Don't HR Alone · Episode 50
How to Write a Job Description That Actually Works
An employee insists they are doing a good job while their manager knows the work is not going anywhere, or a newly promoted employee is unsure what is expected. In this episode, Rhamy argues that these are often documentation and communication problems, rooted in a sloppy or outdated job description, and shows how to write one that works.
He separates job descriptions from job ads. A job ad is a marketing tool for recruiting. A job description is about retention, performance, compliance and clarity: it sets expectations, gives a path to build competency, helps protect the company from legal risk and defines what it takes to earn raises and promotions.
The process starts with job analysis: interviewing employees, managers, colleagues and even clients about the role's goals, priorities, failure points, competencies and required certifications, and checking benchmark sources like the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook. From there, identify the essential functions for ADA purposes and use a clear format that includes FLSA classification, work environment and physical demands. Rhamy also recommends a disclaimer that the description is not a complete list of duties and that responsibilities may change.
The episode closes with how to use the finished document: review it with the employee, keep it accessible and update it annually. Rhamy lists common mistakes and suggests auditing one description now, starting with a role many people hold.
Key takeaways
- Start every job description with a job analysis that includes interviews with the people who do the job, manage it and depend on it.
- Identify which duties are truly essential for ADA purposes: done regularly, not easily reassigned and a real problem if left undone.
- Include the job title, department, FLSA classification, reporting line, essential functions, competencies, qualifications, work environment and physical demands.
- Add a disclaimer that the description is not a complete list of duties and that responsibilities may change.
- Review each job description with the employee and manager, and update it at least once a year.
- Audit one job description now, starting with a role many employees hold rather than a single executive role.
What is the purpose of a job description?
A job description defines a role so that everyone shares the same understanding of it. In this episode, Rhamy explains that when done right, a job description is one of the most powerful tools in a business, not HR red tape. It sets clear performance expectations, gives a path to develop competency, helps protect the company from legal risk and defines what someone needs to do for their pay and promotions to grow. It also aligns the role with the broader company goals.
It differs from a job ad. A job ad is a marketing tool for recruiting. A job description is about retention, performance, compliance and clarity. Rhamy points out that many performance problems, such as an employee who thinks they are doing well when they are not, or a confused new manager, are really documentation and communication problems rooted in a sloppy or outdated job description.
How do you do a job analysis?
By talking to the people who know the job best. In this episode, Rhamy describes job analysis as the first step in any job design. Interview current employees, their managers, cross-functional partners and even clients about what they need the role to accomplish.
Ask about the role's goals and how they are prioritized, what happens when things go wrong, what personalities tend to do well, and what competencies and skills someone needs to succeed. Capture any required certifications, the tools used, the decisions the person makes, and what breaks if the job is not done.
Rhamy also recommends checking benchmark sources like the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook, which has useful guides for many occupations. A common mistake he sees is skipping this step, which leads to no alignment between the employee, the manager and HR on what the job really needs to do.
How do you identify essential job functions for the ADA?
Ask which duties the job truly cannot do without. In this episode, Rhamy explains that for ADA compliance, a job description should identify which duties are essential. His working test has three parts: the duty is done regularly, it cannot simply be assigned to someone else, and there is a real problem if it is not done. A duty that meets all three is an essential function.
List those essential functions as bullet points in the job description. For the same ADA reasons, he recommends including the work environment and physical demands of the role.
The point is to cover the essentials and key competencies, not an exhaustive list of every task.
What should be included in a job description?
The episode recommends a consistent structure:
- Job title and department
- FLSA classification
- Who the role reports to
- A summary of the position
- Essential functions, as bullet points
- Competencies and skills the person needs to have and grow
- Required qualifications
- Work environment and physical demands
- Travel requirements
- Supervisory responsibilities
- A disclaimer
Rhamy stresses clarity throughout. Avoid vague phrases, such as strong communication skills with no context, and avoid copying from outdated templates. When you audit a description, ask whether it reflects the role's current responsibilities, whether someone new to the organization could understand it, and whether it includes the essential functions, competencies, tools, compliance disclaimer and expectations.
Why does a job description need a disclaimer?
Because jobs change, and a job description that is too rigid causes problems. In this episode, Rhamy says writing overly rigid descriptions is a mistake he sees companies make all the time.
His recommended best practice is a statement saying the job description is not designed to cover or contain a comprehensive list of duties, and that responsibilities may change with or without notice. That protects both the company and the employee from unrealistic expectations on either side.
Missing that disclaimer is on his list of common mistakes, alongside vague wording, outdated templates and a lack of alignment between the employee, manager and HR. The disclaimer works together with the goal of the document itself: describe the essentials, key competencies and expectations clearly, rather than trying to list every task the person might ever do.
Do employees need to sign their job description?
It is good practice but not legally required. In this episode, Rhamy recommends that the employee and their manager sit down, go through the job description together and both sign it. That meeting builds a shared understanding of the role and creates documentation for future performance conversations, giving both the manager and the employee something to measure performance against.
He is clear that there is no legal reason a signature is required. The job description could simply be acknowledged or emailed to the employee, and he says that does not create a compliance issue. The value is in the joint understanding.
After that, keep the description accessible so employees can check it when they have questions, and update it annually. Rhamy notes that managers often use it more than employees, to look at what the person was hired to do and to judge performance against it, making it an ongoing reference rather than a hiring tool.
About this episode
Want expert help creating job descriptions that actually work? employers with 10+ employees) →
Most companies treat job descriptions like paperwork — but they’re actually one of your most powerful tools for retention, accountability, and legal protection.
In this episode, you’ll learn how to design job descriptions that are strategic, legally sound, and performance-driving.
You’ll learn: ✅ How to perform a real job analysis ✅ The key sections every job description must include ✅ How to prevent legal and performance issues with clarity ✅ Why a clear job description can fix performance, not just document it
Drop your biggest job description question in the comments — Rhamy reads and replies personally!


