings.
- IT help desk associate with a graphic design side business, when the employer contracts with them to create a new company logo.
- Electrician who does handyman work in the community after hours, when they contract with their employer to replace the company's roof.
- School custodian who runs his own snow plowing service on nights and weekends, when the county contracts with him for snow plowing.
- Laid-off production worker who starts doing janitorial work for local companies, including the company that laid them off.
In each case, the contract work is separate from the person's job and done through their own business. Each still needs to be evaluated against the classification factors.
What IRS factors determine if a worker is an employee or a contractor?
In this episode, Rhamy outlines three areas the IRS looks at:
- Behavioral control. Does the company control, or have the right to control, what the worker does and how they do the job?
- Financial control. Does the business direct the financial side of the work, such as how the worker is paid, whether expenses are reimbursed, and who provides tools and supplies?
- Relationship of the parties. Are there written contracts or employee-type benefits such as a pension plan, insurance or vacation pay? Will the relationship continue, and is the work a key aspect of the business?
Applied to an employee whose cleaning business cleans the employer's offices at night: the worker decides how the cleaning is done, stands to make a profit or take a loss, and the cleaning is not a key part of the employer's business. That points toward contractor treatment for the cleaning work. As of March 2024, check current IRS guidance.
When must extra work by an employee be paid as employment?
When the employer still controls the person in the extra role. In this episode, Rhamy explains that if the classification factors show the employer remains in control of the individual in the secondary role, the work is merely an extension of their employment duties. The employee cannot be classified as an independent contractor for that work, and it should run through payroll like the rest of their job.
In practice, warning signs include the employer directing how and when the extra work gets done, supplying the tools and materials, paying for it the way it pays wages, or the work being a key part of what the business does. Contract treatment is most defensible when the employee operates an established outside business that serves other customers, makes its own decisions about how to do the work, and can make a profit or take a loss. As of March 2024, check current guidance before classifying.
What is IRS Form SS-8?
Form SS-8 is the IRS form for requesting a determination of worker status, titled Determination of Worker Status for Purposes of Federal Employment Taxes and Income Tax Withholding. In this episode, Rhamy points to it as an option for employers who are unsure whether a worker, including a current employee doing extra work, should be treated as an employee or an independent contractor.
Submitting the form asks the IRS to review the facts of the working relationship and make the call. It can be useful in the dual classification situations the episode covers, such as an employee whose outside business also does work for the employer, where the line between an extension of the job and genuine contract work is not obvious. Rhamy compares dual classification to walking a tightrope: it is possible, but precision is key. As of March 2024, check current IRS guidance on the form and process.
About this episode
🕵️♂️ Can you be both an employee and an independent contractor at the same time? Dive deep into the legal and financial intricacies of dual employment statuses, including crucial DOL and IRS factors, through real-world examples and expert analysis. Whether you're evaluating secondary roles within your current employment or considering hiring employees for independent tasks, this discussion is packed with insights on navigating these dual roles legally and effectively.


