Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 51
The Onboarding Mistakes That Make New Hires Quit
Chapters (10)
When a new hire walks in to find no one expecting them, a desk that is not set up and a pile of paperwork in place of training, many start wondering on day one whether they made a mistake. In this episode, Rhamy explains why weak onboarding drives new employees away and lays out a structured plan to fix it.
Rhamy cites figures showing that companies with great onboarding see 82% higher employee retention and 70% higher productivity in the first 12 months, while a bad experience sends one in five new employees toward the exit, sometimes before their first paycheck.
The episode starts with a distinction: orientation is a one-time crash course in policies and paperwork, while onboarding is the longer work of integrating someone into the culture, how decisions get made and what success looks like. The best programs last at least 90 days, and many run a full year.
Rhamy then walks through four phases: pre-onboarding between the offer and the start date, a structured first day, foundation building in weeks one to four, and continuous development from month one through month six and beyond. He covers the five most common mistakes, including treating onboarding as a checklist, information overload, unclear expectations, ignoring culture and dropping follow-up after week one.
The episode closes with how technology, such as a central new hire hub and short learning modules, makes onboarding repeatable and easier to improve over time.
Key takeaways
- Treat orientation and onboarding as different things, and plan onboarding to run at least 90 days.
- Use the time between the offer and the start date to send a welcome email, set up workspace and logins, and assign a buddy or mentor.
- Give new hires a structured first-day agenda and involve them with their team right away, even if formal training comes later.
- Set clear goals and performance expectations in the first weeks, and start new hires on real projects with deadlines.
- Schedule 30, 60 and 90 day check-ins at a minimum, and watch for the engagement dip around the six month mark.
- Break training into short, interactive sessions mixed with shadowing or real work instead of long days of slides.
What is the difference between onboarding and orientation?
Orientation is a one-and-done crash course: policies, paperwork and where the bathroom is. It is necessary, but it is only a small piece of bringing someone into a company.
Onboarding is about integration, culture, decision making and productivity, and it does not happen in a day. A new employee needs to understand what success looks like in their role, which behaviors will drive that success, and what kinds of decisions they need to make to align with the company's needs. They also need to know who to turn to for help, whether to go to a manager, a coworker or HR first, and how things actually work beyond the employee handbook. In this episode, Rhamy explains that when companies get this right, employees stay longer, are more engaged and make better decisions.
How long should an employee onboarding program last?
In this episode, Rhamy cites research showing that the best onboarding programs last at least 90 days, and many last as long as a full year. Rather than putting everything into a single day, he recommends thinking of onboarding in four phases:
- Pre-onboarding, between the accepted offer and day one
- First day essentials, with a structured agenda and early team involvement
- Building a foundation, in weeks one to four, with clear goals and regular check-ins
- Continuous development, from month one through month six and beyond, with ongoing training and feedback
At a minimum, he recommends scheduling check-ins at 30, 60 and 90 days. The overall goal is to turn an enthusiastic new hire into a trusted, competent professional who would make the same decisions you would, even without instruction.
What should employers do before a new hire's first day?
The period between an accepted offer and the start date is valuable, because no one will ever be more excited to work for you than on the day they accept. You cannot make them work during that time, but you can make sure they have what they need to hit the ground running. Steps from the episode include:
- Send a welcome email with everything they need to know
- Have their workspace, logins and tools ready
- Assign a buddy or mentor to guide them through the first few weeks
- Reach out before the start date just to welcome them
- Give access to material you would normally cover on day one so they can read it in advance
Rhamy notes that Facebook calls this the 45 minute rule, because new hires there can start contributing within an hour of arriving.
What should a new employee's first day include?
The first day covers the basics: introductions, paperwork and policies. But in this episode, Rhamy stresses that new hires need a structured agenda so they are never left wondering what to do next or how things work.
The first day should share the company's mission, culture and values and include introductions, lunches or other time with the team so the person feels part of the group. Just as important, get them working quickly. Even if a week of classroom training is ahead, they can join their team's morning meeting on day one to be introduced and see what everyone is working on. Short shadow sessions, even 30 minutes or an hour sitting with someone doing the work, help connect training to the real job.
What should the first month of onboarding focus on?
Weeks one to four are about building a foundation. In this episode, Rhamy recommends setting clear goals and performance expectations early, because whatever pace you want a new hire to run at is the pace they need to start at. Avoid two weeks of "just look around." Give them real projects with deadlines so they start running.
During this phase, schedule regular check-ins so they feel supported, and integrate them broadly into the organization. They should meet company leadership, their manager, their manager's manager and experienced coworkers. Encourage cross-team connections with people they will actually work with outside their own team. Specific performance goals for the first days, first week and first four weeks give them a track to run on; as they learn the company, they can start setting their own goals.
Why do new employees lose engagement around six months?
In this episode, Rhamy explains that employee satisfaction often dips around the six month mark. By then, new hires have moved past the period when everyone cuts them slack. Six months feels long enough that they should have the answers, so coworkers raise their expectations, and the employees raise their own expectations of themselves too.
To counter this, keep developing people well past the first few weeks. Gather feedback on what is working and what is confusing, and bring them into the fold on long-term vision, values and goal setting. Ongoing training also matters: Rhamy notes that companies that invest little in training often find someone a year and a half in who can still do only what they were hired to do, which is a missed opportunity.
What are the most common employee onboarding mistakes?
The episode names five:
- Treating onboarding like a checklist. Handing over a laptop and a handbook and asking for questions. Make it an ongoing process, not a one-day event.
- Information overload. Nobody wants to sit through eight hours of slides. Break training into bite-sized, interactive sessions mixed with shadowing or real work.
- No clear expectations. If employees do not know what success looks like, they flounder. Set specific performance goals for the first days, week and four weeks.
- Forgetting about culture. People join for the environment, not only the job. Connect them with mentors, teams and traditions, and tell stories that illustrate your core values.
- No follow-up after week one. Schedule 30, 60 and 90 day check-ins at a minimum.
How can technology improve the onboarding process?
In this episode, Rhamy argues that onboarding should be a repeatable, iterative process that can be tweaked over time, and technology makes that possible. A process run on paper and lots of one-on-one time can work, but it is hard to know what happened and hard to improve. His guidance is to keep a human touch for exceptions and automate the majority.
Practical steps include using an HR platform that centralizes paperwork and training so you are not chasing signatures, replacing long reading assignments with interactive learning modules in five, 15 or 30 minute chunks, and setting up a digital new hire hub that people can access as soon as they accept the offer. The result is fewer overwhelmed employees and a process you can improve step by step based on feedback.
About this episode
1 in 5 new hires quit before their first paycheck. But it’s not about salary. It’s your onboarding. Starting a new job can be rough if companies lack proper employee onboarding. In this episode of the Don't HR Alone podcast, Rhamy Alejeal reveals: • The biggest onboarding mistakes that drive away great hires • How to structure a 90-day onboarding plan that works • Why orientation is NOT onboarding — and what to do instead • The real cost of poor onboarding (and how to fix it with automation)
Don't lose another employee to chaos.
What You’ll Learn: ✅ The 4-phase onboarding plan that actually retains employees ✅ What to do before Day 1 to set up long-term success ✅ How to integrate culture, connection, and performance from day one ✅ Why most checklists fail — and what to do instead ✅ How technology + automation can save your HR team time and money


