Chapters
Don't HR Alone · Episode 60
When HR Ignores ADA: One Mistake, Big Consequences
Chapters (8)
An employee keeps clocking in late and missing shifts, and a frustrated manager is ready to start the paperwork for termination. In this episode, Rhamy explains why that moment can be one casual comment away from an ADA claim, and how to handle it instead.
The case comes from a distribution company with about 40 employees. A warehouse associate, called John in the episode, had been with the company for about a year when he began arriving late nearly every day and missed four shifts in six weeks. His manager was about to issue a final written warning. When the People Processes HR business partner asked whether anything had changed, the manager mentioned that John had said a week earlier that he had been diagnosed with diabetes and was struggling to stabilize while adjusting to insulin. There was no formal request, but Rhamy explains that a comment like that is enough to trigger the ADA interactive process.
Rhamy walks through what happened next: opening the conversation respectfully, focusing on how the condition affected the job rather than the diagnosis, requesting documentation from John's provider, and finding the accommodation he actually needed, which was a predictable start time. The company temporarily moved his shift start by an hour, documented every step and coached the supervisor on keeping accountability within ADA boundaries.
Three months later John returned to his regular schedule. The episode closes with low-cost accommodation examples and the systems that prevent these situations: manager training, unified leave processes, documentation and regular HR check-ins.
Key takeaways
- Treat any sign that a medical condition may be affecting job performance as the start of the ADA interactive process, even without a formal request.
- Pause discipline for attendance or performance issues long enough to ask whether anything has changed for the employee.
- Focus the conversation on how the condition affects essential job functions, not on the diagnosis itself.
- Ask the employee what they need to do the job, and consider simple changes such as a predictable start time.
- Document every interaction, form and change made during the interactive process.
- Train managers to recognize possible accommodation situations so they do not discipline someone for the effects of a disability.
When does the ADA interactive process start?
As soon as the employer becomes aware, formally or informally, that a medical condition may be affecting job performance. In this episode, Rhamy sums it up as: medical condition affecting job performance equals interactive process.
The employee does not have to say "I need a reasonable accommodation" or fill out a form. In the case Rhamy describes, a warehouse associate mentioned in passing, during a conversation about his tardiness, that he had recently been diagnosed with diabetes and was having trouble stabilizing his energy and schedule while adjusting to insulin. That casual comment started the clock. Rhamy warns that terminating the employee without going through the process would have been a lawsuit waiting to happen. The process may not change the outcome in every case, but the employer has to go through it in good faith.
Can I fire an employee for attendance problems caused by a medical condition?
Not without first going through the ADA interactive process. In this episode, Rhamy explains that employers must avoid disciplining or retaliating based solely on the effects of a disability. In the case he describes, a manager was ready to issue a final written warning to an employee who was late nearly every day and had missed four shifts in six weeks, unaware that the employee's recent diabetes diagnosis was behind it.
Had the manager gone ahead, Rhamy says the employee might have filed an EEOC complaint, the company could have faced a costly legal defense, a state agency or unemployment claim could have followed, and word would have spread that the company punishes health disclosures. Even a win would have been expensive. He notes he has seen settlements ranging from one or two years of salary to over a million dollars, plus legal fees. Accountability can continue, but within ADA boundaries.
How do you conduct the ADA interactive process with an employee?
In this episode, Rhamy describes the steps used for a client's warehouse associate:
- Open the door respectfully. For example: "You mentioned some health stuff going on. Are you doing okay? Is there anything we can do to support you at work?"
- Clarify the impact, not the diagnosis. The goal is not to play doctor but to understand how the condition affects essential job functions, here punctuality and attendance in a safety-sensitive setting.
- Request appropriate documentation from the employee's provider confirming the need for accommodation, without asking for every detail.
- Explore accommodations together by asking what the employee needs to do the job.
- Document everything, including every interaction, form and change.
- Coach the supervisor on maintaining accountability, tracking attendance going forward and when to check back in.
In this case, the answer was a predictable start time, not fewer hours.
Which employers are covered by the ADA?
Federally, employers with 15 or more employees. In this episode, Rhamy cautions that state laws can reach smaller employers, in some states as few as five employees, so a business with seven employees should still check its state rules.
The ADA protects anyone with a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity, or with a history of such an impairment or who is perceived as having one. Once aware of a potential disability, a covered employer must engage in the interactive process and consider and provide reasonable accommodations unless doing so would cause undue hardship. Rhamy notes that the larger the company, the harder the undue hardship argument becomes. He also points out that the government is not asking employers to torpedo their business, only to do what is reasonable, and that employers have a lot of room within the undue hardship standard.
What are examples of low-cost reasonable accommodations?
In this episode, Rhamy says most accommodations cost nothing or nearly nothing, and shares examples People Processes has helped implement:
- Letting an employee in recovery avoid closing shifts so they can attend a 12-step program
- Adjusting a workstation to avoid fluorescent lighting that triggered migraines
- Allowing light snacks at a desk for a diabetic employee, even where snacks are normally not allowed
- Modifying a uniform policy to allow orthopedic shoes
- Temporarily moving an employee's shift start by an hour to give a consistent schedule while he adjusted to new medication
In that last case, the employee's hours were not cut. He stabilized within three months, returned to his regular, more variable schedule and, as Rhamy tells it, returned to being the strong, reliable employee he had been before the issues began. Rhamy adds that accommodations like these support morale and help attract and retain good people.
How can employers prevent ADA violations?
Build a process before the issue arises. In this episode, Rhamy says most ADA violations come not from intentional discrimination but from untrained managers, reactive decisions and missing documentation. The common gray areas are a casual health comment that should have triggered the interactive process but did not, and a performance issue that masks a disability.
He recommends training managers and supervisors to recognize potential accommodation situations without violating privacy, running ADA, FMLA and state leave through one unified process, keeping audit trails, medical documentation and decision logs, and holding regular HR check-ins with leadership to surface issues before they escalate. A leader does not need to know every nuance of the law, but needs systems and partners who do. As Rhamy puts it, when it comes to the ADA, employers are judged on their process and documentation, not their intentions.
About this episode
One late clock-in. One casual health comment. That’s all it takes to trigger ADA compliance obligations. Most managers don’t realize they’re just one step away from a six-figure EEOC lawsuit.
In this episode of Don’t HR Alone, Rhamy Alejeal breaks down: - The ADA “interactive process” and when it must begin - Real-world case study: a diabetic employee and a near-termination disaster - Why documentation and manager training prevent lawsuits - Examples of reasonable accommodations that cost nothing


