Don't HR Alone · Episode 61

Pay Transparency Mistakes That Cost You Talent (And How to Fix Them)

September 18, 202513 minHosted by Rhamy Alejeal
Chapters (8)

Pay problems rarely start at the exit interview. In this episode, Rhamy explains how a single raise can set off a chain of resignations when a company cannot explain why people are paid what they are, and how to build a compensation system that holds up when employees compare notes.

The case involves a company of about 70 employees that promoted a top performer into a manager role, moving her salary from the low eighties to $96,000. Word spread, and a longer-tenured manager asked why he was paid less. Leadership had no salary bands, no compensation philosophy and no documentation, and focused on how the employee found out. Within two weeks, two other high-performing managers resigned and another asked for a counteroffer. Rhamy points out that employees across the United States are allowed to discuss their pay with each other.

The People Processes audit found no equity violation, just a lack of logic: raises based on memory and gut feel, inconsistent job titles, and bigger raises for louder employees. Over 60 days the team wrote a compensation philosophy, built salary bands, ran an internal pay audit that adjusted three underpaid roles and paused raises for two, trained managers to talk about pay, and updated job postings for states that require salary ranges.

The episode closes with common objections to pay structure, from "we just pay what we can afford" to "we're too small for salary bands," and the habits of companies that run compensation as a system.

Key takeaways

  • Write a compensation philosophy that states your priorities, such as performance-based growth, market alignment and internal equity.
  • Set salary bands with a minimum, midpoint and maximum for each common role and level, and review them every year.
  • Run an internal pay audit to find people outside their bands and fix gaps before employees find them.
  • Do not try to stop employees from discussing pay, since they are allowed to, and focus on being able to explain every decision.
  • Document the reason for each pay difference, such as tenure, credentials or performance reviews.
  • Check pay range requirements for job postings, promotions and offer letters in every state where you hire, including for remote roles.

Can employers stop employees from discussing their pay?

No. In this episode, Rhamy explains that employees across the United States are allowed to discuss their pay with each other. The right comes from protections tied to collective bargaining, and it applies even where there is no union. Many states have gone further with pay transparency laws.

In the case Rhamy describes, leadership's first instinct after a pay complaint was to find out how the employee learned a colleague's salary and who was talking about pay. He says that line of conversation goes nowhere. Relying on employees not talking to each other is not a strategy, because they will. The better approach is to have a system that explains pay: a written philosophy, salary bands and documented reasons for differences. As of September 2025; check current guidance.

Which states require salary ranges in job postings?

As of September 2025, Rhamy names Colorado, California, New York, Washington and Illinois as states that require salary ranges on job ads, and says more are coming. In some states, the requirements go beyond job postings to pay range disclosures for promotions, offer letters and other points in the employment relationship.

Rhamy explains that these rules can apply even if your business is based elsewhere. If you hire remotely into one of these states, or a remote hire reports to someone in one of them, the law may apply. For his client, People Processes created a national standard for job postings so remote hires across those areas were covered. Because these laws are changing quickly, check current requirements in every state where you hire.

What does pay transparency require employers to share?

It does not mean publishing everyone's paycheck. In this episode, Rhamy explains that transparency means defining salary bands, justifying how offers and raises are determined, and explaining how someone progresses within a range. A transparent answer sounds like "this role pays $70,000 to $90,000 depending on scope, certification, location and years of experience," not "she negotiated better."

Documentation is what protects you. Rhamy's example: if two employees do similar work with a $10,000 pay gap and you cannot point to a documented difference, such as tenure, credentials or performance reviews, you are exposed. Pay discrimination based on characteristics such as age, race, religion or gender is prohibited, so an unexplained gap invites the assumption that one of those is the reason. Even where the gap is not an equity issue, it becomes a cultural problem when employees find out.

How do you build salary bands for a small business?

Start with a compensation philosophy and work down. In this episode, Rhamy describes what People Processes did for a 70-person client in 60 days:

  1. Write the philosophy. Leadership defined its priorities: performance-based growth, market alignment and internal equity.
  2. Build bands. Each common role and level got a minimum, midpoint and maximum, aligned with geography, industry benchmarks and scope differences inside the company.
  3. Audit internal pay. The audit found five primary outliers. Three underpaid roles were adjusted up, and raises were paused for two people whose pay had outpaced their responsibilities. Rhamy is clear that no one was let go for being overpaid.
  4. Train managers to talk about pay with clear, repeatable frameworks.
  5. Update job postings for state pay range laws.

The result, he says, was not a fix to one number but a system that earned trust.

Why do pay secrecy and unexplained raises cause turnover?

Because silence creates assumptions, assumptions become resentment and resentment turns into turnover. In this episode, Rhamy says most of the damage from pay transparency problems is relational, not legal. The moment someone feels their pay is arbitrary or secretive, their loyalty shifts: they start listening to recruiters, stop bringing problems forward and lose trust in leadership.

In his client's case, one promotion from the low eighties to $96,000 led a longer-tenured manager to ask why he earned less. Leadership had no bands or documentation to explain the decision. Within two weeks, two other high-performing managers resigned and another asked for a counteroffer. The audit later found no equity violation, just a lack of logic: raises based on gut feel, inconsistent titles, and bigger raises for louder employees and more aggressive managers. The perception of favoritism did the damage.

Do small companies need a compensation structure?

Yes. In this episode, Rhamy responds to the most common objections:

  • "We just pay what we can afford." Without a framework you overpay some roles and underpay others. A company can choose to pay at the 25th percentile; once you know the market pays $60,000 and you pay $45,000, you have a basis to work from.
  • "If they don't ask, we don't tell." Silence creates assumptions and resentment. Addressing pay up front prevents surprise conversations.
  • "We're too small for salary bands." If you are big enough to promote, you are big enough to explain why.
  • "We just look at market data." Market data is a tool. Without a policy and structure around it, decisions still look arbitrary.

The best-run companies, he says, write a philosophy, set bands reviewed annually, audit pay, train managers and communicate proactively.

About this episode

One promotion. One raise. One poorly handled pay conversation — that’s all it takes to spark resignations, lawsuits, and a cultural breakdown. Most turnover linked to pay transparency issues starts weeks before an exit interview, when employees feel pay decisions are arbitrary or secretive.

In this episode of Don’t HR Alone, you’ll learn: • The #1 mistake leaders make when giving raises • Why pay secrecy quietly fuels turnover • How to build salary bands that stop resignations • The compliance risks hidden in promotion conversations • A proven 3-step framework to fix pay transparency problems