Don't HR Alone · Episode 6
Are You Choosing the Right Safe Harbor Match for Your 401(k)? Find Out Now!
A 401(k) match helps attract and keep good employees, but small employers often default to whatever match formula their provider suggests without weighing cost, incentives or vesting. In this episode, Rhamy explains the most common safe harbor match designs and how to choose among them.
A safe harbor match comes with fewer compliance hurdles than a traditional 401(k), which is its main appeal. The tradeoff is less flexibility. Employers that want longer vesting schedules or bigger or smaller matches cannot use safe harbor and instead face restrictions to pass compliance testing.
Rhamy walks through three designs. The most common matches 100% of employee contributions up to 3% of pay, then 50% of the next 2%, for a maximum match of 4%. It is generous, but the match is not subject to vesting, so employees take it with them when they leave. The design Rhamy recommends for most small businesses starting out matches 100% of the first 1% of pay and 50% of the next 5%, for a maximum of 3.5%, and allows a two-year vesting schedule. For employers that want to go further, he describes a dollar-for-dollar match up to 6% of pay, also with optional two-year vesting.
The episode closes with Rhamy's advice to fit the match to the company's budget and the incentives it wants to create, and his preference for a design with vesting. As of December 2023, plan rules should be confirmed with your plan provider.
Key takeaways
- Decide whether safe harbor fits before choosing a formula, since it limits vesting and match size in exchange for fewer compliance hurdles.
- Model the cost of each match at different employee contribution levels before choosing one.
- Know that the common 100% of 3% plus 50% of the next 2% match caps at 4% of pay but carries no vesting.
- Consider a 100% of 1% plus 50% of the next 5% design if you want a lower maximum cost of 3.5% and a two-year vesting schedule.
- Use vesting to reward employees who stay, so the match supports retention rather than leaving with short-term hires.
- Confirm the exact rules for any safe harbor design with your plan provider or benefits specialist before adopting it.
What is a safe harbor 401(k) match?
A safe harbor match is an employer contribution formula that lets a 401(k) plan clear compliance requirements with fewer hurdles than a traditional plan. In this episode, Rhamy compares it to a VIP pass at a concert: fewer hurdles, more perks, quick and easy.
The tradeoff is flexibility. Rhamy explains that employers interested in longer vesting schedules, more control, or bigger or smaller matches will not be able to use safe harbor. That is a legitimate choice, but it means the plan will face restrictions designed to make it pass compliance testing. For many small businesses, the simplicity of safe harbor is worth the limits. The next decision is which safe harbor formula to use, since the options differ in cost, in how much employees must save to get the full match, and in whether vesting is allowed. As of December 2023, confirm current plan rules with your provider.
How does the standard safe harbor match of 100% of 3% and 50% of the next 2% work?
The employer matches every dollar an employee contributes up to 3% of pay, then 50 cents on the dollar for the next 2% of pay, so the match maxes out at 4% of pay. In this episode, Rhamy calls this the normal option and the one most standard small businesses use.
His examples show how it plays out:
- Employee contributes 1%: employer contributes 1%
- Employee contributes 3%: employer contributes 3%
- Employee contributes 4%: employer contributes 3.5%
- Employee contributes 5%: employer contributes 4%
- Employee contributes 20%: employer still contributes 4%
The formula is generous and encourages employees to save a decent share of pay. Its downside, Rhamy notes, is that there is no vesting. The match belongs to the employee as soon as it goes in, and they can take it with them when they leave, roll it into a new 401(k) or cash it out.
Which safe harbor match is best for a small business?
For most small businesses getting started, Rhamy recommends a match of 100% of the first 1% of pay followed by 50% of the next 5%. An employee who contributes 6% receives a 3.5% match, which is the maximum.
He prefers this design for two reasons. First, the company's total cost is a bit lower than the standard 4% formula, and employees have to contribute 6% instead of 5% to get the full match, which encourages more saving. Second, unlike the standard formula, this design can carry a two-year vesting schedule, so employees need to stay to keep the match. Rhamy calls it a great starter plan that will not break the bank and puts the right incentives in place.
This design, with its two-year vesting, is a safe harbor that requires automatic enrollment, known as a qualified automatic contribution arrangement (QACA). As of December 2023, confirm the rules for this formula with your plan provider before adopting it.
Can a safe harbor 401(k) match have a vesting schedule?
Some safe harbor designs can. In this episode, Rhamy explains that the most common formula, 100% of the first 3% of pay plus 50% of the next 2%, has no vesting: the match is the employee's money as soon as it is deposited.
Two designs he describes allow a two-year vesting schedule. One matches 100% of the first 1% of pay and 50% of the next 5%. The other, a more generous go-big option, matches dollar for dollar up to 6% of pay. With two-year vesting, an employee who does not complete two years of service, with at least 1,000 hours in each year, forfeits the employer match. The 3.5% and 6% match designs with two-year vesting are safe harbor designs that require automatic enrollment, known as a qualified automatic contribution arrangement (QACA). Rhamy strongly prefers a design with vesting because it ties the match to retention and rewards employees who stay. As of December 2023, check current rules with your plan provider, since eligibility for vesting depends on the specific safe harbor design.
How should an employer choose a 401(k) match formula?
Choose based on budget, the incentives you want to create and how your employees save. In this episode, Rhamy says choosing a match is not about picking a number from a hat. A well-structured match helps attract and retain talent, boosts participation and gives employees a reason to stay.
Start by deciding whether safe harbor fits. If you want longer vesting or more control over match size, a traditional plan with compliance testing may suit you better. If safe harbor fits, compare the formulas: what each one costs at different contribution levels, how much an employee must contribute to get the full match, and whether it allows vesting. There are many other safe harbor setups beyond the three in the episode. Rhamy recommends working with a financial expert or benefits specialist to fit the plan to your budget and goals.
About this episode
Ever asked why safe harbor matches rock the 401(k) world? When it comes to offering a competitive and attractive retirement plan for your employees, a 401(k) plan with a safe harbor match is an excellent option. Safe harbor matches ensure that your plan meets certain requirements set by the IRS, making it more accessible and beneficial for your employees. However, with several safe harbor match options available, it's crucial to select the one that aligns best with your company's goals and financial capacity. In this episode, we'll walk you through the different safe harbor match options and help you determine which one might be most suitable for your group 401(k) plan.


