Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 56
How We Saved $130,000 in Workers’ Comp Without Changing Carriers
Chapters (9)
Workers' comp premiums that climb every year are often blamed on the market. In this episode, Rhamy shows how they can instead come from job descriptions that do not match what employees actually do, and from records too thin to prove otherwise. He walks through a real client case where People Processes found more than $130,000 a year in preventable overspend without changing carriers.
The client, a sign manufacturer operating in four states, had just seen its workers' comp premium rise another 10%. A review of their policy and payroll by class code and state showed nearly 80% of employees listed under a higher risk category than their work justified. Designers who sat at a computer most of the day were classed like crews who climb billboards, and with no time tracking for split roles, whole roles defaulted to the highest risk code.
Rhamy explains how class codes, state coverage and the annual premium audit work, then lays out what the team did: interviewed department heads and frontline staff, rebuilt job descriptions, added time tracking for split roles, prepared reclassification packets with the existing broker and shopped the policy with two other brokers. The client saved more than $130,000 and got better coverage.
The episode closes with ongoing controls, including a quarterly payroll report by class code and a liability account for audit true-ups, plus a comparison of traditional and pay-as-you-go billing.
Key takeaways
- Pull your current workers' comp policy and check that each role's class code reflects what people do today, not what they used to do.
- Rewrite job descriptions so they are specific enough to hold up in front of an auditor or claims adjuster.
- Track time by work type and location for employees with split duties, because an undocumented split defaults to the highest risk code.
- Tell your carrier about any employees working in other states, since each state needs coverage and rates differ by state.
- Run a quarterly payroll report by class code so you can see audit adjustments coming and set money aside for them.
- Compare traditional annual billing with pay-as-you-go based on how stable your headcount and roles are.
Why are my workers' comp premiums so high?
Often because employees are coded under riskier classifications than their actual work justifies. In this episode, Rhamy describes a client whose broker said rising premiums were just the market. The client's premium had just risen another 10%. Rhamy calls that more than a market shift and a signal that something deeper is wrong, usually with classifications and documentation.
When People Processes broke down the client's payroll by code and state, nearly 80% of employees were listed under a higher risk category than their work justified. Some people doing mostly desk work were classified under field or production roles. Others had split duties with no time tracking to show how much time went to each, so the whole role defaulted to the highest risk code. Fixing the classifications, not changing carriers, is what brought the cost down.
What is a workers' comp class code?
A class code is a number, typically four digits, assigned to each employee on payroll to identify the nature of their work, and it drives the premium rate. In this episode, Rhamy gives two examples: 8810 is clerical work, the most common code and very low risk, while 9501 covers scenic painters or sign fabricators, a much higher risk category.
Codes are not assigned by payroll software. They are based on the work the employee actually performs, and keeping them accurate is the employer's responsibility. If codes are wrong, whether by accident or because no one has updated them in years, you can be hit hard in the annual audit. Rhamy says the bigger danger runs the other way: if you have not covered the risks your people actually take, an injury may not be covered. An employee coded 8810 who is out moving traffic cones every day is a problem.
How does a workers' comp premium audit work?
Every workers' comp policy includes an audit, and it is standard rather than a punishment. In this episode, Rhamy explains that you are quoted based on estimated payroll by location and classification for the coming year. At the end of the policy year, the carrier reconciles that estimate against your actual payroll records, such as your 941s.
If you estimated $1 million in plumbers and $400,000 in office staff but actually ran $2 million in plumbing payroll, you will owe the difference at the audit, and your next year's estimate goes up too. If the carrier overcharged you, you get a credit. Rhamy describes this as a feature: you get coverage for the whole year even if you grew. The catch is that your records have to be tight. If you cannot document who did what, the default assumption is risk, and that means higher cost.
Do I need workers' comp coverage for employees working in another state?
Yes, according to this episode. Rhamy explains that workers' comp is handled state by state. If your employees are insured in one state, such as Tennessee, but go work in another, such as Mississippi, they are working under different regulations and you need coverage for that state. Most policies handle this with addendums that add each additional state.
Rates also differ by state for the same class code. In the client case Rhamy describes, the company worked in several states, and he notes that New York was more expensive than Vermont, which was more expensive than Maryland. Tracking where people work, not just what they do, made a big difference in the final premium. His advice: if you have employees on the ground in another state, tell your carrier and have a way to track their hours by location.
How can I lower workers' comp costs without switching insurance carriers?
Correct how your employees are represented on paper. In this episode, Rhamy walks through the steps People Processes used for a client:
- Request the current policy and break payroll down by class code and state.
- Interview department heads and frontline employees about what they actually do every day, and review time sheets and hours by function.
- Build a new classification map, role by role and location by location.
- Rewrite job descriptions so they are accurate and match reality.
- Add time tracking so split-role employees document time by work type and location.
- Walk the existing broker through the findings with reclassification justification packets, and shop the policy with alternative brokers to confirm it is competitive.
The client saved more than $130,000 and got better coverage, without cutting headcount or changing carriers.
What is pay-as-you-go workers' comp?
Pay-as-you-go calculates the premium every payroll based on actual wages and job codes, and pays it right away. In this episode, Rhamy contrasts it with traditional annual billing, which most of his clients use: estimated premiums are paid during the year, quarterly in his client's case, and reconciled once a year at the audit.
Traditional billing works well when the team is stable and classifications are accurate. If you are growing, shifting roles or hiring seasonally, it can create audit whiplash and a big cash need at renewal. Pay-as-you-go avoids the large upfront bill and reduces audit surprises, but Rhamy notes it is not always available and often not cheaper, since the large policies are annual. His client stayed on a traditional policy because its team was stable and the pay-as-you-go carriers cost more. Instead, they added a quarterly payroll report by class code and a liability account so audit adjustments are expected.
About this episode
What if your workers’ comp premiums are inflated by outdated job codes and sloppy records? In this episode, Rhamy shares how People Processes saved one client over $130,000 a year—not through discounts or new carriers, but through accurate job documentation, audit prep, and classification correction.
Here’s what you’ll learn: • Why most businesses overpay for workers’ comp • How classification codes are misunderstood • What auditors really look for • State-specific pitfalls in multi-location teams • The step-by-step audit strategy People Processes uses


